I handed her back her phone only when her tender anus had shrunk back to his usual size, regaining its crinkled appearance. It was glossy with cum and a bit reddened from the reiterated sodomy it had endured, a thin dribble of semen still leaking from it. Still, I marveled at the elasticity of that once again tiny butt-ring that I had just thoroughly reamed, twice.
“So,” I said while Deb scrolled through the pics and commented on which ones to choose, “What’s the caption gonna be then, ‘Thank you for the idea, sis’ I guess?”
Deb laughed. “Not bad, baby, but I was thinking more like ‘Beat you to it, bitch!’ or something”
“Sounds good, Debs,” I chuckled. “Dana is gonna freak out so bad…”
“Yup, that’s the idea!” she giggled, sending the pics of her freshly deflowered, cum-dripping asshole to her twin.
We cuddled on the couch a bit more, then we went to take a much needed shower. We carefully soaped and scrubbed and rinsed one another, enjoying the feel of the other’s slick body. We took our time under the rejuvenating spray of the shower-head, kissing and caressing in perfect relaxation. As I ran my hands all over Deb’s soft curves, luxuriating in the sight of the droplets of water shining on her splendid tits and running down her plump ass, I couldn’t stop telling her how gorgeous she looked, how awesome she was in every possible way and how crazy about her I was.
She shrugged and made fun of my sappy adoration, turning her head down and tittering. Her cheeks were flushed as she tried to play down my compliments, as usual. Of course that only egged me on. At times like this I could clearly see the shy, chubby teenager she had been in high school, that smart yet withdrawn girl I had heard about in her memories of a time when she had lived in the shadow of her cheerleader twin, feeling fat and ugly and uncomfortable about her body. It made my heart ache to know that my sweet Deb had felt like that when she was younger. Ever since she had mentioned her past insecurities to me, I had made it my mission to do whatever I could to let my amazing girlfriend know how beautiful she was, in case she should forget.
As I kissed her and held her and murmured into her soft mouth, I reached my hands to her pussy and ass. Gently, ever so slowly, I slid a soapy digit inside her tender anus while I eased two fingers into her wet vaginal folds, pressing my thumb to her clit. Deb leaned into my body, squashing her heavy boobs against my chest, offering her luscious lips for me to kiss, moaning softly. I lazily circled her engorged clit and masturbated her holes for a long time, until she shivered in orgasm, moaning, pressing herself tighter against me as she whimpered: “Mmmh, baby… I love you so much. Mmhh… You make me feel so good.”
I wasn’t really surprised when, minutes later, as we toweled off, Deb smiled and fell to her knees, taking me in her mouth. Not a day passed without her blowing me and swallowing down a big load of my cum. Clearly, she had no intention of letting her ass be the only receptacle of my seed tonight either. Looking up at me as she sucked me lovingly, she worked her cocksucking magic on my dick, using her soft expert lips and her deep-throating gullet at the best of her ability, until I was once again hard and throbbing in her slurping mouth.
I was surprised when, instead of sucking me off to completion, she slid her lips off my aching boner and sat up on the cabinet by the sink. Spreading her legs apart and pulling her pussy lips open with her fingertips, Deb looked at me and pouted. In a sultry voice, she said: “Don’t you want some of this too, baby? My pussy is feeling neglected tonight. And seeing how much you liked my ass, she’s afraid you may have found a new favorite hole to stick your cock in…”
As I wedged my spongy glans between her moist pussy lips, Deb wrapped her legs around my back and her arms around my neck, pulling me closer.
“We can’t have that, I guess,” I chuckled, lingering at the entrance of her soaked, needy cunt. “But honestly Debs, I’m not sure what my favorite hole was, or is, for that matter. Your tiny little asshole is just amazing, so tight and warm. And I’ve always been a big fan of that talented mouth of yours, as you well know. Still, this sweet wet pussy…”
Her giggles faded into a throaty moan as I finally pushed forward, sinking my whole length into her snug silky tunnel. I fucked her with long deep strokes, enjoying the softness of her vaginal walls caressing my cock, grinding firmly into her thick clit when I buried myself balls-deep into her. At Deb’s urgent request, I picked up my pace until I was pounding her savagely, my slamming thrusts punctuated by her groans of incoming release. I was ready to blow when Deb’s soaked pussy started contracting and she shrieked out in climax. I held back, knowing where she wanted me to shoot.
As soon as her orgasm started abating, Deb fell once again on her knees in front of me and blurted out: “Fuck my face now, baby. Use my mouth to get off and give me all your cum! I need to taste you, I need to drink you!”
