Natalie was in a great mood as we ate, chatting away about her week at school, what she was doing with her friends. Netball season had long finished as we approached summer so she was spending a lot of time in the pool. Megan had already sent me a text of things we’d need to know for the week, asking if we wanted to bring her back the next Saturday, which worked for all of us.
Thinking of the pool had me thinking of my parents, so I called them up, asking if we could pop around. They practically insisted we visit for lunch and probably dinner, Cindy calling her mother and sister, asking if they wanted to join us. Pulling up outside my parent’s house just before midday, the parents knew we were arriving with Cindy’s mother and sister, so they were not surprised, no surprise the two mothers seemed to be conspiring immediately, Cindy and her sister taking a seat outside, while I joined Dad by the barbecue, sipping at beers, keeping an eye on Natalie.
“Natalie, want a friend or two to come around?” I wondered.
That made me very popular, calling up a couple of parents I knew well. Within another hour, lunch was being served as Natalie was chatting and giggling away with her two best friends. When I told Mum and Dad what Megan and I had agreed, I think I saw their opinion of my ex-wife change completely. The marriage may have ended badly but they knew it was losing my children that hurt even more at times.
“Nice to hear your relationship is so much better,” Mum said, smiling at me as I wrapped an arm around Cindy.
“Once I managed to find it within myself to forgive her, everything has been better. Though I think thanks for all that goes to the little lady next to me.” Cindy snuggled into my side, Mum looking on approvingly. She’d always been an open-minded woman. I remember when telling her about Mike and Chris confessing their sexuality, not realising at that age it wasn’t really my place to share, but after explaining that there was nothing wrong with that, she asked if I felt the same way. More importantly, she said if I did, they’d still love me regardless. “And since the agreement will see Natalie with me more often,” I added, “I’ll make sure we visit more often too.”
“And Greg?” my father wondered.
“He’s sixteen and very much doing his own thing. But I’ll give him a gentle nudge to make sure he comes to see you more often.”
“Is he dating Emily?” Mum wondered, giving her a curious look as I’m fairly sure she’d know.
“They are dating,” I confirmed, “And I think it’s safe to say, from what he tells me, he’s in love. Big time.”
“Last time Emily was here, he was the constant topic of conversation,” my father replied, chuckling away, “Never heard her talk so much.”
“It’s rather cute. Emily has plenty of photos on her social media. They’re only sixteen and just started dating but I think it might just last,” Mum suggested.
My daughter and her friends returned to the pool, Cindy and her sister joining them, Cindy in a little black bikini, Stephanie causing my heart to stop in a white bikini that showed off her body at the same time. No surprise I was eventually convinced to join them too, sitting on the ledge, Cindy happily sitting on my lap with Stephanie sitting next to me. Wrapping an arm around her, she leaned against my shoulder, noticing Cindy smile at me, resting her head against my other shoulder.
“Feeling like quite a lucky man right now,” I muttered. After receiving a soft kiss on each cheek, I added, “Now feeling very lucky.”
“Has Cindy talked to you?” I nodded. “I’m serious about giving you both a baby, Mark.”
Tightening my arm, all I could say was, “Thank you, Steph. I know what it means to both of you. And what your offer means to us as a couple.”
“I love my sister and I’ll do anything for her.” She paused before adding, “I want a threesome with you too.”
“I want a threesome with you, Steph,” Cindy whispered, “You’re my big sister, and I love you.”
“You’re my brave little sister. I adore you.” Hugging them tighter, Cindy leaned across to hug her sister tightly. “Let me know if you agree to anything and we can talk about it together.”
Glancing at Natalie and her friends giggling away at the other end of the pool, I leaned closer to Stephanie. “I think you need to be fucked by me and your sister,” I whispered into her ear. Stephanie met my eyes, a moment of surprise before she smiled.
“Does that idea turn you on, Mark?” she asked softly.
“I think it’ll be a lot of fun but also very loving.”
“Cindy’s told me how great your cock feels. I’ll admit, I’m wondering how it’ll feel buried in my pussy.”
“Maybe you’d like to feel Cindy buried in your pussy?”
Stephanie smiled. “More than anything…”
“Fuck, Mark, I’m so hard right now,” Cindy murmured, “I’ve got to calm down.”
Pulling her against me, I caressed her side, Stephanie kissing my cheek then hers before she walked away, smiling back at us more than once before disappearing inside. Cindy met my eyes, kissing me softly on the lips. “So we both might end up making love to my sister,” she said softly.
“I think she really wants to with you, Cindy. I think she’s kept some very taboo thoughts to herself for a long time.”
Cindy kept gazing at me. “You’re not weirded out?”
“Considering she’s offered to have our baby… Nah, not really. And if we end up fooling around, and it gets what others consider ‘weird’, then so be it. I’m just going to go with the flow. And if you two want to fool around in front of me while we’re in bed together, knock yourselves out.”
Her tongue found its way into my mouth rather quickly, making out for a couple of minutes, before she moved her to lips to my ear. “Definitely earned one hell of a gangbang, handsome,” she breathed into my ear, “And the day you put a baby in my sister, whether it’s for us or for her, my god, I don’t know how I’ll thank you.”
“And when I propose?” She leaned back, meeting my eyes. “I’m trying to choose a ring but there are three. And I want it be perfect.”
Her soft fingers found their way to my cheek. “Mark, any ring will be perfect because it will be from you and I’ll receive the one question I want to hear from you.”
“I have to ask then… When? I’m ready now, Cindy. Honestly, I’ve been ready from within a week of meeting you.”
“I’ll be ready when you pop the question, Mark. I don’t care when. I don’t care where. It doesn’t need to be a spectacular event. What will matter is you getting down on one knee and asking that question.” She kissed me softly before adding, “And I’ve been thinking, Mark. I don’t want to stop our fun just yet. I love my friends. You love them too. So just because we’re married doesn’t mean…”
“It’s up to you, sweetheart, but I’m happy to keep it going too. The only agreement that remains is that we’re always together doing it.”
“Fuck, I love you so much!” She hugged me so tightly, I couldn’t help chuckle, hugging her back not quite as tightly. “We should head inside and join the others. They probably think we’re having sex out here.”
We eventually had dinner with my parents, Natalie’s friends remaining for that too, before their parents came to pick them up. My parents, Laura, Cindy and Stephanie then enjoyed a few drinks. As I was driving, I remained teetotal, Natalie eventually falling asleep on my lap, the universal signal for us to leave.
Cindy and I walked her mother and sister to the door when we arrived at their place. Natalie still fast on the back seat of the car. Laura hugged us both before wishing us goodnight. Stephanie hugged me first, leaving a soft kiss on my lips. Turning to her sister, she kissed her the same way, before turning back to me. “I want to kiss you far more than that, Mark,” she said softly, “And do far more things than just kiss. And I’d like my sister involved every step of the way.”
“Okay.”
“I love my sister. I’m not in love with her, it’s not that, but… I still remember watching her and I’ve still never been more turned on in my life. I had thoughts then that I still have to this day.”
Raising a hand to caress her cheek made her smile. “I’ll put this simply, Steph. I’m not going to be the only one to fuck you when it finally happens. We just have to be careful.”
Hugging her again, Cindy joined in on the hug before Stephanie disappeared inside, wishing us goodnight before closing the door. Taking Cindy by the hand, leading her back to the car, she smiled at me before saying, “Well, looks like we’re going to be having a lot of fun in the future, Mark.”
“Good. It’ll keep life interesting.”