Dawn turn to me and kissed me and grabbed my hand and pulled me towards the stairs, too. “Off we go too, Johnny,” she said. “I’ve missed you so much. Did you miss me?”
I stopped her and turned her around and held her face in my hands. “You have no idea, my love,” I said. I kissed her and my hands roamed up and down her back. Nudity in this house was common and no big deal but nudity just before sex is intriguing and enticing, especially when the participants are particularly horny, more especially when the subject of the intrigue is my lovely niece, and most especially when the particularly horny participant in question is me. My hands worked their way between us while we kissed and encompassed her bare breasts and she moaned into my mouth. Her hand moved down and played over my aching erection.
She broke our kiss and spoke. “You. Bed. Now.” And hand in hand we walked up the stairs.
In a very short time Mary Beth had gotten Jay naked, onto her back in bed, and so revved up that she had pulled the bottom sheet out from its anchor underneath the mattress. Now Jay was running her hands through Mary Beth’s hair and crying out her pleasure. While we watched from the doorway Mary Beth sucked Jay’s clit hard and Jay groaned and panted and her head flipped to the side and her eyes opened wide and she saw us just as her orgasm hit her and she screamed.
“Mmmm, you taste good, Baby,” Mary Beth said as her hands moved onto Jay’s breasts and squeezed. Jay pulled her up until their mouths met and their tongues played together. Dawn and I looked at each other, then quickly shucked off our remaining clothes and moved to the bed. Jay grabbed me as I lay down and pushed me onto my back and positioned me so that her head was resting just above my crotch. She smiled at me.
“Been waiting for this. Been waiting for hours,” she said, and I groaned as her lips encircled my cock and her head pushed down and she sucked me hard and continued pushing down until her throat opened and she swallowed all of me.
“Fuck,” said Mary Beth. She had been trying for almost a year to suppress her gag reflex and take all of me, without success. Jay didn’t have to bob up and down or suck to pleasure me; she simply stayed where she was and swallowed over and over again. The sensation was amazing. Every once in a while she would stop swallowing and pull back a little to breathe, and then her throat would attack me again. It was too much. Hey, I hadn’t had an orgasm in almost a week.
“Gonna cum,” I panted.
Jay immediately gripped the base of my penis with a thumb and forefinger and squeezed hard, blocking my orgasm. She pulled off me and scooted up to straddle me. She looked at my girls, a question in her eyes.
“Go for it,” Mary Beth said.
Dawn kneeled up on the bed and wrapped her hands around Jay’s breasts from behind. “Take him,” she said. “This is hot.”
Permission granted, Jay grabbed my rigid cock, centered it against her pussy lips, and squealed as she sank down onto me. Her pussy was tiny like the rest of her. She was impossibly tight. I groaned and my hands replaced Dawn’s on Jay’s little breasts as she settled onto me and began to ride me, yelping as she bounced up and down on my cock.
Dawn lay down next to me and kissed me passionately. One of her hands snaked down my body and grabbed the base of my cock, feeling Jay slamming down over and over again. “How does it feel, Baby?” she whispered in my ear.
“She’s tight, so fucking tight,” I moaned, still watching Jay.
“Tighter than me?” Dawn said. I looked at her to see if she really wanted to know but she was sticking her tongue out at me so I knew I was off the hook.
“I love you, Dawn,” I said. And meant it.
“I love you too, Johnny,” she said, and kissed me again as Jay rode my cock hard.
“What about me?” Mary Beth said, and Dawn gasped as Mary Beth sucked a nipple into her mouth.
“I love you too, Baby,” Dawn said as she stroked Mary Beth’s hair.
Jay stopped moving and I looked at her. A tear was running down her cheek. I touched her face and said, “What’s wrong?” She sank down and laid her head on my chest and wept silently as I held her in my arms.
“You three,” she said. “I envy you. I don’t have anything like what you have. I can have all the sex I want, any time I want, but I don’t have anyone who loves me.”
I held her as Dawn and Mary Beth both wrapped their arms around her. Mary Beth kissed her neck and shoulders as Dawn kissed her cheek and said, “You do today, Baby.” Jay cried harder against my chest and I held her tighter and stroked her back until the tears finished.
“I’m sorry,” she said.
“That’s okay,” I said. “Now I get to punish you for your outburst.” I pushed her over onto her tummy and positioned myself behind her and she yelped as I quickly sank into her pussy and she began to grunt as I grabbed her tits and slammed against her ass for all I was worth. Her grunting turned into a wail that grew louder as I rammed into her.
“She’s gonna cum,” Mary Beth said.
And she did, with a scream that rivaled Dawn’s usual in length and volume. Mary Beth kissed her and Jay continued yelling her pleasure into Mary Beth’s mouth. Jay’s pussy was convulsing on my cock and I couldn’t hold out any longer. Part of our threesome protocol when it became a more-than-threesome was that I needed my lovers to tell me how to cum. Far from being a restriction, it was more an enjoyment maximization. If they didn’t want me to cum in Jay then I’d be coming in one of their mouths, or in one of their pussies, or on their tits or on their faces.
“I’m going to cum,” I said.
“In her,” they both said at once. I guess they really liked her.
“Yes, please,” Jay panted.
I thrust several times deeply into Jay and then squeezed her breasts and yelled as I came hard. My girls held me and stroked my back and my ass as I spurted into Jay, and Jay moaned as she felt my hot cream coat the walls of her pussy. I held her tightly until my orgasm subsided. She moaned in protest when I pulled out of her but I knew what my girls wanted. I rolled her onto her back and kissed her as she squealed and thrashed under me when Dawn and Mary Beth both latched onto her pussy to suck her clit and eat my cum.
“Oh, fuck,” Jay moaned. I sucked a breast into my mouth and mauled the other with my hand and Dawn licked her clit while Mary Beth lifted her ass off the bed to get at the cum running out of her pussy and Jay’s body went rigid and she screamed in pleasure again.
I rolled one nipple with my fingers while my tongue attacked the other, hoping to prolong her orgasm and make it stronger. Suddenly the tension left her body and she simply collapsed, trembling, onto the bed.
“Jay, are you okay?” I said. Now Dawn was the one sucking my cum out of Jay and she stopped and looked up at Jay’s face, concerned.
Jay was silent for a time, then her eyes opened and locked on mine. She smiled.
“Can I live here?” she said.
I chuckled and looked at my girls. I stopped laughing. Their faces were deadly serious.
“Maybe,” Dawn said.