After this morning we’d all gone to our separate corners to reflect on everything. Even though Jess had long ago “moved” into my bedroom, we had kept hers as a decoy. Lately, she mainly used it as a large closet. She had stayed in her room all morning long. Likewise, Maggie had holed up in her room, as I did in mine.
All day I had to keep reminding myself that life wasn’t a teenage fantasy, that a shared relationship was difficult to maintain. I did some quick internet searches, but those quickly devolved into either porn sites or fake testimonies obviously written by someone who had no idea what they were talking about. Frustrated, I frisbee’d the tablet onto the bed.
The teenager in me was screaming at the adult part to stop worrying and enjoy it. The rational part of me couldn’t stop worrying. Could we make it work? What if someone got jealous? What if they realize they don’t need me anymore?
It wasn’t like I could call any friends and ask for advice. ‘Hey, I’m thinking of starting a three-way relationship between my sister and the girl who threatened us and now lives with us wearing an ankle monitor. What do you think?’ would either get the cops called or get me hung up on.
I slowly came to the realization that Jess would never lie to me, even to spare my feelings. She’d always been blunt and honest with me. If she said she was okay with it, then I should take her at her word. Likewise, Maggie had been upfront and honest with both of us. If they said they were okay with it, why shouldn’t I believe them?
After several hours, a growling sound interrupted my thoughts. I looked around, trying to find the source of the noise before realizing that I hadn’t eaten in quite a while. Sighing, I left my room to heat up some leftovers for everyone for dinner.
About halfway through getting the pasta and meatballs warmed up, I heard someone enter the kitchen. I looked up and saw Jess standing there, smiling at me. She came up behind me and wrapped her arms around me.
“Hey,” she said, resting her head against my back
“Hey.” I rubbed her arm. “You okay.”
“Mmhmm.” she sighed contentedly.
“I gotta know since it’s just us right now.” I turned to face her. “Are you sure you’re okay with all this?”
She nodded, then sat down at the kitchen table. I turned the heat down to simmer and sat with her.
“Jace.” she started. “When we first started, I finally felt whole again. Every time we made love, I felt that. But I knew it couldn’t last forever. Neither of us are stupid or overly idealistic. Let’s face it, nobody would accept a brother and sister relationship like this, no matter what the reason. I knew we couldn’t keep it up forever, and that eventually you’d have to find a ‘real’ girlfriend.”
Jess reached over and took my hands, kissing my fingers gently.
“I meant what I said earlier. I knew that when you did things would change. Probably not for the better, at least not for me, but they would have to change. I just wasn’t sure how it would work, you know? I mean, it’s not like I can think of any girl who would be okay with you occasionally heading to my bedroom to give me a vitamin J injection.”
“A what?!” I laughed.
“Sorry, it’s what I think of it sometimes.” she giggled before continuing. “Anyway, I knew that would put us in a really bad spot, but I guessed we’d work something out. Doesn’t mean it wouldn’t kill me knowing you were with someone else and had to keep us secret.
“When Maggie came in our lives, I wondered if she would be the one to take you away from me. I liked her; thought she was kinda cute and everything, but I wasn’t sure if you did. Then I saw how you looked at her and how she looked at you. And it was weird, because I thought I’d be jealous or something, but I wasn’t. I started to see her through your eyes.”
“I felt so guilty,” I confessed. “God, I still do.”
“For what?”
“Starting to have feelings for her while still in love with you. Like a two-timing scumbag.”
“Jace, baby, nothing about our relationship is conventional. Why would that be any different?”
“You know I still love you. I’m still in love with you, right?”
“Of course! I will never understand how people think that love has to be binary or some finite amount. That if you love someone that somehow means you can’t also have feelings for someone else! Love is boundless, and I truly believe that you can love multiple people at the same time. Hell, parents do it all the time with their kids.”
“Yeah, but loving someone and being in love are two different things.” I pointed out
“Are they really?” Jess asked decisively. “I don’t think they don’t have to be.”
“You never really answered my first question. Are you okay with this? With three people together?”
“If all three people are good with it, then sure.”
“So you think we can make this work?” I asked.
“If anybody can, it’s us,” Jess said, smiling. “Now come on. I’m starving!”
*****
That night, Jess and I left the bedroom door open as we crawled into bed and turned the lights off. We were both buzzing with anticipation and nervousness.
“Think she’ll show?” I asked.
“I hope so,” Jess said, then looked over at me. “Yeah, I said it. The more I’ve thought about it the more I’m kind of excited.”
