Then all eyes were on me. Sammy was staring at me and he had a strange look in his eye. I think that it might have been lust. I have to admit, that I felt a sexy chill run through my body when his eyes fell on me. I felt the same about the two girls looking at me. I wanted them to want to look at my body. I quickly pulled off my long-sleeve t-shirt. I was wearing a black bra with a front clasp. My heart was beating now and I felt a sort of sick excitement mixed with fear. But I reached up and unclasped the bra. I grabbed the two cups and pulled them away from my breasts. I looked down and saw my round pink areolas and longish nipples, my small but perky breasts and felt proud of my body. I felt Adrienne, Carrie, and Sammy’s eyes on me and I looked up at them. They all looked at me hungrily. I close my bra back up, but felt strange. I could feel the moisture between my legs and realized I was very turned on! In front of my brother!
“You all have pretty bodies,” Sammy said and he blushed.
“He is so cute!” Adrienne said and he just blushed harder. I was sort of proud of him for making the compliment. And I actually felt glad he liked how my body looked. That was a weird thought. Suddenly I realized the room felt very hot (all the cold from Adrienne’s mooning had dissipated). It felt muggy in the room and smelled a little like arousal. This was getting weird. But I didn’t want it to stop.
“Ok Adrienne, your turn,” I said. I turned to hear and her cheeks looked flushed. Carrie was the same. I realized we were all getting turned on with our naughty little game. This had gotten sexy so quickly; I didn’t even realize how odd it was. This was not the sort of thing I did with my roommates! But I’d wanted something like this for my brother, so I had to keep going.
“Never have I ever,” Adrienne said, “masturbated in my sibling’s room,” I looked around and saw that Sammy’s hand was down! He was my only sibling. He had masturbated in my room?
“What?” I asked.
“I knew it!” Adrienne said, “I totally can tell that dudes like to do stuff like that. They crank it in weird places!” I was looking at my brother and he was blushing, but he was giving a sly little smile too. I felt a little grossed out. But also a little intrigued. Why had he masturbated there? What did he think about?
“Sorry sis,” he mumbled, “I just want to do it in a room that smelled like a girl.” He explained and Carrie and Adrienne giggled. I was dumbfounded. My brother, masturbating with my smell in his nose. I was a little disgusted that it turned me on even more.
“Come on, huddle up for the dare,” Adrienne said. This was Sammy’s first dare, so we discussed it for a while. I will have you know that I fought against the dare; I said it was gross and a bad idea and begged them not to do it. I was shocked by how quickly I felt this was spinning out of control. But they took a vote and I lost. Finally, Adrienne got to deliver the challenge.
“Sammy, we dare you,” Carrie said, “to show us your dick.” Sammy’s eyes got very wide and he made a small choking sound in the back of his throat.
“I… uh…” he managed to say. He looked at me for a moment, then his eyes darted away, mortified.
“Come on, you made us show you our tits, even Lynn had to show her tits. This is really the least you can do,” Adrienne said, putting her hands on her hips.
“Lynn…” Sammy started and I looked at him and shrugged.
“This is so embarrassing,” Sammy said and then he hooked his thumbs into his sweatpants. He was actually going to do it. I don’t even know how to describe the feeling I had when I saw that. I was happy he was into it, but I didn’t want to embarrass him. And I didn’t want to see his cock. I didn’t think I wanted to see his cock. I kept looking at my feet.
“Holy shit!” Adrienne said and I looked over at her. Her eyes were wide and her mouth was a little slack. Carrie had the same look on her face.
“What?” I asked.
“He’s got a huge dick,” Adrienne said. I turned quickly and looked. My brother was on the couch with his sweat pants and boxer shorts pulled down to about mid-thigh. His cock was hard and standing straight up out of his lap. Adrienne wasn’t kidding. My tiny, nerdy little brother had a huge dick. I am no virgin (nor a slut), I’ve seen my share of dicks. And his was the biggest. It was around 8. 5 to 9 inches long. Not only that, but it was thick, maybe 2. 5 inches in diameter at its thickest point. The circumcised tip was red and glistening with pre-cum. Sammy looked incredulous.
“I have a big dick?” he asked. I realized that he was probably the only person to see it since he was a baby.
“It’s one of the biggest dicks I’ve ever seen,” Adrienne said, “And I’ve seen quite a few.” Carrie just nodded her head. Suddenly I didn’t like these two girls staring at my brother. He was smiling and looking proud of himself as he slid his big dick back into his boxers. I saw it straining against his sweatpants now; I still couldn’t believe how big it was compared to how tiny he is. I wanted to move on.
“Carrie, it’s your turn,” I said, and my voice sounded thicker that I’d expected.
“Right,” Carrie said, “Sorry. Umm… Never have I ever… masturbated while thinking of a family member.” It was a shocking question. I didn’t know what Carrie was thinking. Then Adrienne spoke.
“You rat! I told you about that in confidence!” she said, but she was smiling. But her hand was down, “My cousin Ricky is really cute okay.” I giggled at that. So naughty. Then I looked; Sammy’s hand was down as well. One of our relatives? I couldn’t believe it. It could even be…
“Who was it for you?” Carrie asked, also looking at Sammy. For a moment, Sammy’s eyes darted to me, then down at his feet.
“I don’t have to answer, I mean that wasn’t part of the rules,” he said. I felt my stomach churning. He didn’t have to say it. We all knew what happened.
“No, its cool,” Adrienne said slyly and smiled at me. Then Carrie and I huddled up to come up with a dare for Sammy and Adrienne. My stomach was all butterflies and my panties were soaked through. What was wrong with me? I mean, I know sex talk turns me on, but this was not okay. Carrie and I were both a little timid at this point, so we came up with a dare we thought might slow things down. I delivered it.
“Okay, Sammy and Adrienne, I dare the two of you,” I said, “to switch clothes!” We thought it would be funny to see Adrienne Sammy’s baggy, but short, sweats and Sammy in Adrienne’s girly shirt. We didn’t expect what happened. We didn’t expect them to get naked in the living room. In a quick motion, Adrienne’s shirt was on the floor, and then she quickly shimmied out of her pajama pants. Finally, she threw a tiny red thong onto the floor. She was standing in front of us completely naked. I’d seen little bits and pieces of her naked, but never seen her completely nude. She was gorgeous, with slim body lines and a tiny, pink shaved pussy. My head was swimming. Sammy was staring at her as well.
“Hey I am naked here, want to give me those clothes,” she said to Sammy after a few moments. He shook his head like he was waking from a dream, smiled sheepishly, and pulled off his shirt. He was bright red all over from blushing. Next he took off his sweatpants and boxers in one motion and set them on the floor. He was thin and pale and completely devoid of chest hair. His monstrously large cock was still hard and looked even more absurdly huge now that he was standing.