Alex giggled and nodded, but then asked, “Wait, where does Wade fit in this equation?”
“Inside us,” Toni joked. “No… I don’t know, honestly. I care about him, but I love you.”
Alex turned, kissing her twin. “It’s different. Of course, we’ve always loved each other. Like, sister… twin love.”
Toni nodded. “But now we both feel so intensely for one another,” she finished.
There were a few seconds of silence as Alex thought about their situation. Looking at her again, she asked, “Do you really think it’s okay that we’re devoted to each other and we’re still fucking… practically everyone else?”
“I don’t think either of us could survive without dick,” Toni replied with a giggle.
Alex laughed with her, but then remembered the encounter with Danny yesterday.
“By the way, our brother surprised the hell out of me yesterday,” she said. “He came in while I was laying on my bed in my lazy shirt and basically just shoved his cock in me.”
Toni whimpered at the thought, and Alex hear see the envy in her tone.
“Dane?” she asked.
“Danny,” Alex corrected, amused at the look of surprise on her twin’s face.
“Unfortunately, that was really the only orgasm from yesterday that’s worth mentioning. Bryce came close again, though,” she said.
“Ugh, do I need to have Wade take care of him or something?” her sister asked.
“Fuck no,” she replied. “Toni… he could have had me yesterday, several times. He even wants to, by his own admission. There’s something there, between us, I just… I don’t want know…”
Toni looked at her weirdly.
“I like him,” Alex said, shrugging. “I know it sounds weird saying that I love you but that I have feelings for this other guy.”
“No… I actually get it,” Toni said, “I just don’t get why it’s with Bryce.”
Alex shrugged. “There’s some kind of connection,” she said. “Maybe it’s just all the deliberate flirting that we do with each other. We both seemed determined not to break before the other. But damn… we were cutting it close yesterday.”
She described getting the pizza and then Bryce’s rampant misbehavior with her in the kitchen.
“Fuck… he just… wouldn’t stop messing with me. He had his hands on my hips and had pulled my pants down. And don’t forget, Beck is sitting in the living room only a few feet away. But he didn’t stop and didn’t care. He just grabbed my hips all rough-like, and slid his dick inside me. I was fucking melting,” she groaned.
“God… so hot,” Toni moaned.
“But then stopped and I realized that he could have had me then and there,” she finished. “Fuck… I was just… his in that kitchen.”
Toni whimpered. “God… there’s nothing sexier than a man who knows when to take charge and has the balls to do it.”
Alex kissed her, then brushed a hand through her hair as a delightful thought came to her. “Ooo, can you imagine the two of us and then Bryce and Wade?”
Toni groaned and closed her eyes. “Please tell me you’re making that happen?”
“I’m thinking about it. I’ve really got to talk to Beck and think about things.”
“Like what?” Toni asked.
Alex sighed. “Well, I’m in love with my twin sister, having sex with her, my two brothers and their girlfriends, Kenny, his mom, his dad, his sister, Bear, and Eric! Plus, I work at a half-topless restaurant, and now we’re thinking about going nude on the internet. What guy in his right mind would want to date a girl like that?”
Toni sighed. “Alex, you’re not being fair to yourself. Lots of people have sex. Just… consider yourself an overachiever.”
Alex looked at Toni, wondering if she was actually serious, but then saw the goofy grin on her twin’s face and burst out laughing.
Toni giggled along with her, and eventually both fell silent.
“I like him, I just don’t want to hurt him,” Alex said eventually.
“If you want to be with him, then just be completely honest. If he gets hurt, then it’s on him.”
Alex turned and kissed her again. “You always make me feel better,” she said.
“Well, don’t forget, your heart belongs to me,” Toni said, a curl of Alex’s hair latched by her finger.
Caressing her face, Alex kissed her again. “It always will,” she assured her.
Hearing footsteps in the hall, Alex thought about moving, but then realized that it wasn’t weird for people to see her in bed with her twin. They did stop caressing and kissing each other before the knock, though. The memories came flooding back about what Alex had overheard as their mother stepped in and dropped off some clothes before closing the door behind her.
“So… you’ll never believe what I found out,” she said.
**
“OH MY GOD,” Toni said loudly for the tenth time. “What the fuck!”
Alex tried again to quiet her down. “Jesus, she’s going to come in here. Shut up!”
“They’re swingers!” Toni whispered, seemingly as loudly as she possibly could.
