“If anything hurts, tell me and I’ll stop,” I said. “If anything feels uncomfortable in any way for you, tell me and I’ll stop. If you just want me to stop for any reason, tell me and I’ll stop.”
She turned to face me as best she could. She was smiling. “Shut up,” she said. “Shut up and fuck me.”
So I did. I knew from experience that she got off on ass play so I had high hopes that this would be great for her. I reached down again and started rubbing her clit as I pressed the head of my cock against her tight little ring and pushed until the head popped through and she immediately came, yelling, thrashing around on the bed, bumping into Mary Beth.
“Goddamn,” Mary Beth said.
I pushed again. She was slippery but her ass was still incredibly tight. Still playing with her clit, I slowly worked my way in until half my cock was buried in her and she came again, yelling.
Behind me, Tina said, “Wow, she really likes it up the ass.”
“Yep,” Dawn said. “You?”
“I have no idea,” Tina said.
“Ass Night 2,” Dawn said.
I pushed the rest of my cock into Esmeralda and she fucking came again, hard, screaming out my name. Next to me, Mary Beth was watching her with an expression that mixed lust with fear. I put my mouth next to Esmeralda’s ear.
“Remember our first time, when I said it could be strong for you because another person was doing it or it could be strong for you because you like ass play?”
Her only answer was ragged breathing and a nod. Sweat was forming on her face.
“It’s the ass,” I said.
She made the effort to look up at me. “No, really? You think?” she said.
I laughed and started thrusting hard and after a while Esmeralda tensed and screamed out her pleasure again, yelling my name. Then she went limp. Juana was looking at her in amazement. I stopped moving and reached under her and cupped her breasts and pulled her into me and kissed her neck.
“Johnny,” she gasped into the pillow. “Thank you.”
“No, thank you,” I said, and kissed her again. “It was my honor.”
“You cum?” she said.
“No,” I said.
“Sorry,” she said. “But as far as Ass Night goes, it’s a good thing. My mom is next.”
“There’s an order?”
She blushed under me. “I got to go first, everyone decided that. The others played rock, paper, scissors.”
Tina came to us with soap and washcloths. I kissed Esmeralda’s neck again and hugged her tightly, then slowly pulled away and flopped onto my back. Tina moved in and cleaned me carefully and lovingly.
“You’re good to go, Champ,” she said.
“Oh my God,” Juana said softly.
I looked at her voluptuous body, then at Dawn and Tina, then at the other lovely naked bodies on our oversized custom bed. I thought about how in the course of a year I had gone from living alone and having virtually no sex at all to being drained daily by my three lovelies, and then to also having access to some of Barker’s women. Hell, I knew that I could have access to all of his women, but to do so I’d have to give up my exclusivity with Dawn. Which I wasn’t prepared to do. At least not yet. And Thomas wasn’t ready to give me Tina.
“Juana?” I said.
“I am ready for you, Johnny” she said. Her eyes were squeezed shut. Her hands were fists.
“No you’re not, my dear,” I said.
She opened her eyes and looked at me. I bent down and kissed her. She put her arms around me and pulled me down onto her and kissed me back, passionately.
“Johnny, I think… I think I could love you, if we had the opportunity,” she whispered. “And I want to do this with you. I want to do this. But I am afraid.”
As we kissed I lined up my cock and pushed it into her warm slick pussy. She groaned into my mouth and pushed up to meet my thrusts.
“Then we won’t,” I said.
“So thick,” she gasped. And as I slammed into her, she came hard. I was pretty good, I knew, but not that good. They really had primed each other.
When she could breathe again she said, “We will do this, please. I fanaticize about how it will feel. I want to know. And I want it to be you. Please.”
I had a fantasy of my own. “Esmeralda?”
“Yes, Johnny.”
“It might be easier for your mom if she were… being stimulated… when it happens for her.”
Esmeralda stared at me for a moment, then smiled. She turned on the bed until her head was near her mother’s mound. “Why not?” she said, and moved in and grabbed Juana’s ass and began to lick her pussy.
“Wait… mija… no… oh… dios mio…” Juana’s hands went to the back of Esmeralda’s head, stroking her hair as her daughter licked her clit. I waited until I felt Juana start to come, and as she did I pushed myself into her ass in one full strong thrust and she screamed out her pleasure. Esmeralda continued eating her mother as I pushed repeatedly into Juana’s ass until finally she screamed again and her body went rigid and she bucked a few times and then went totally limp.
“Uh-oh,” Esmeralda said, pulling back from her mother. “She’s passed out again.”
I pulled out of Juana and turned her and checked her vitals, then held her to me. “She’s fine,” I said. I stroked her back and her ass and kissed her face and her neck until she came back to us.
She looked up at me and smiled. “Johnny,” she said.
“Hi there.”
“That was fucking amazing.”
“Mom!” Esmeralda said.
Juana turned to her. “Well, it fucking was. Am I not using this term correctly?”
Esmeralda started laughing. “Yes, you fucking are, Mom. I just haven’t fucking heard you say it before.”
Juana turned to me and hugged me. “Johnny, once again I have failed to give you pleasure. I am so sorry.”
I pushed her back and kissed her and caressed her cheek until she opened her eyes and looked into mine.
“Juana. It’s a gift every time I get to see your body. A greater gift when I can touch it. And you’ve given yourself to me and trusted me with you. And you’ve trusted me with your daughter. How much more pleasure do you think you need to give me?”
“I need you to cum inside me,” she said.
“I need that, too,” Esmeralda said.
“Jay, Dawn, and I are going to Sonoma this weekend for a girls’ getaway,” Mary Beth said. “I’d really appreciate it if you two would come over and fuck Johnny until he’s limp and raw. Just to keep him on the straight and narrow.”
“We will do this favor for you,” Juana said.
Tina was cleaning me again. My cock was rock hard. “Fuck this,” she said. “I need to fuck you. I need you.”
I sat up and held Tina’s face in my hands. “Do you love your brother?”
She stared at me. “Yes,” she said.
“Then go home,” I said. “It would kill him a little if you and I had sex. I know how he feels. You don’t want to do that to him. We have a big liberal fuckfest lifestyle going here, but in the midst of it there is this reality: you can’t be with me, and Dawn can’t be with him. I won’t apologize for it. It just is what it is.”
She looked down and breathed deeply. “I know,” she said. “I’ll stay and just help.”
“If you’re done agonizing, there’s somebody over here who needs to be buttfucked,” Mary Beth said sweetly. But her voice was a little unsteady. I moved over next to her and just held her.
“I love you,” I said as I gently rubbed her ass. “This has got to be something you want. Otherwise there’s no point in doing it.”
“I do want to,” Mary Beth said. “I do. Mostly because I don’t want stupid Dawn to have all the ass fun.”