I nodded, “I mean, I’m making love to all of you. It’s nothing you haven’t or won’t see. And I guess it can help seeing someone else experience something you’re curious about to see if you want to try it or not.” Then for Brittany’s sake, I added, “And, Courtney, you’ve been there to support Suki and Sarah when they lost their virginities, it seemed to help them push through and enjoy it. I wouldn’t want to take that from any of the new girls as they join.”
Brittany’s blush increased.
“Well, any more questions, Brittany?” Sarah asked.
“Do I have to decide right now?” Brittney asked, but she was squirming in her seat, her legs clamped together and her thighs rubbing. Her hands wringing in her lap. Her blush was still going strong. The discussion was having clear effects on the poor girl and it wasn’t hard to see.
“No, you could decide at any point, so long as you still meet the requirements. The invitation is extended, and you may accept whenever you are ready.” Sarah informed her, but she was smiling knowingly.
“Can I… Can I talk to Tom… Alone?” Brittany begged. “To help me make the decision?”
“Of course. The rest of us can either wait here and you can go to the bedroom to talk, or we can go to the bedroom and you can talk here. Which would you prefer?” Sarah replied.
“I’ll… I’ll take him to the bedroom.” Brittany decided and she stood up, I stood with her and she took my hand and walked me, slightly hurried, to the bedroom.
Brittany closed the door behind her and leaned against it, her eyes closed. “I can’t believe this is happening.” She whispered.
“You’re telling me.” I retorted as I sat on the foot of the bed. “You know you have a choice.”
“That’s the crazy thing!” She muttered exasperated.
I patted the bed next to me and she came and sat, her dark skin glistening with the sweat of her concentration.
“Okay, here goes. You’ve seen me naked. I’ve seen you naked….” She started. “I am not going to pretend I didn’t like what I saw. You are fit, but not undernourished, and I am terrified and excited by the size of your package… but what about me? Did… did you like what you saw?” Brittney stammered.
“Oh yes!” I hurried to assure her, “Your breasts are amazing, big enough to grope and play with, and dying to be sucked on. I love the way your waist makes your hips pop. Your fine ass is going to be great to hold while we make love, and your skin contrasts with all your intimate parts… your sexy vagina, your nipples, and your anus and really draw me to them. You are beautiful, and sexy, and I am honored to even be considered as a lover.”
Brittany looked up at me, “That’s sweet. But every boy has a type, and you have three girls in there saying you are into small boobs and butt. My ass isn’t like theirs. They got those tiny asses, and you clearly like that. You still like my fat ass?”
“Brittany, I like ‘fit’ asses. I also like my girls to be natural. Fake giant asses and tits do nothing for me. Especially not those fake brazilian asses. I want an ass that responds to my hand.” I explained, “And frankly, something that is extremely hot for me is the variety of my… err… harem. I mean, as a man, the idea of having multiple women is incredible. Yes, Courtney, Suki and Sarah are similar in many ways but each is unique in their own way, and you are just unique in more visible ways. If you doubt me, the giant erection in my pants will testify on your behalf. You are sexy and I can hardly believe you are considering allowing me to enjoy your sexiness. I promise, you aren’t some sort of pity fuck. Don’t worry, Suki and Sarah were both worried about that too. But I find each of you sexy and appealing in your own way.”
Brittany seemed comforted by that, “Really, the asian cheerleader worried she wasn’t fuckable?”
“Oh, she was terrified of it. Apparently her nickname from her fellow cheerleaders is “the two-by-four”, because they say she is a flat, skinny board.” I informed her.
“I’ll rip their fucking throats out!” Brittany blazed, her eyes full of rage.
“I think I was able to help Suki realize they were just jealous.” I assured her.
Brittany tried to calm down. “Those bitches have it coming to them. They are whores that couldn’t stand the fact that they didn’t have control over Suki.” She shook her head.
“Anyway… now…. how… how painful was it for the others…. Getting split open by your monster?” She breathed, shamelessly staring at my cock, which was bulging obviously in my pants.
