Chapter 41 “We don’t deserve her”

Book:The Wallflower and The Alphas Published:2025-4-2

Elijah P. O. V.
Damn, that was a good hit I thought in my mind when I grab my jaw. I know my jaw is strong and it is like a brick wall but when someone can hit me like Jake Stone. Well, you know pain is coming him and I and our friends are tough mother fucker.
“Fuck man!” I groaned and shook my face I stared over at him, and he still has that stupid angry look on his face. If looks can kill yeah, I would be dead by now by just his stare.
“Why you got start now Jake,” I told him with a little irritated in my voice.
“Why, why, he was pulling on his hair when he was walking around outside in the parking lot, he’s not looking over at me and he is pacing back and forth speaking in a low voice and we didn’t leave yet. But I need to get us out of here before Jake does something really stupid like last year. I am not going to speak about how crazy he acts when someone tries to ask out Avery. Yes, I knew I was her mate in the past two years now. But I had to wait until she knew I was her mate. But this year I found out Jake my best friend was her mate too. I heard of she wolfs getting two mates but only if the guy is bisexual and I know I am not but when I look over at Jake. I wonder is he bisexual. When I thought that Jake looks at me with a disgusting look on his face.
“D-o-n-t fucking thinking about!” He said with gritted his teeth when he read my mind. I let out a breath and I thought that was a relief because I am hell not fucking faggot. I wanted to puke and the look on Jake’s face he did too.
“You got that right, I am no fucking faggot either” I heard him chuckle, inside my mind. Then my wolf started growling at Axe.
“Hey! I wanted to fuck her pussy!” He told Jake wolf.
“Hey! You had her earlier, it’s my turn” Axe said back.
“Well, I umm he didn’t finish his words because there is a voice I never heard before until now. I think her other side and she sounds beautiful. We both just found out she had another half inside Avery.
I guess they are having a little fun with Avery she wolfs, and I hear another voice inside my mind. She sounds angelic
“Hey Axe, you can have me,” she said with a breathless voice.
Oh, fuck! We need to take her somewhere to talk to her before her party, but I know if we are alone with her, she won’t make it to the party intact virgin. We already wanted to wait until she founds out, we are her mate, and she wants us back. But I know it’s going to be a lot for her to realize that the boys she grew up with teased and bullied her are her mates.
It’s happening me and Jake looked at each other and we heard a soft voice speaking and when I knew it was Avery. I put her in the truck and laid her softly down in the backseat because she was still in my arms. I felt her wiggling and talking in her sleep. But what she said turned me the fuck on.
“Oh, yes right there Elijah and Jake”
“I need you both!” she said with a breathless moan.
Fuck! I looked at her beautiful face after I laid her down. I started caressing her cheeks and I was moving up my finger toward her mouth, and to my surprise, she started licking and sucking it inside her mouth.
Fuck I said with a groan and I wasn’t the only one watching her. I look over at Jake and he already staring at her with heat and fire in his eyes.
Damn it! Seeing her with her tongue licking and sucking on my finger and she still asleep and didn’t even wake up and the other thing is Axel and Axe fucking our mate’s other half and feeling their reaction fucking the shit out of them she wolfs.
Fuck! I pulled my hand inside my hair and pulled on it because I am torn between wrapping our clothes off and fucked the shit out of our mate or stopping this and taking her home. Her parents have no idea she was in the hospital because we asked the nurse and the front desk not to.
We knew it wasn’t serious so, we didn’t tell her parents and her friends, but we did tell our friends to keep the girl’s company I thought with a cocky grin. Jake and I knew how Jayson and Eli feelings about the other nerd wallflowers in the school. I see they like to stare and tease the poor girls.
I shook up my head and chuckled and Jake looked over at me and I saw his face. We both knew we would be so fucked because Moon Goddess gave us a girl we hated since we were little and we always teased her, pull her hair, and trip her in school when she walked by us, and she would spill her paint in kindergarten and threw high school. But it all changed when she became so beautiful and perfect for me and Jake.
I let out a breath and wanted to kick my ass for being mean to the prettiest and perfect wonderful girl for me.
“Ugh, fuck!” I let out a groan I felt Avery hit me in my face she now squirming around in the seat, and she mumbles under her breath.
“No, please, don’t hurt me,” she said with tears coming down her face. I am staring down at this pure innocent creature. I am staring at her with sadness because of how I treated her over the years. God, I am so stupid and now my chest it is feeling like someone stabbed me with a knife because I know she will reject me now when she finds out I am her soulmate, and I am supposed to keep her safe and love her not hurt her. I hope she gives me a chance and if she does, I am going to spend the rest of my life making up for her and maybe she falls in love with me like I am with her. But what I heard made me catch my breath in my throat.
“I love you, Elijah and Jake, please don’t break my heart again?” What? I thought she didn’t mean what she said. She loves me I mean us. But before I got out of the truck I look over at Jake and I see his eyes are red. I felt wetness running down my cheek and the last time I ever cried was when I saw James Watson kissing her on the cheek in second grade. I remember like yesterday I ran home crying in my room the whole day and after I stop crying, I started getting angry at her. I told myself ever since that day I became her bully.
“I don’t deserve her,” I said with tears running down my cheeks. I didn’t hear Jake, but I saw him nod with tears streaming down his cheeks too.