Holding my cock straight, I pushed it up between her legs and slid inside of her. She groaned in pleasure and lost the strength to keep herself on her knees and sunk down onto me, stuffing more of my cock deep into her pussy.
I held her waist and rolled her over on the bed so I was on top, between her legs. I looked down at her, drawing my cock back before sliding it in. She exhaled loudly in pleasure
“God, fuck, that’s amazing,” she said. “Oh, you have an amazing cock, Daddy.”
I drew it out again, keeping just the tip between her dripping pussy lips. “You want me to push it back in?”
“Yes!”
“The truth then, did you lie to me tonight?”
She bit her lip hard. “Push it in deep. I’ll answer but only if you’re deep inside of me.”
I pushed it in deep, nice and hard, and her nails dug into my shoulders as she moaned out. “Oh, god, yes!”
“Answer,” I said sternly, “or I’ll take it out and it’s never coming back.”
She swallowed, catching her breath. “Yes, I lied.”
I withdrew my cock, almost out of her. “Those four boys didn’t fuck you tonight, did they?”
She pinched her eyes shut. “I don’t have to answer. You took it out.”
I rammed it back in harder. Her back arched and her legs closed around me. “Fuck! God, you’re in me so deep!”
“Answer!” I snapped.
“No, they didn’t. I lied, I’m sorry.”
I started to pull out.
“Wait!” she cried. “Wait, don’t take it away, please.”
“You said all this just trick me into fucking you?” I asked, my cockhead nearly slipping out of her.
She whimpered and cried. “I’ll only answer with your cock in me.”
I pushed my cock back in, my long shaft spearing through her warm red swollen pussy. Even I couldn’t help from moaning in pleasure once my log was back in her fire. “Tell me the truth.”
“Okay,” she said breathlessly. “Just… need a second.”
I made my cock throb while I was deep in her but didn’t remove it and she squirmed.
“Daddy…”
“Answer me.”
“Okay,” she said. “I staged it. I wanted you to find me like that.”
I started to pull out again. “Why?”
“Oh, more cock,” she said. “More cock or I’ll lie.”
I stuffed it back into her, angrily this time. “I want answers!”
“Oh, fuck,” she cried. “Okay, god, why do you think? I wanted you to fuck me.”
I withdrew, looking down at my cock hugged by her pussy lips, stretching her. “There are easier ways to get me in bed. Did you have to scare me with all this, make me think you’d been used and abused?”
She frowned at me. “In or no answer.”
“Karla, this is serious.”
“In!”
I pushed back in and we moaned together. I was happy for the excuse of pumping my fat cock in and out of her warm little pussy, but I wanted answers. “Tell me the truth.”
“Promise you won’t stop fucking me,” she said. “Promise you’ll cum in me. Then I’ll tell you everything.”
I pulled my cock back, only to push it in again, not for the truth this time, just because I needed it. “Fuck, I promise. I can’t stop fucking you now anyway. I need to cum, so tell me the truth.”
“God that feels good,” she said with heavy breath.
“Karla, focus,” I said, not helping her focus by pushing my cock in and out of her, but at least I was going slow enough that we weren’t fucking like animals, not yet anyway.
“Uhmm,” she said. “Okay, it wasn’t all a lie. It did happen, just not exactly like that. It was a week ago. Everything was the truth, but they uncuffed me afterward, and I had to clean up the house, the sheets, my body, my pussy, all of it.”
I was stunned as I stared into her eyes in the dark of the night. “Baby, really? That’s the truth?”
“Yes, and it was eating me up, no one knowing. I had to tell you, somehow.”
“You had to tell me like this?”
She grasped my face, her thumbs in my cheeks, brushing my stubble. “Yes, Daddy. You’re supposed to be my hero. You’re supposed to save me. That’s a daddy’s job. I wanted you to come home and save me so much, but you weren’t there. They just kept fucking me one after the other for so long, and all I wanted was my daddy, but you didn’t come. You never even knew.”
I wrapped my arms around her, holding her as I kept my cock buried in her pussy. “I’m sorry.”
“I wanted to tell you. I just didn’t know how. All I could think to do was recreate it, and let you find me and save me when you came home.”
I kissed her forehead. “Saving you is tricking me into fucking you?”
She kissed my cheek. “I wasn’t lying about why I want you to cum in me. I don’t know if I’ll be pregnant, my period isn’t for a couple weeks, but if I do get pregnant, I want to believe it’s yours.”
I kissed her lips, and I gently rocked my cock in and out of her. She moaned into my mouth.
“Oh, Daddy,” she said.
Her legs were nice and wide, welcoming me as I began pumping in and out of her pussy with my long cock. I looked into her eyes, watching pleasure flutter in her eyes. I wanted to give her pleasure. I wanted her to experience what it was like to make love, not just get fucked like a dog. I kissed her again, and our lips caressed each other.
“You feel so good, babygirl.”
“You really like my pussy, Daddy?” she asked, groaning while I was inside of her.
“Fuck yes.”
“Leo said I was a boring fuck. He said all I did was lay and take it. Like, what did he expect me to do? I was exhausted. He was so rude, after everything I gave them. They didn’t even say thank you.”
I held my hand to her cheek. “Forget them. They don’t matter. None of them matter.”
She stretched her neck to kiss my lips. “Daddy, can I show you I can fuck? Can I be on top a little?”