He came back over to her and kneeled. “I never stopped trusting you, babe,” he whispered. “And I never will.”
She felt her heart leap up into her throat, and she pulled him down for a kiss, whispering an “I love you” to him before watching him crawl into bed.
Smiling happily, she closed her eyes and drifted off to sleep.
**
The next morning, she yawned, stretching and looking around as light poured in through the window. Grumbling, she slid out of bed and glanced at her boyfriend and their friends, seeing that they were still asleep.
Alec was practically still in the same position that he fell asleep in, and she giggled as she pulled the curtain closed. Erin and Dexter were snuggled up to each other adorably, her boyfriend’s arm over her, and her nose nuzzling his chest.
“So cute,” she whispered, blowing a kiss to him. She smiled to herself, realizing then that she’d done it. She’d spent the night in the bed of another man and hadn’t acted on her baser urges. Sure, they’d both been comatose, but it was a win and she was going to count it.
Smiling, she went to the bathroom and started to get ready to head home, wondering if Erin had been successful with her plan.
*****
Dexter
the previous night…
As he lay there in bed, Dex looked over several times and wondered if Jessie was really going to behave herself. He was a relatively deep sleeper, but he figured that it wasn’t so deep that he wouldn’t hear someone doing… something in the same room he was in.
He shook his head, forcing the thoughts from his head and focusing on the fun day that he’d had with his girlfriend and some good people. The park had been fun, Erin had been awesome to hang with, and they’d just had sex in the same room as another couple. Again, he was forced to realize what a lucky guy he was.
Listening to Erin in the shower, he closed his eyes, picturing her nude form with water running down it in rivulets. Sighing, he shook the scandalous thoughts from his head and fought to stay awake, at least so that he could say good night to her.
A few minutes passed, and finally the water was turned off. It was another ten minutes before she emerged, turning out the light and then coming around to her side of the bed. Smiling, she grinned at him as she saw Jessie asleep in bed next to Alec.
“Again, I gotta ask, are we sure that’s a good idea?” she whispered.
He chuckled, shrugging. “They’ve been pretty good so far.”
She smiled, nodding. “They have,” she agreed.
She stared at him curiously for a minute, then reached up and untucked the towel from between her breasts, letting it drop and smiling as he looked up and admired her nudity. Winking, she reached over and turned out the light, plunging the room into darkness. His eyes hadn’t adjusted when she pulled the cover back and slid in. Her butt was certainly a wake-up call when he felt her scoot it against him.
“Ugh, you’re actually wearing boxers?” she asked. “I think of the four of us, we’re much more careful and trustworthy than they are.”
He chuckled. “I just don’t want to poke you in the eye in the morning,” he said, drawing a quiet laugh.
“Come on,” she said. “Just slip them off for a while. I’ve been wanting to feel your warm skin on mine. I promise, we’ll be good.”
He smiled in the darkness, then began to fumble around and managed to pull his underwear off.
“Mmm, now warm up my butt and feet,” she said, giggling quietly.
He sighed, smirking in the blackness as the rhythmic breathing of their roommates reached their ears in the stillness. He was surprised to feel her reach back and pull his arm over her. Taking that as an invitation, he pulled her tight up against him, his cock sliding nicely down her butt crack.
“Just be careful,” she whispered, “if I wake up with that in my ass, there’s going to be some tough questions,” she said, giggling quietly again.
He snickered, pulling her tighter and trying not to thrust against her.
“You feel pretty incredible,” he whispered.
“Yeah?” she asked. “What do you like about how I feel?”
He sighed, smiling. “How much time do I have?” he asked. “I like this curve of your hips,” he said, running a finger down her side and the womanly arch. “I really like how soft your skin is, and how it always smells incredible.”
“Always smells?” she whispered.
“Yeah,” he admitted. “It’s intoxicating. It’s hard not to notice.”
She snickered. “That might be the sexiest thing I’ve ever heard.”
He chuckled. Drawing her closer and gently squeezing. “Goddamn you feel incredible,” he said, breaking a few moments of comfortable silence.
“You’re what feels incredible,” she whispered.
He sighed happily, fighting the very real urge to kiss her neck, turn her over, and take her then and there.
“Dex,” she whispered.
“Hmm?” he replied.
“Thanks for being mine today,” she said.
He smiled, relaxing and nuzzling the back of her neck a bit before sleep slowly crept up on him.
