“I bet our cocks would feel a lot nicer,” Colin cupped one of her tits and sucked her nipple into his mouth and gently nibbled it. “You’re not a virgin, are you?”
Dirk stopped finger fucking Haley as he waited for the answer. She squirmed at the loss of the pleasure. She raised her hips to get his fingers back inside her but he wouldn’t give in.
“No!” she cried out. “Happy? I’m not a fucking virgin!”
Dirk started finger fucking her again and she released a loud moan. He had her completely under his control and he knew it.
“Pop?” Colin looked up from Haley’s tits.
“Yes, son?”
“It’s a bit unfair…”
“What’s unfair?”
“You and me are giving all this pleasure to Haley, but she’s not giving any back.”
“You’re right…”
Dirk picked Haley up in his arms and went inside the house with Colin following behind. He placed her on his king-size bed and the two men got undressed. Haley knew that it was her chance to escape, but the sight of their hard cocks stopped her in her tracks. She hadn’t been fucked for over a month and these guys had huge cocks, at least 7 inches each and an impressive girth. Colin kneeled by her face and started rubbing his cockhead on her cheek.
“Come on, little sis,” he teased as he rubbed precum on her lips. “Why don’t you suck your big brother’s cock?”
Haley parted her lips and sucked him in. He tasted of sweat and precum and he turned her on, in spite of her best efforts to feel disgusted. Dirk parted her legs wide and held them up by her ankles, admiring the view of the rosy folds he’d just been finger fucking. Then she felt him rubbing his cocks along her wet slit, making it wet and sticky with her juices. She wanted to tell him to stop, but the cock fucking her mouth tasted too good and then he pressed his cock against her clit, making her moan with delight.
Then he penetrated her. She felt him stretch her tight cunt wide and she loved it. He started sliding in and out of her fuck hole and she raised her hips in rhythm with his thrusts. Colin started kneading her tits as she sucked his cock and she felt absolutely depraved. To her surprise she loved it. Her stepdad and stepbrother weren’t pretending to make love, the way her prep-school boyfriends had with her previously. They were just fucking her and it was amazing. She started working Colin’s cock and balls with her hands at the same time as she sucked him and he started thrusting his hips against her face, fucking her mouth.
It was inevitable that she should cum, but she surprised them all by the sheer magnitude of her orgasm. Her entire body shook as her cunt squeezed Dirk hard and her cry was only muffled by the huge cock in her mouth. When she finally calmed down, father and son pulled out and told her to get on all fours. She faced Dirk and he smiled at her.
“Son, it looks like Haley’s decided she wants your cock in her cunt now so be my guest.”
He grabbed her hair and forced his cock across her lips. The taste of her pussy on his shaft was a huge turn-on for Haley. Then she felt Colin’s cock slamming into her from behind, balls deep. He held on to her hips and grinded his hips against her ass, making her feel every inch of his manhood inside her. Colin started slapping her ass as he slammed in and out of her. Then he reached round to finger her clit and she squealed in delight. Dirk was fucking her mouth hard and fast. He kept shoving his shaft into her throat and there was nothing she could do but enjoy it and keep sucking. Dirk reached for her tits that were dangling free like two perfectly formed peaches.
Haley lost track of time and had yet another orgasm while being fucked at both ends. Dirk and Colin didn’t stop. They were getting every single moment of pleasure that they could from their little fuck toy. They’d both picked up the pace by now.
“I’m gonna cum,” Dirk moaned between his teeth. “I’m gonna fucking cum inside this tight pussy.”
“Go for it, son,” Dirk encouraged him.
Colin groaned out loud as he started shooting his load straight up his stepsister’s womb. When his son finally got his release, Dirk decided to surrender to his pleasure as well and came into Haley’s mouth. She was forced to try to swallow, but not able to and soon his salty cum spilled out of her mouth and down her chin. When the two men finally pulled out, Haley looked like a slut with cum running off her face and down her bright pink thighs.
“You’re on the pill, aren’t you?” Colin asked Haley.
She could only nod in reply, disgusted with herself for what she’d just done and absolutely satisfied.
“Good,” Colin wrapped his arms around her from behind and started playing with her tits. “Then my little sis can be my fuck toy until Amy Sue gets back.”
She wanted to say no, but her body wanted to be fucked by him again.
“And your mom will be gone for another couple of weeks,” Dirk placed his lips on hers and kissed her. “You’ll be my pussy too.”
“What about me?” The voice came from the doorway and they all looked over to see a grinning Justin watching them and knowing exactly what had gone on in the bedroom. “Do I get my fair share of rich girl pussy?”
“We won’t be selfish,” Dirk said. “I think she needs a shower now and, by the looks of it, so do you. Save some water and shower together.”
Justin walked over to the bed and took Haley’s hand and they walked to the bathroom together. He turned on the water and stripped. He let Haley enter the shower first and he came after, semi-erect cock in hand. He pinned her against the cold tiles and started kissing her.
“Oh baby,” he moaned as his cock was fully erect, squeezed between them. “You have no idea how long I’ve wanted to do this.”
“Then fuck me, brother,” Haley moaned against his lips.
He grabbed her thighs and lifted her onto his cock. She wrapped her legs around him as he started pounding her hard. He sucked and bit her tits as he fucked her hard and fast. She’d just had several orgasms and they fucked for nearly 30 minutes before she finally came, quickly followed by him. They were out of hot water by then and rinsed themselves in cold water. As they stepped back into the bedroom, Haley naked and covered in love bites and bruises, Dirk and Colin had been joined by the youngest of Haley’s stepbrothers, Phil.
Dirk smiled at the naked crew.
“We have one hot cunt and four horny cocks. I think we better come up with a rota for the next few weeks while Justin and Phil come and stay with us.”