The next morning, he turned over and looked around. Curiously, he looked down and saw that he still had on his boxers.
“Did I fucking dream that?” he wondered.
He looked down, under the cover, and saw that Erin was topless but wearing her panties. He sighed, quietly whispering a thank you and relaxed, listening to the sound of the shower. For a few minutes, he lay there, listening to the sound of someone washing off, wondering how exactly he could have dreamed something so real. The water stopped, and he heard someone hop out and start to towel off. The door opened and Jessie stepped out, smiling as he looked over at her.
“Good morning!” she said, smiling happily.
He chuckled, seeing that his bubbly morning girlfriend had woken up the other two.
“Ugh,” Alec said. “She’s like this in the morning too?” he asked.
Dex grinned, sitting up and looking over at Erin. She smiled, then slid from bed and went over to climb in with her true boyfriend and snuggled up to him, pulling him down to the bed with her and talking quietly.
He realized then that it had to be a dream. There was no way that she would have allowed something like that to happen. She was too sweet and caring. Breathing another sigh of relief as Jessie sat down next to him, he reached up and pulled her back to kiss him. With a cry of surprise and a giggle, Jessie turned and kissed him.
“I think we both did it, babe,” she said. “We both behaved ourselves.”
He smiled, nodding. “I had a dream I’ll have to tell you about sometime, but you’re right, we did.”
She grinned, kissing him again. The other couple was still talking quietly as Jessie and Dex kissed for a few moments, then Alec stood up, kissed Erin and told her he loved her, then headed to take a shower. Jessie grinned and kissed him a final time before jumping up and getting dressed.
Dex started to do the same, standing and electing not to take a shower until they got home. Jessie pulled on her shoes as he languished a bit, finally heading over and pulling his shorts up. A little later, the four of them gathered all their stuff and had breakfast in the hotel before all climbing into the truck and heading home.
Stopping for gas, Alec hopped out and started to fill up, Jessie sneaking over and popping her dad’s credit card in before Alec could protest. She giggled, then opened his door and said that she was going to run inside to go to the bathroom and asked if anyone needed anything.
Smiling, Dex shook his head, as did Erin, sitting in the back seat. Watching as Jessie went inside, he turned and smiled at Erin, who looked up and grinned at him.
“I really liked being able to sleep next to you last night,” he said.
She smiled, nodding. “It’s funny, I had a pretty kinky dream last night,” she said, smiling provocatively at him.
He froze, his eyes going wide as she spoke. “You… had a dream?”
She nodded. “I heard you telling Jessie about one that you had.”
He didn’t follow, and confusion showed on his face.
The door opened and Alec went popped his head in. “Going in for a drink. You need anything babe?”
She nodded, “Get me a drink,” she said.
He nodded, closing the door and turning to head inside.
“Erin… I had an intense dream that we…” he said, then saw her look up and smile widely. “Shit,” he whispered.
She smiled. “Relax Dexter,” she said. “It’s okay. I’m just messing with you. You were dreaming!”
He looked at her in surprise, then breathed out in intense relief. “Goddamn that was mean,” he said. “I thought I’d made us both cheat on Alec and Jessie.”
She giggled. “I figured you had a sex dream about us,” she said. “I woke up several times in the night and felt your ridiculous dick poking me in the most delightful spots.”
He smiled, seeing her close her eyes and wistfully recall the night before. “So, we didn’t actually…”
She grinned again, shrugging. “I had several, really dirty dreams about you last night. But… somehow we both had our underwear on this morning.”
Dex felt even more confused, and now he was wondering what the heck really happened.
Erin, obviously enjoying the torment that she was putting him through, giggled and shook her head at him. “Relax, handsome. If something did happen, it was only because the two of us were turned on and groggy, and we thought we were dreaming.”
He raised an eyebrow, looking back at her, thoroughly confounded.
“But… nothing did,” he stated.
She smiled, then shook her head. Still she had a curious, mischievous look on her face. Finally, she looked up, staring provocatively at him and biting her bottom lip as if she were trying to get him to leap over the seat and have sex with her then and there.
Jessie came back out and slid in the seat behind him, handing him a candy bar and a drink, though he hadn’t asked for anything.
“Thanks,” he said, shaking Erin’s confusion from his head.