I reached over and ran my hands across her body. Like me, she had decided to skip any clothes tonight. She spread her legs as my fingers drew closer. She was soaked already!
“You really are, aren’t you?”
Her response was reaching over and grasping my engorged cock.
“I’m not the only one, hmmm?”
“Don’t forget we were interrupted last night,” I reminded her. “And it’s been a pretty sexually charged day. I’ve been ready for hours!”
“Poor baby,” she said, slowly stroking me. “Need some relief?”
I didn’t say anything. I pulled her to me and kissed her. She responded in kind, kissing me back as she slid on top of me.
Before much more could happen, a shadow at the doorway caught my attention. Maggie stood there, clutching at her long nightshirt as she watched us. Jess followed my gaze and smiled when she saw Maggie.
No one moved for several seconds, everyone a little unsure what to do. Slowly, Jess got off of me and walked over to Maggie. Maggie stood transfixed, staring at Jess’ naked body as she approached. Jess reached out and took Maggie’s hand, pulling her into the room.
“I’m glad you’re here,” Jess said, giving Maggie a hug.
Maggie hugged her back.
“You two sure you still want me here?” Maggie asked, worriedly.
Instead of saying anything, Jess reached down and lifted Maggie’s shirt. Maggie raised her arms, allowing Jess to strip her. I smiled when I saw Maggie was wearing the same pale blue panties she had on the last time I saw them. Moving towards the center of the bed, I gave Maggie room to lay down.
She climbed in beside me and pulled the covers up over her. Jess quickly got into bed on the other side, leaving me sandwiched in the middle.
“I could get used to this,” I said, trying to break the tension in the room. I at least got a few laughs from the girls.
Maggie rolled over to me. I slid my arm underneath her, pulling her closer and enjoying the feel of her against me. She ran her fingers over my cheek then rested her forehead against mine. Gently, she kissed me. The kiss grew hotter and more passionate as her hand slid down my chest and stomach. As she neared my cock, her eyes grew wider as she realized I was naked just like Jess was.
I felt another hand on me and saw Jess watching us.
Sensing Maggie’s apprehension, Jess took her hand.
“Here,” Jess said, guiding Maggie’s hand to my cock. She touched it gingerly, lightly running her fingers over it. A tremor ran through me when she took hold of it firmly and began stroking it while we kissed.
“What do you want me to do?” Maggie asked me.
“Whatever you want,” I replied.
“Anything?”
“Anything.”
Maggie slid down me and disappeared under the covers. Before I knew it, I felt her lips kiss the tip of my cock. A couple of more kisses, then she wrapped her lips around my cock and took me into her mouth. I gasped as she began working her head up and down my shaft.
Jess leaned over and kissed me, her tongue darting into my mouth to play with mine. We kissed for a bit before she squealed in surprise.
“Oh God, Jace. She’s touching me.” Jess breathed.
Jess lay back, resting her head on my shoulder. Maggie pulled the covers off, apologized for being hot, then resumed her work on us both. I watched her blonde hair fall around her face as she slowly slid up and down on me. Jess’ moans pulled my attention over to her, where I saw Maggie’s hand furiously rubbing Jess’ clit. Jess’ body started to tense up and I could see her legs start to tremble.
“Oh fuck, Jace.” she breathed. “Oh God, baby. She’s gonna make me cum.”
As soon as she said it her back arched and she cried out as her orgasm washed over her. Maggie’s hand continued to rub for a few seconds more, then shifted as she slid two fingers inside Jess. Jess cried out again as Maggie’s fingers worked inside her. She looked over at me, her eyes wide in surprise pleasure. As Maggie’s fingers moved and curled inside her, Jess started beathing harder. I reached around her, taking her breast in my hand and squeezing it as best I could. Maggie’s mouth was making it difficult to concentrate.
“Oh sh-” Jess gasped. “Don’t stop Maggie. Don’t stop. Uhh. I… I… Ahhh!”
I watched as Maggie drove my sister to her second orgasm. Jess thrashed on the bed as Maggie’s fingers continued their magic inside her. I could hear Jess’ wet sounds slosh out of her as she climaxed.
Jess was a sweaty mess laying against me, breathing heavily in my ear. Her still twitching body pressed against mine, sending small jolts through me. Hearing and seeing my sister pushed over the edge twice like that was all I could take.
“Maggie, I’m gonna cum,” I warned her through gritted teeth, giving her the chance to switch to her hand.