**
Several hours later, he awoke and got up quietly to go to the bathroom. Sitting down in a decidedly unmanly fashion so that he wouldn’t make as much noise, he relieved himself and then closed the door, sliding back into bed after casting a glance over at the other side of the room at Jessie and Alec. They looked like they were in the same positions that they’d been in before.
Re-fluffing his pillow, he lay his head down on it and let sleep take him again. As he snoozed, he was surprised to feel Erin turn over, pulling herself tight up against him. Feeling her soft skin against his was incredibly exciting, and she must have sensed what she was doing to him. Whimpering, she reached up and pulled his face down, kissing him softly.
Below the covers, her soft, warm hand slid down the flat of his stomach and gripped the thick girth of his cock as he grunted softly and felt an erection coming on quickly. Moving up, she kissed him on the lips, whimpering as quietly as she could, one hand clutching at him as if he were going to go away.
She apparently slid off the bed, and he wondered for a moment what she was going to do, until he felt the sheet move and then her warm lips sliding over the head of his cock.
“Fuck,” he thought, shaking his head.
Erin’s mouth was incredible, sliding down his shaft and sucking as hard as she could, her tongue seemingly painting every inch that it could with a loving coat of saliva and drool.
Wiggling her face back and forth, he felt her grip both of his ass cheeks and pull, wriggling again and again as she tried to take him deep. Coming up for air, she immediately moved back into the position that she’d been in, only this time she pulled him hard against her, her hand reaching down and pulling him between her legs.
He groaned, his head swimming and part of him wondering if it was a pleasant dream that he was having, the other part screaming at him to get on with fucking her. She lifted her leg and kept pulling at him as she kissed his neck. His mushroom head was just at her entrance and he couldn’t help but acquiesce, rolling over and sliding on top of her as he kissed her on the lips, her tongue almost desperate to be in his mouth.
Her hand reached down and found his arm, pulling it up and placing it on her bare breasts, enticing him to grope and fondle her. Her arms moved, sliding around his waist as she quietly but forcefully pulled at him. It was too much, and he finally thrust, pushing the head of his cock against her slit, sliding it excruciatingly up the front. He’d missed, but the head of his cock slid nearly inside and then up across her clit, forcing him to retract and then pull back a little more before thrusting again and finally sliding deep inside of her.
A quiet whimper came from her, and she pulled him tightly up against her and groaned, clutching at him as he slid completely in. Her pussy was sopping, and she was incredibly tight. He couldn’t believe how amazing she felt. The full length of his shaft was encased in her tight, wet flesh, and the two lay there in silence, desperately wanting to continue but both knowing how inappropriate they were being. As he stared at her face, trying to force himself to roll off her, he saw the arousal and desire in her eyes and thrust the slightest bit, causing her to whimper in pleasure. Resorting to kissing him, she nodded, pulling at him to keep him fucking her.
As quietly and as softly as he could, he slowly slid his cock into her, his hands mauling her soft breasts as he did so. As he reached the limit, he retracted, forcing himself to go slowly, silently, and trying not to make a sound.
The dim light of the room was just enough to see, and he broke the kiss, feeling her desperate pulls getting more frantic. Staring down, he watched as she started to cum, her eyes never leaving his as her entire pussy shuddered on his cock. She whimpered, shivering violently, her legs quivering as he watched, his cock completely buried in her and holding steady. He couldn’t believe how quickly she’d gotten there, and how intense her orgasm looked. Clutching desperately at him, he felt the pulsing wave of contractions rippling up and down her tight, wet little pussy. Her flesh squeezed his cock, as if it were trying to draw him in deeper inside and keep him there.
Soon, her breathing and desperate clutching and kissing at him slowed. Finally, she reached up and pulled the back of his head down for a kiss, the other hand pulling at his back and sliding his cock all the way in.
Movement on the other side of the room caught his attention, and he silently mouthed, “Shit,” at her.
Her eyes went wide, and she looked over, seeing Alec sit up and scratch his head.
Dex silently slid to the side as she faced away from him, the two moving quietly apart. Alec stumbled groggily past the bed and went to piss. She briefly turned her head and kissed him, then scooted back up against him, nestling his shaft in her butt crack again.
Both froze as the toilet flushed and the bathroom door opened. Alec made his way over to Erin, leaning over and kissing her on the forehead. He paused there for a second, then turned stumbling over to the other bed and sliding back in.
For a long time, Dex didn’t move, and was surprised to see that Erin had fallen asleep. Sighing and quietly realizing that he was the one that wasn’t to be trusted, he fell asleep.