She had to be screwing with him. He would have known if he really did have sex, and did he really think that the other two in the room wouldn’t have heard them? Smiling, he shook his head and glanced back at the blonde, who looked up and smiled infuriatingly at him. Turning, he looked at Jessie and eyed her suspiciously, checking to see if she was in on it.
His girlfriend smiled sweetly at him, then looked over at Erin in confusion.
“You okay?” she asked, looking back at him.
“I’m trying to figure that out,” he said.
“I heard him talk about the dream he had,” Erin said. “I’ve been playing with him a little.”
Jessie giggled. “How so?”
“Oh, you know, making him think we actually fooled around,” she said.
Dex looked back at her, then at Jessie again. “Y’all having fun?”
Jessie giggled. “No, but it sounds like you guys did.”
Erin laughed at that and Dex sighed and turned around.
Alec climbed in at that point, and nothing more was said. “Everyone ready?”
Not wanting to give him any clue that there was a little drama in the air, Dex smiled and nodded as he looked over.
“Let’s hit it!” Erin said, Jessie cheering with her.
“You nutballs know that we’re just heading home, right?” he asked.
The girls giggled, and then devolved into quite conversation between just the two of them.
Dexter knew better than to try and hear and went about fooling around on his phone until they’d gotten gossiping out of their systems. The trip passed easily, and by the time they pulled into Dexter’s house, he was ready to get out.
“Can I use your bathroom?” Erin asked.
“Oh, me too,” Jessie said.
“Yeah, feel free,” he replied. “Alec?”
“I’m good,” he said. “Hey, we gonna lift tomorrow night?”
“I should be free,” Dexter said. “But… you know Jessie.”
Alec nodded and fiddled with his phone a bit.
“I’m glad that you and I were able to handle the girls on the trip,” Dex said, unsure of how to word the statement.
Alec grinned, nodding. “Honestly, bro, I feel like I missed out on an opportunity.”
Dex smirked. “You probably did, dude.”
“Like, Jessie was right next to me, but hell no, I gotta be a heavy fuckin’ sleeper.”
Nodding, Dex smiled and shrugged. “Well, I appreciate you not doing anything,” he said.
Alec grinned and nodded. “Still, it was pretty fuckin’ hot watching y’all have sex.”
“Yeah, likewise,” Dex replied. “Erin’s a fuckin’ knockout man. Don’t let her get away from you and your stank ass.”
Laughing, Alec nodded. “Dude, she’s so out of my league.”
“Shit, I’m in the same boat,” he replied, smiling widely.
The two shared a laugh and then a nod of the head. With a pat on the shoulder, Dex got out and waved, then headed inside. As he stepped through the door, he saw that Jessie was apparently in the bathroom, and that his dad was probably upstairs in his bedroom office.
Erin smiled innocently at him.
“Mmmhmm,” he said. “Look… I’m not the quickest on the uptake. Did we or not?” he asked.
She smiled, shrugging. “Like I said, I had a pleasant dream. If something happened, it was an accident.”
“What did you tell Jessie?”
She smiled. “I told her that I had a vivid dream, then we talked about trying to get you two to play more.”
He sighed. “I feel like you aren’t telling me everything,” he said.
She giggled and moved up to him. “I know you aren’t ready to share Jessie,” she said, smiling and putting a hand on his chest. “To be honest, I don’t blame you. But… if you tell Alec that you and I actually fucked last night…”
Dexter’s eyes widened. “What?”
She smiled. “If you tell either of them, then the chances of him trying something with Jessie increase. Right?”
Dexter winced, realizing the dream was real.
“Dexter,” she said, poking him in the chest. “We don’t have a lot of time. The chances increase, right?”
He sighed, looking down at her. “Yes, I suppose.”
“Exactly. So, don’t tell them about what happened.”
He raised an eyebrow. “But… you just…” He exhaled slowly. “Erin…”
She smiled, looking up. “Dex, honey, I waited long enough to have what I wanted. I do all sorts of crazy stuff for Alec, and he can give me this one.” She smiled up at him infuriatingly and added, “even if he doesn’t know about it.”
“But…”
“Dex, I’m not trying to hurt anyone. I’m not stealing you from Jessie or trying to hurt my boyfriend, but come on… was pretty damn incredible, wasn’t it?”
He sighed, grudgingly admitting that it was.
“So… we’re both telling a couple of little white lies. I can keep a secret if you can. In the meantime, you can work on being able to share Jessie, and I might get to have you again sometime. Trust me, I know for a fact that it’s going to be okay.”