Alex sighed. “Apparently,” she said with a shrug. “Speaking of, I’ve got to text Kenny and see if there actually is a party tonight.”
Toni was making retching sounds, which Alex did her best to ignore. Heading back to her own room, she shut the door behind her and stretched out on her bed.
“Hey,” she texted after grabbing her phone.
“Sup my dude,” he replied, causing her to snicker and roll her eyes. “When we gonna make some fuck?”
“I don’t know, but I fucking need it,” she replied. “Listen though. Are your parents having a swinger party tonight?”
“… yes…” he sent.
“Ugh… gross,” she replied. “I overheard my parents talking about it.”
“Oh,” he replied. “Well then. Nice talking to you. I’m moving to another town.”
She sighed. “I’m serious!”
“For real? And they mentioned my folks?”
“Yes,” she replied.
“Goddamnit… do my parents have to fuck everyone we know?” Kenny asked.
“Does your sister still go with them?” Alex asked.
“I know she and Brian are both planning on going tonight,” he replied. “Dude, our parents might actually fuck tonight.”
“I hate to break it to you, but by the way they were talking they already did. They were saying how the Logan’s always threw the best parties.”
“Goddamnit,” he replied.
“Dude, our parents have had sex with each other,” she sent a few seconds later.
“Dude, your dad and mom might bang my sister and her boyfriend!” he pointed out.
“Jesus Christ,” Alex replied. “I… I can’t think about this right now. I’ve got to go to work.”
“K, sorry dude. Suck some dick tomorrow?” he asked.
“You don’t have to ask me for permission to go suck dick,” she fired back.
“Touche,” he replied. “Alex 1 — Kenny 0.”
“Seriously though, I need to get some,” she sent. “Are you free tomorrow?”
“For that ass, hell yes. Gonna let me get in that butt?” he asked.
“Eric told you?” she replied.
“Told me what? I was just wanting to fuck your ass.”
“Oh,” she replied. “Nevermind…”
“Goddamnit, you let him have anal, didn’t you?” he sent back.
“No…..” she sent playfully, adding an angel emoji to the message.
“Nice,” he replied. “I’m getting’ in that thing next. Have a gropey day at the titty factory, buttslut.”
“Thanks!” she sent.
Kenny always seemed to know how to cheer her up, and his banter had done just that.
**
For the rest of the day, Alex was stuck at work. She made pretty good tips, but all in all, it was a normal day and nothing out of the ordinary happened. Sam was pleasant but seemed a little distracted at times. Unfortunately, they didn’t have much time to talk, though.
After they closed and she counted out, she bid farewell to her sisters and got ready to head home. Walking out, she saw Bryce standing outside his vehicle which was, parked beside hers.
“Good shift?” he asked.
“What are you doing here?” she asked, ignoring his question.
“Stalking you,” he replied.
She sighed. “I’m tired Bryce.”
“I’ve got an idea,” he said.
“Oh really?” she asked, wondering what genius scheme he’d possibly cooked up.
“So far, the best part of you and me is the shit that happens when we’re just screwing with the other person,” he said.
“Yeah, I’ll grant you that,” she said, tossing her purse in the car and then leaning against it, facing him.
“So, stay with Beck,” he said.
She sighed. “That’s your genius plan?”
He shrugged. “Think about it. You and I were fucking yesterday, right behind him! The sexual tension… the excitement! Wasn’t it fucking hot knowing that he could turn around and catch us?”
She had to admit he had a point. Grudgingly, she shrugged, then nodded.
“I mean… when I came in your panties, that was a spur of the moment thing and I just fucking knew that he would figure something out!”
She closed her eyes, sighing deeply as her pervert of a brain conjured up the image in her head.
“Can’t you just see yourself coming over to hang out with him, “Hey babe,” etc. You toss him a kiss and a fuck every now and then. But then… when you come over, me and the other dudes are puttin’ the full court press on you? You said yourself that you like the manhandling and groping.”
She looked up, genuinely impressed with how much he’d listened and understood her. “Taking liberties with me without asking?”
He gave her a confident nod. “I mean, as long as that’s something you’re interested in. Today is a different day and you could’ve changed your mind.”
She sighed, unsure of what she wanted anymore. “So… is this what us taking it slow is?”
“Yeah,” he said with a shrug. “Look, I don’t want Beck to get hurt. But I can’t deny that I want to be part of your life. But yeah, I gotta be honest. You scare me a bit.”
“So why are you bothering? Why are you so interested in me?”