“This was still in the living room?”
“Yeah, but after the panties came off, I stopped sucking Leo’s cock. I figured, let me at least try to slow it down, so I stood up and I said, like, ‘okay, let me just suck your cock until you cum.’ But Ralph had this look in his eyes, like he wanted pussy, and he knew he was going to get it. He came right at me. I backed away, but he practically chased me into my bedroom. They were all there, except Mike was the slowest. He was like, ‘come on, guys, leave her alone.'”
“The kid who came in 2 seconds?”
“Yeah. So Ralph was kissing me, and his hand was on my pussy, and he pushed me down into the bed. Don tore my skirt off and then I was just 100 percent naked, and I knew there was no way out of this, but I was kind of excited. My pussy was soaked, and I liked Leo, Don was really sexy, and Ralph was so dominant. I mean, getting fucked by all four scared me, but I led them on, you know? It’s my fault.”
“They were pigs that smelled truffles. Don’t blame yourself.”
“Thanks, I think,” she said.
“This is when they handcuffed you?”
“Yes.”
“Where did the handcuffs come from?”
“Huh?”
“Where did they get them?”
“Oh, um, I think Ralph had them already.”
“An 18-year-old high school boy walks around with handcuffs?” I said doubtfully.
“Okay, okay,” she said. “They were mine.”
“How did you get them?”
She focused on petting my cock for a moment. “I told a friend of mine that I thought it was really kinky and sexy if a boy handcuffed a girl and fucked her. So for my birthday, she gave me a pair of handcuffs as, like, a joke gift. And when I was with the boys, we were talking and flirting, and I mentioned it. One of them asked to see them, so I showed them, and they were playing with them.”
“Hmm,” I mumbled. I was still trying to reconcile this story with what really happened, what was fact and what was fiction. Maybe it was all true, even though her details didn’t line up. Maybe she just remembered a few things incorrectly. Maybe the fake cum was real but maybe the real cum was real too. Or maybe not. “Go on.”
“So I was handcuffed and fucked. I didn’t even see who fucked me first,” she said. “I was too busy with whoever’s cock was in my mouth. There were two, both fucking my face, and they were blocking my view. I remember there was a lot of pain from the penetration. I tried to cry out, but I was just gagging on cock. Someone else was holding open my legs, and I felt completely helpless.”
“I’m sorry,” I said.
“It’s okay, Daddy,” she said softly, her fingers gently massaging my mushroom cockhead. “Whoever fucked me first came pretty soon, and then I heard them arguing to hurry up, because someone else wanted to fuck me. And then I had a gooey cummy cock in my mouth, and someone else was stuffing my pussy with a fresh cock.”
“They came in your pussy without even warning you?”
“Yeah,” she said. “I mean, it wasn’t all bad. It was sexy, and I really liked tasting the cum on the boys’ cocks after they fucked me and came in me. Even Mike fucked me, but I don’t remember if he came or not, because he’d already cum. Pretty sure he did.”
“And then what happened?”
“It was like an hour long fucking between all four of them, and I remember Ralph especially wanted more, even after he’d already fucked me and cum in my pussy once. I saw him watching me from one side, stroking his cock while I sucked off another boy, and I could tell he was going to stick it back in me, and he did. I think he even shoved whoever was between my legs out of the way. He wanted more pussy and no one was going to stop him.”
“What a little fucking asshole.”
“Yeah, but it motivated the others, because they all wanted turns again too. After they’d just cum, they weren’t as hard, but they each fucked for so much longer because they couldn’t cum again right away, so my pussy was just wrecked by the time they finished with me.”
I sighed. “They fucked the hell out of you.”
“Yeah,” she said, giving my cock a nice long stroke.
“And then what happened?”
“Well, that was kind of it,” she said, smiling at me in the dark. “But that’s why I want you to fuck me.”
“I would have thought you’d been fucked enough for one day,” I said, though I was still suspicious if she’d really been fucked at all, except by her own dildo.
“It’s because they all came in my pussy,” she said. “I’m scared I’ll get pregnant, and I don’t want their baby. If I have to have a baby, I want your baby, a little brother or sister I can take care of.”
I was stunned. “Wha… Sweetie, that’s not how it works.”
“Is so,” she said. “You’re my daddy, so your cum is better than theirs. At least if you cum in me, I can always believe it’s your baby, not theirs.”
I was very confused now, because this seemed like a strange rationale for me to fuck her, not that I needed much motivation at this point, but if she was making it all up, I needed to understand why.
“What else happened with the boys?” I asked.
“What do you mean?”
“After they fucked you and came all over you.”
“They left.”
“And the cuff key?”
“Oh, yeah they were joking and saying where should they put it, and Leo said in my pussy, and they did, and left, and you came home a couple of hours later.”
“Did they know I’d be home?”
“I don’t know, why does it matter?” she asked.
“Because you could have died, starved to death. Seems a bit reckless for boys just having fun with you.”
“Oh. Well, I don’t know. I guess they didn’t think about that.”
She gave my cock another stroke and then gave me a smile. She turned her head and kissed my lips.
“So,” she said, “can I put it in?”
“You really want my cock in your pussy, my cum too?” I asked her.
She nodded. “Yes, Daddy.” She sat up on her knees, maneuvering to straddle me. My cock pointed right up at her pussy. I took hold of my dick and grabbed her ass cheek to control her.
“I’ll make you a deal.”
“A deal?” she asked, looking down at my cock an inch away from her warm pussy lips. She wanted that cock inside her so badly, I thought she’d grab it and impale herself before I could finish speaking.
“Yes. I’ll put my cock in you, nice and deep, and fuck you good and proper, but—”
“But what?’ she said, licking her lips.
“But if I do, you have to promise to tell me the truth.”
She bit her lip nervously. “The truth?”
“Yes. If I put my cock inside of you, like you want, you have to tell me the truth.”
I could hear her taking a few quick breathes. “You’re going to ask me questions while you fuck me?”
“Yes.”
“What if you don’t like the answers? Are you going to take it out?”
“Is there something that would make me want to take it out?”
She gulped. “As long as you don’t stop fucking me, I promise to tell you whatever you want.”
“Not whatever I want,” I said, my cockhead sliding across her wet pussy lips. “The truth.”
“Okay,” she said. “I’ll do it, anything, just fuck me.”
“Promise?” I said, rubbing my cockhead against her clit.
“I promise,” she said quickly. “Stop teasing me. Please, Daddy, put it in.”