“Feels good now, Nick!” Nicole says. “I was scared for a second and it hurt a little at first, but now it feels great!” She says, rocking back against my cock as I start pumping a little more vigorously. Jesus Christ! Her ass is so fucking tight. I’m glad Maggie put a lot of lubricant in there because her ass is hugging my cock so firmly, I wouldn’t be able to move without it.
“Fuck her harder, Nick!” Maggie says, working frantically at Nicole’s pussy with her hand. I start pounding my hard cock into Nicole’s stretched out asshole. With my hands on her hips, I pull her sweet, round cheeks back against me, as I thrust forward. Nicole is really into it now, pushing back against my cock on every downward stroke, sucking my cock deeper into her narrow channel.
“Oh fuck! I’m cumming!” Nicole shouts, pushing back harder against my cock and rocking against her mother’s hands. “I’m fucking cumming!” Nicole shouts, as her body convulses in quick little shakes. Her asshole quivers around my cock, as her orgasm ripples through her, flooding her pussy.
“Cum with her, Nick!” Maggie says. “Fill her ass with your thick, hot cum!” She says, while reaching between Nicole’s legs and cupping my balls. I jump at the unexpected stimulation, as she squeezes and caresses my balls, and I start spurting cum inside Nicole’s stretched out asshole. Bucking against her firm ass cheeks, I unload my balls, into her, as she continues to revel in the after shocks of her orgasm. I pull my spent cock from her ass and collapse on the bed beside her. Maggie is holding her daughter, rocking her against her chest.
“You did good, sweetie.” Maggie is telling Nicole, as she holds her in a tight embrace and rocks back and forth. “That was great for your first time.”
“How was it, Nick?” Nicole asks, turning towards me with a questioning look on her face.
“Unbelievable!” I say, because I still can’t believe what Maggie just did to her daughter. I’m no prude, but I don’t think I would have used the trigger like that. I have really mixed feelings about what we just did to Nicole.
“I’m really going to leave you two alone, now.” Maggie says, kissing us both and getting off the bed. “Don’t get up.” She laughs. “I’ll see you both tomorrow.” I hold Nicole tightly, as I listen for the front door to close.
“I think I need another shower.” Nicole says, softly. “There’s stuff running out of my butt.” I laugh, and agree that a shower is a good idea. We go into the bathroom and I adjust the water temperature, while Nicole uses the toilet.
“I keep feeling like I have to shit, but I think it’s just from having your cum inside me.” She shrugs, smiling at me.
We take a hot shower, lovingly lathering each other’s bodies, but I feel so fucking guilty about using the trigger to fuck Nicole’s ass, that I don’t really enjoy it. Nicole doesn’t seem to notice my preoccupation and we dry each other off before snuggling under the covers. Our exhaustive day of sex finally catches up with us and we fall asleep instantly, with me spooned against Nicole’s back.
I awaken to the feeling of naked flesh against my back and figure Maggie has decided to join us. I turn over, wrap my arm around her and open my eyes. Light from the living room makes her face almost a silhouette, but I can see enough to realize it isn’t Maggie. It’s my sister, Susan!
“Surprise!” She says, kissing my lips and running her hand down my body, gripping my soft cock. “I missed you and figured…”
“What are you doing here?” Nicole says, leaning over my back and staring at Susan. Although, Nicole knows all about my relationship with my sister, she’s as surprised as I am to see her.
“Ohmygod!” Susan screams, jumping out of bed. “I’m so sorry!” She cries, making a futile attempt to cover her nakedness, by putting her hand in front of her smooth pussy mound and wrapping her arm across her large tits. “I thought… I thought… you’d be alone!” She stammers. “I didn’t think Nicole’s mother would let her spend the night.” She starts to leave the room and I jump out of bed and grab her arm.
“It’s okay, sis.” I tell her, wrapping my arms around her.
“Nick!” She whispers, trying to push me away. “Don’t let her see us like this!”
“It’s okay!” I try calming her. “Shhhh! Shhhh! It’s okay.” I say, holding her tightly against me. “Nicole knows.” I tell her, and she abruptly stops fighting, her body going completely tense.
“She knows you’re fucking your sister?” She asks, incredulously.
“Yes.” Nicole answers. “And your mother.” She adds sleepily. “And my mother, for that matter.” She says. “Now, can we all just get some sleep?” Nicole says, turning over and pulling the covers up.
“You’re fucking your girlfriend’s mother?” Susan asks, not quite hysterically.
“Shhhh!” I say, trying to calm her down.
“Nick fucks whoever he wants.” Nicole says, from the other side of the bed. “Don’t forget he’s also doing your roommate.” Nicole adds, sleepily.
“She knows about Sherrie?” Susan asks. “Why don’t you just take out a fucking ad, Nick?” Susan’s confusion seems to have transitioned to anger.
“Okay.” I say, still holding her naked body against mine, her breasts heaving against my chest. “Let’s calm down. We can talk all about it in the morning.” I say, leading her over to the bed.
“I’m not sleeping with the two of you!” Susan says, indignantly. “I’ll find another bed. Maybe I should go to a hotel.” She says, pulling away from me. “Oh God! This was such a big fucking mistake.” She cries, as I pull her back, wrapping my arms around her. “I’m sorry, Nick.” She says, collapsing against me, as she starts to cry. I hold her naked body in a tight embrace, rubbing her back, as her tears soak my shoulder. “I’m so sorry. I just wanted to surprise you.” She whispers between sobs.
“You did.” I tell her, trying to make her smile. “You surprised me a lot.”
“I couldn’t stand the idea of you down here…” Her voice trails off into more sobs. “I love you so much, Nick.” She says, kissing me between sobs, her tears running down her cheeks.
“I love you, too!” I whisper. “Sleep with me. It’s not really different than what we do with Sherrie.” I tell her. “Come on, Susan. Nicole’s asleep anyway; you won’t even know she’s here.” I pull her warm body towards the bed. “You don’t want to sleep alone tonight, sis… I’ll hold you.” She nods, and we lay down on the bed together. I stroke her hair, telling her how much I love her, while I caress her back and shoulders. She finally relaxes in my arms, falling asleep with her head on my shoulder.