“Well, I try to make sure that my lover is as aroused as possible before I make that move.” I told her. “That helps it hurt less. And honestly, every girl is different. Courtney seemed to feel it most. It took her a few minutes to get used to it. Suki I think felt the pain but wanted the pleasure and pushed through and enjoyed everything in spite of the slight pain. Sarah seemed to think it wasn’t significant. I think she said something like, ‘That’s it?’ then had me go hard into her. I can’t tell you which it will be for you, but I will try to make it as pleasurable as possible.”
Brittany bit her bottom lip, “Can I see it again?”
“Of course.” I told her, and I lowered my pants enough to let my cock free.
“Damn, boy. You must be six or seven inches…. That fits inside a girl?” Brittany gasped lightly. Her hips were definitely grinding, trying to suppress the need between her legs.
“Honestly, Suki can’t take it all in her vagina. I bottom out about an inch early, but I can get it all inside both Courtney and Sarah.” I informed her.
“So if my little pussy can’t handle the whole yard of penis, I won’t be the first girl to pussy out?” She confirmed.
“Suki takes as much of it as she can, but she is tiny and tight. I am still working her to be used to it. So no, if you can’t take my entire dick in your pussy, you wouldn’t be the first. And if Courtney and Sarah get their way and we get as large a harem as they seem to think, you won’t be the last.” I told her.
“I can deal with that. Now put that beast away. I ain’t in the harem yet, so I don’t think I get to just…. Do it.” Brittany sassed.
“You ready to talk to the girls again, or anything else you need to know?” I asked her, pulling up my boxers and pants.
“The other girls… were they… good? The first time?” She asked.
“Well, mostly what’s happened is me driving things forward, and I like to think I know how to make it good for both parties. Courtney is getting to be okay on top. Sarah and Suki have no idea what they are doing, so everyone is learning together. But no, none of the girls have had a clue what they are doing. Suki is great because her pussy and ass are both so tight, Courtney is down for anything and that is hot as hell. Sarah and I have only made love once, and she was losing her virginity, so while I enjoyed it, she wasn’t particularly skilled or anything. I’ve had a lover before for just over a year and learned how to make a woman feel really good, but no one is ‘natural’ at being amazing at sex. If you just relax and enjoy, we’ll both have a good time and you can worry about learning sex techniques later.” I assured her.
“Just so long as I am not the worst you’ve had, I guess I can be happy with that.” She said, “The hoes back home, they were just always so proud of how fast they could make their man cum.”
I snorted, “How old were the boys? Sometimes all it takes to make a 16 year old boy cum is to show him a pussy. Also, making a man cum fast…. Isn’t necessarily the goal. It is to make the sex mind blowing for both partners, that’s the big thing. I mean, most girls can stroke off a guy with their hand faster than their pussy if they do it right. Does that mean the hand is more enjoyable? Hell. no. They were blowing smoke to make themselves look…. I don’t know, what they imagined was sexy. I’d rather have sex with a girl that takes a half hour, and both of us are seeing stars at the end, then have sex where I come in two seconds and no one really has fun.”
Brittany gave me a startled look. “You mean, making a man come fast isn’t it?”
“Brittany, when referring to a man, sexually, the desirable trait is ‘stamina’, generally, meaning you can have him stimulating you with his penis longer, because that is what feels good for everyone. Sounds like your ‘hoe’ friends were bragging about either finding shitty lovers or having crappy techniques that made sex too short to enjoy.”
“Ha! Fuck you, Keisha!” Brittany laughed. “Alright, let’s go join the others again. I’m ready.”
Brittany walked back to the others, her shoulders back, her head high. A woman who had made a decision. I was pretty sure I knew what she was going to say, but it was still a relief.
“I’m in.” Brittany declared. “Is there a paper I need to sign or something?”
“Nope, now, have you been tested recently for STDs? That is the only thing remaining.” Courtney replied happily.
“I donate platelets regularly, and they test you there. I can pull up my most recent result on my phone.” She pulled out her phone and showed Courtney the results.
“Welcome to the harem!” Courtney clapped excitedly. “Now do you want to experience the perks of membership before dinner or after? I assume you want to take the plunge.”