Always amazed by her fellating expertise, I moaned deeply as I watched my boner, oozing pre-cum and glossy with her sweet pussy juices, disappear between Deb’s soft lips. She gobbled my pulsing cock to the root effortlessly, inhaling my whole length in one swift, well-practiced deep-throating motion. Sealing her incredible cocksucking lips at the base of my pole, she reached her hands around me and sank her fingers into my buttcheeks. She grabbed hard, pulling me to her, forcing my cock as deep into her throat as it could go, silently reaffirming what she had just said. Grinning at her, I mouthed ‘Love you babe’ as she looked up at me. A spark of unbridled lust was glinting in Deb’s eyes as I grabbed the back of her head in both hands and started slamming my shaft into her surrendered mouth.
I fucked her face like it was her pussy, fast and hard and deep, sliding easily down her saliva-drenched oral cavity and burying myself in her constricting gullet at every brutal throat-fucking thrust. My legs were shaking with impending climax as I held her head in my hands, more to steady myself than to force Deb to take my oral assault. She was totally willing, absolutely horny and as well-trained in the lewd art of face-fucking as the sluttiest of porn stars. Moaning through my grunts of pleasure and the chorus of sloppy, slobbering, choking sounds of our throat-fuck, my sweet babe held perfectly still, except for the rapid movements of her hand furiously frigging her clit.
It wasn’t long before I felt my balls tingle. I gave Deb’s mouth a final series of furious humping strokes, then I lodged my throbbing cock deep in her gullet and let go. As I unloaded my third batch of cum straight into her esophagus, Deb was purring and shivering, most likely cumming on her own fingers, most definitely making me cum harder thanks to the added stimulation of her humming oral cavity. As I fed her my seed, she made delicious swallowing motions, making her throat tighten even more around my ejaculating dick. She milked me like this while I pulsed inside her gullet, swirling her tongue on my sensitive underside and sucking hard with her mouth, submerging my cock in swirling wet spittle, making me spew more sperm into her stomach.
When I retreated from her throat, Deb held my spent dick in her mouth and devotedly cleaned off the foamy layer of juices coating me, gulping everything down hungrily without spilling a drop. By the time she finally let me plop out of her incredible mouth with a smack of her wet lips, I was weak in the knees.
I had to sit down on the edge of the tub while Deb giggled at my awestruck face. “Mmmh… Yummy as always, baby,” she cooed, standing up. “It wasn’t as big as usual, though. I’m still kinda hungry. You up for pizza?”
I could barely nod my head as I watched her walking out of the bathroom, her plump ass swaying, her big tits jiggling, her delicate fingers clearing her pretty face of the spittle dribbling down her chin and shining on her cheeks.
As expected, Deb had a bunch of texts from Dana waiting on her phone. She read through them with a satisfied smile on her face as we ate, smirking and looking very pleased with herself.
“She’s totally losing her shit, isn’t she?” I asked, knowing all about Dana’s competitive streak.
“Oh yeah, big time,” Deb chortled. “She is calling me all kind of nasty things. And of course NOW she mentions the pact, what a surprise. I’m not even gonna reply, she’ll go even crazier!”
“Well,” I said, raising my hand, “mission accomplished I guess.” Deb gave me a high five and a big wet smooch on the lips. Then, offering a nice rendition of an evil mastermind’s cackle, she set her phone down and returned to her slice of pizza. Looking at her, I couldn’t help but grin as I replayed the events of the evening in my mind. Jeez, I thought, talk about weird sisters.
We spent the rest of the night cuddling in bed, watching TV until we were pretty much sleeping with our eyes just barely open. I was dozing off with Deb’s head resting on my chest and my arms wrapped around her, when her phone started buzzing with a series of incoming texts. Looking at the hour, I assumed it was Dana telling Debs that she had evened the score, getting her own anal cherry popped and who knew what else. Maybe she also upped the ante by going ass to mouth on her boyfriend, I thought.
Apparently Deb wasn’t asleep just yet because she reached for her phone and started reading through her twin’s texts. I watched her reactions closely. She was grinning in triumph at first, then her eyes went wide in surprise, then she furrowed her brow in thought. Her final expression was an unusual mix of contented pride, intrigued curiosity and mindful concentration. After she finished tapping out her response to Dana, she turned her phone off and snuggled once again into my side, smirking.
I just couldn’t resist. “So?” I asked, trying to hide my eagerness and failing.