“We dare you,” Tess said, “To take off your shirt and bra for the rest of the game!” They were obviously proud. Rachael was excited. She couldn’t deny that outside of her little plan, this was fun and she wanted to show the girls what she had. She nodded and quickly slipped off her white tank top and then unhooked her pink bra and let it fall. Her supple tits jiggled out and she felt the girls eyes on her and she loved it. She knew that she looked good. She let them sit and look at them for a little bit. Then she decided to fuck with their heads.
“Never have I ever kissed a boy,” she said. Their eyes got very wide like they didn’t believe it. But they had to trust her. They had both kissed boys, “I guess I am the odd girl out again. I pick truth,” she said. The girls looked very confused now. They had been looking at her as a sexual creature, what did this mean? They conferred briefly, but then asked a very quick question. But seemed embarrassed to be asking it.
“Are you a lesbian?” Lyda asked.
“Yes,” Rachael said with pride. It actually felt good to say it, beyond just the effect it had as it related to fucking with the girls minds.
“Really?” Tess asked, looking at her with different, but no less reverent, eyes.
“Really. I am only attracted to girls,” she explained. No reason to let the girls stew on it too much, “Never have I ever masturbated in public,” Rachael followed up quickly. The other two girls giggled and then quickly raised their hands. This was part of the plan.
“So do either of you masturbate?” Rachael asked, trying to weed a little information outside of the rules. It worked.
“Yes…” Lyda said blushing but Tess shook her head vehemently.
“I don’t” she said.
“Well I do. I just think it feels so… perfect. To give yourself pleasure whenever you want. To feel your body and to make yourself have an orgasm. It’s just so amazing,” Rachael explained. But now they had to either all do a dare or all do a truth.
“So girls, what do we want to do, Truth or Dare?” Tess asked and Rachael liked that she was moving it along.
“How do we decide,” Lyda said and Rachael turned to look at her and saw that the girl was still staring at her tits and she smiled and jiggled them slightly but discreetly and saw the girl’s eyes follow them. “I think we should all say it, all at the same time. The one that has at least two goes,” Rachael said and the other two girls nodded in agreement, “Okay, on three. One. Two. Three. Dare!”
“Truth,” said Tess.
“Truth,” said Lyda. Damn. A bit of setback. But that was alright. She would have to bend this her own way.
“Okay, as the odd girl out I think I should get to pick the truth at least,” she said quickly and the other girls agreed. She leaned forward and rested her elbows on her knees and sexily placed her chin in her palms, pretending like she was thinking very hard. Of course, she had already thought of dozens of questions and dares, it was just a matter of picking the right one.
“Okay, truth. Have you girls ever played with your asshole while you were masturbating or instead of masturbating or whatever?” she said. Rachael liked how kinky this was getting but she wanted to make it more so. The other girls looked at each other and blushed. They didn’t want to answer.
“I think you should go first,” Lyda said to Rachael.
“No way, I came up with the dare, you go first,” Rachael said to her, giving her a look that said she wasn’t joking about it.
“Fine,” said Tess rolling her eyes, “I can honestly say that I have never played with my… asshole in a sexual way.”
“Do you play with it in other ways?” Rachael asked and the other two girls laughed, releasing some of the tension.
“No I didn’t mean it like that!” Tess explained and they all laughed again. But then they turned and looked at Lyda. It was clear she was going to have to go next. She took solace in the fact that she assumed that Rachael wouldn’t be asking the question if she hadn’t done it. She closed her eyes and started to speak.
“Okay, it was just this one time,” she said.
“No way!” Tess said, interrupting her. Lyda flung herself down and covered her face with a pillow. Rachael shot Tess a very evil look.
“Don’t worry about it,” She said to Lyda. “Tell us about it.”
“”No!” She said sitting up. She looked like she was ready to quit. Things were getting dangerous. This could ruin the whole plan. Rachael knew that she shouldn’t have let Lyda stay here. She looked over at Tess and pleaded with her eyes. She needed this to work. She was having fun. More importantly, Kitty needed her to do it.
“I am sorry. I don’t think it is weird or anything. I was just surprised,” Tess said, putting her hand on Lyda’s shoulder. Lyda looked up, her face was still red, but she was smiling sheepishly.
“Sorry I got upset,” she said and Rachael felt her heart loosen up a bit.
“So tell us about it,” Rachael said, leaning forward with intense interest.
“I don’t know,” Lyda said but she could tell by her friends’ looks that they wanted to know. She giggled then spoke, looking at Rachael’s tits as she did so, “It was just this time in the bathtub. Sometimes I like to masturbate underwater because it slides in easier. So I was just… fingering myself in the tub and it was like… really good that time. I don’t know why. So I was going really hard and I slipped my finger out and then pushed it really fast into my asshole. It was like… an accident. But it slipped in really easy because of how wet it was. But it was so… intense it just made me cum right then,” the girl explained. Rachael felt her pussy getting very wet. She looked over at Tess and saw that she was flushed too, but not from embarrassment. This was turning her on too. Lyda looked horny too, like the story had awakened something in her.