The animal brain part of him was all for it. He sighed again.
“I’m not going to come over and sneak into your window, stalk you, or like… creep into bed. It was a onetime thing,” she said. “We’re just covering it up.”
He nodded.
“You realize I’m lying for you, right? You’re the one that doesn’t want to share Jessie more. You’re only not telling her because Alec will want to take advantage of the situation.”
He nodded again. “I know. I get it, it just… makes me feel like I’m really fuckin’ selfish.”
She smiled. “It should,” she said, smiling and turning to walk to the door. “She’s incredible,” she said, stopping as she reached the door and turning around.
He sighed, walking over and opening the door to walk her out.
“You know, we didn’t use a condom last night,” she whispered, smiling up at him as they walked toward Alec’s truck.
Dexter looked at her, shaking his head.
“I don’t even let Alec have me without a condom. You’re little guys have been in me all night.”
Sighing, he raised an eyebrow and smirked at her.
“Seriously though,” she said. “That was the best time I’ve ever had. Ever.”
He smiled, nodding. “It was one for the record books for sure.”
She winked, then turned and walked around to the other side of the truck.
Heading back in, he looked around for Jessie but didn’t see her. Heading upstairs, he saw her down at the end of the hallway, apparently listening to his dad.
She turned, waving him over as she noticed him, holding up a finger to her lips for him to be quiet. Raising an eyebrow, he did as she asked and quietly went up to her and listened. He heard a curious noise coming from his dad’s room and began to walk much quieter. Realizing what he was hearing, he felt his heart breaking. His dad was crying.
“I know,” he said. “I’m just so damn lonely.” He sounded like he was talking to someone on the phone. “It feels like an obvious thing, but I just want someone that’s not a complete nutcase, you know?”
Whoever he was talking to was saying something long and drawn out, and Dex quietly waited next to Jessie, listening to the sad sniffles from the safety of the hallway.
“Jesus, Susie,” he said. “You didn’t just ask me that.”
Susie was his dad’s little sister. He must have called her, needing to talk.
“I know… but it’s not every day that you get asked about your sex life by your little sister. I know you’re concerned.”
“I…”
“Well…”
He stammered, being interrupted several times. “I had a one-night stand a while ago,” he said. “It was… incredible, but it can’t happen again.”
“It’s complicated,” he added a few seconds later. “She’s with someone else.”
Susie was talking for a while after that, and they heard conversational noises coming from his dad.
“Well, I appreciate you making me feel better. Tell Joe I said hey and kiss the kiddos for me. Okay… love you too. Bye.”
Jessie quickly took his hand and went back to Dexter’s room, padding silently down the hall.
“Babe, we’ve got to do something,” she said, frowning, her eyes rimmed with tears. “That was heartbreaking!”
Dex nodded.
“I hear him sometimes at night, upset or talking to mom. I just don’t know what to do anymore.”
She frowned, hugging Dexter quickly and kissing him on the cheek. “Well, is he lonely or just horny?”
Dexter couldn’t answer that, of course. He couldn’t read his mind. “I’m not sure.”
“Who is Susie?” she asked, looking up at him.
He focused on her for a second. “Hm? Oh, my Aunt, his little sister.”
She nodded and then fell silent for a few seconds. “As I see it, the problem is simple. He needs a woman. He needs someone that can hang out with him and have fun; someone that likes sex and isn’t judgmental but isn’t taken.”
There was a quiet pause while they tried to figure out who that might be, and then she looked up at him.
“Let me go and talk to my family tonight. Maybe my mom knows some single women that aren’t crazy.”
He nodded. “I’ll drive you home.”
Jessie smiled, then tiptoed downstairs with him as they headed for his vehicle. Preoccupied with what he was going to do about his father, he completely spaced and forgot about the trouble with Erin.
As they pulled in, Jessie smiled and leaned over to kiss him. “I promise it will be okay, baby,” she said. “We’ll figure it out.
Dexter smiled, nodding. “Call me later, okay?”
She smiled, nodding. “I will! Love you! Get a nap!”
“I love you,” he said, then smiled and watched as she walked up the stairs. Still smiling, he turned and headed for home.
*****
Jessie
Stepping into her apartment, she went to her room and put her things down, then stripped out of the dirty clothes she was wearing and turned to leave the room. Smiling at her from the doorway, Donna had quietly come in and was watching.
“Whoa… hey creepy,” Jessie said.
“Hey,” she said. “How was the trip?”
“Good. We had fun at the park and even switched boyfriends for the day. Dex and Erin are pretty timid about the big rides, so Alec and I went and rode a bunch together.”
“Sounds like a blast. Did y’all have a big orgy when you got back to the hotel?”
Jessie giggled. “No, silly. We did sleep in different beds though. Alec and I took one bed, but it wasn’t any big deal because he just went to sleep.”
“Boring,” Donna said. “Erin and Dex get up to any trouble?”
Jessie giggled, grinning. “Earlier, she said she was going to try and get him to have sex with her at some point during the night. Then, on the trip home, she admitted that she’d been successful.”
“Oh really?” Donna asked, stepping aside as Jessie moved past her and went toward the bathroom. “Shower?” she asked.
Jessie nodded her head in confirmation, then smiled as Donna led the way. As they headed into the bathroom, the brunette reached into the shower and turned on the water for her, then stepped back.
“She said that they were pretty intimate during the night, and that she’d woken up to Dex’s big ole hard cock and couldn’t help herself. It was ridiculous though, she actually apologized!”
Donna smirked. “A friend of yours apologized for fucking your boyfriend! How weird,” Donna said, deadpan.
Jessie giggled. “I’m serious. You know that I love to get my boyfriend laid!”
“You’re so fucking crazy,” she replied, smirking.
“Gonna join me?” Jessie asked, reaching in and testing the water.
Donna smiled, immediately starting to strip. Jessie giggled.
After a moment to let herself get used to the water, Jessie turned and moved back as Donna joined her. Unable to keep her hands to herself, she reached up and playfully squeezed her roommate’s big breasts.
“So, you and Alec didn’t do anything?”
Jessie shook her head. “It’s a weird situation with those two. I think he cheated on her in the past, but I can’t be sure. I know he wants to have a threesome with her and I, but in return, she gets to have another guy. I don’t know if that means Alec and another guy, or just the other guy.”
“She’s obviously had her sights set on Dex,” Donna said. “Are you going to let Alec have his threesome now?”
Jessie felt her taller, stronger roommate spin her around and begin to wash her off with some soap and a loofah. Having no choice but to acquiesce, she did so happily, her roommate busily scrubbing her down while they talked.
“She admitted to me on the way home that she was going to tell Dex to keep it a secret, so I promised I’d play along. He’s such an honest guy though, I give it a day before he’s all apologetic and worried that I’m going to be angry.”
Donna smirked, shaking her head as Jessie looked back. Movement outside the shower caught their attention and they both turned to see John step in, smiling. He was naked, of course, and stepped past them to go and use the restroom.
“So, she’s keeping the secret from Alec so that he doesn’t get to have you?”
“I guess,” Jessie said. “I’m not really too concerned about it.”
Donna spun Jessie back around and washed the front, then smiled as John poked his head in. “Come on in, babe,” she said. “You can have the backside.”
“Hell yeah,” John said, grinning widely.
“She didn’t say my backside,” Jessie said, giggling as he stepped in behind her, kissing her neck and nestling his yummy erection up against her butt crack as he gripped her hips.
“So, what are you going to do if Alec does find out, and Dex isn’t okay with it?” Donna asked.