“Do you love me?” she said.
“Of course.”
“Do you trust me?”
“Yeah, but…”
“I love you and trust you, too. Look Mike, I’m going to tell you something in confidence, okay? You can’t tell anyone else. This morning when you noticed my… wet spot…”
“Yeah?”
She took a deep breath. “It was because I was horny.”
I stared at her. “Okay,” I said.
“Mike… I was aroused… by you. What you did out there, just picking that guy up like he was nothing, your muscles all bulging and straining, and then pinning him to the ground for the win… it did something to me. Maybe because I saw you naked and hard this morning, and saw you…”
“Let’s not talk about that,” I said.
“Let’s do talk about it,” she said. “Do you think I’m pretty, Mike?”
“Yes.”
“Say it.”
“You’re gorgeous, Kait.”
She grinned. “And do you think I’m sexy?”
“I try not to think of you that way, Kait.”
“Does that mean that sometimes you do think about me that way?”
I took a deep breath. “Yeah. Sometimes I do.”
Her grin widened. “Yeah, I’ve seen the way you look at me. Mostly at my tits.” She reached down and before I realized what was happening she had pulled the tank top over her head and tossed it onto the floor. My mouth hung open as, for the first time ever, her beautiful naked breasts were on display in front of me. Then she stood up and faced away from me and wriggled out of her boxers, showing me her fine, tight ass. Then she turned towards me again and I couldn’t help but stare at her lovely little hairless mound.
“Taa-daa!” she said.
“Kaitlyn!” I said.
“Seems only fair after I saw you naked this morning,” she said, and climbed back onto the bed. She poured more oil onto her hand and went back up into my groin, but this time every once in a while instead of just rubbing one of my balls with the back of her hand as she massaged the top of my leg, she alternated between doing that and rubbing the palm of her hand over my entire ball sack. It felt wonderful.
“Kait,” I groaned.
“Just enjoy,” she said, and moved her hand so that her palm rubbed across the base of my cock.
“Oh, God,” I groaned.
“Tight fit,” she said, removing her hand. Then she shocked me by reaching into the fly of my boxers and fishing out my hard cock.
“Woah – nice,” she said as she stroked it from base to tip. “You have a really nice cock, Mike.”
It felt amazing and while I didn’t want her to stop, she was my sister.
“Kait, think about this.”
“I have been thinking about this,” she said as she poured more oil. “All morning.” When she started smearing the baby oil onto my erection, it felt so fucking good that I stopped worrying about the fact that I was her brother. She jacked me slowly, using a twisting motion when she approached the head of my cock on the upstroke. Jesus, she was good at this. It felt a thousand times better than when I did it myself.
She was staring at her hand moving up and down on my cock. “God, this is making me so horny,” she said. “Lift up your butt.”
I did, and she pulled down my boxers, taking care to gently pull my penis back through the fly so it wouldn’t bend the wrong way. She wiped the oil off my cock with them, then tossed them onto the floor with her own clothes and looked at me.
“How do you feel about what I’m doing, Mike?”
I couldn’t help staring at her tits while I answered. “I’m conflicted, Kate.”
“Do you want me to stop?”
“God, no.”
She grinned. “Good.” Then she bent down and sucked my cock into her mouth.
“Fuck, Kait,” I groaned as I watched and felt what she was doing. I’d never even had a girl touch my naked cock, much less with her mouth. It felt warm and wet and when she sucked until her cheeks hollowed it felt tight as she bobbed up and down on me. And she was doing things with her tongue – wonderful things just under the head of my cock. One hand was busy jacking the part of me that wasn’t in her mouth while the other played with my balls. Her tits jiggled to the rhythm of her movements. It was hypnotizing.
“Kate… can I touch your breasts?”
She pulled off of me just long enough to say, “Of course,” then sucked me back in. I reached down with both hands and palmed her lovely little tits then squeezed them both gently, making her moan. I rubbed both of her nipples between thumb and forefinger, and she shivered.
The combination of what she was doing and the excitement of touching a girl’s body this way had me on the edge.
“Kait, careful, I’m gonna cum.”
“Mmmhmm,” she said, and increased her speed and the power of her sucking. The hand that had been playing with my balls moved under my butt and I felt a finger start playing with my asshole. It was too much.
“GAAAAH!!” I screamed, and erupted into Kait’s mouth. She pulled back so that just the head of my cock was in her mouth, and I knew I was spurting directly onto her tongue. My orgasm seemed to extend from her finger on my asshole through my body and balls to the tip of my cock, and upwards into my chest. I saw spots and my lips were numb. I was vaguely aware of Kait moaning and swallowing. I realized that I was squeezing her tits very tightly and let go, and collapsed onto my back.
Kait softened her sucking as the last dribbles of my cum trickled into her mouth and I became too sensitive. She used her thumb to run along the bottom of my cock, forcing the last little bit of semen onto her tongue, then sat up. She opened her mouth and stuck her tongue out to show me a small wad of my jism, then sucked it back into her mouth and swirled it around before swallowing it and smacking her lips. She laid down on top of me, every bit of her front touching mine. My hands found her tight little ass, and squeezed. She was tiny and gorgeous and perfectly proportioned.
“That was fucking hot,” I said.
“Yes it fucking was,” she said, sighing.
“Why did you do it, Kait?”
She looked up at me. “I love you,” she said. “And I told you that you made me horny this morning seeing you naked and hard and cumming. Hell, I get horny all the time seeing you parade your muscles around in your underwear, or a towel, or your tight little wrestling uniform. You know that girls can totally see your junk when you wear that thing, right?”
I blushed. The guys on the team were used to it; I’d never thought about anyone else looking there.
“Then when I watched you lift that guy like he was nothing, and later when I found out you were protecting my honor, I knew I was going to do this.” She kissed me lightly on the lips, then kissed me again, a longer kiss. A lover’s kiss. I felt her licking my lips, and when I opened my mouth to do the same, she pushed her tongue into my mouth and moaned. I felt myself getting hard again under her, and she rubbed herself against it.
“Mike, are you a virgin?”
I blushed and looked away. “Yes.”
She lightly grabbed my chin and forced me to look at her. “There’s nothing to be embarrassed about. Everybody’s a virgin until they aren’t anymore. It just means there’s this one thing you haven’t done yet.” She rolled onto her side, exposing her luscious front to me, grabbed my hand, and led it down to her mons. She rubbed my finger into her slit, gasping a bit as it went into her far enough to feel the warmth and wetness.
“I want to be your first, Mike. If you’ll have me.”
I was boiling hot for her and apparently she was for me, too, and I had the strong sense that nobody was thinking clearly here.
“Kait, your my sister. We shouldn’t be doing any of this at all. We certainly shouldn’t make love.”
“Don’t you want to?”
“Yes, I absolutely want to, but it’s wrong. It’s incest.”
“So? We love each other and we’re hot for each other and we’re both adults. Who cares what a bunch of people we don’t know would think?”