Her hand moved to my chest. “I’d like you to stay,” she whispered.
“I know. Part of me would like that too. It really would.” I lifted her chin to meet my eyes. “I’m glad I can call you my friend again.” That made her smile. A genuine smile, the sort of I used to earn all the time. “But what we’re doing here, don’t you find it weird?”
“No. You’re in my life again. I mean properly. And the sex is just a really good bonus. Plus, I just adore Cindy, and she’s good fun too.” I sighed, closing my eyes and giving it some thought. Megan kissed my cheek. “I just miss you being with me.”
“I know. That’s what makes all this awkward.” Taking a deep breath, I thought of the best way to move forward. “Do you like Caroline?” She smiled and nodded. “Okay. I think starting out any sort of relationship with her by having group sex with all of us perhaps isn’t for the best. I know Caroline really wants to get to know you and make it work.”
“She does?”
“She was incredibly nervous on the way over here. And that kiss you were sharing…”
“It was certainly very passionate. Felt her pressing into me.”
“Megan, Cindy has helped me tremendously. Without her, we wouldn’t be sat here like this now. If not Caroline, there is someone out there who can… Well, who can replace me.”
I heard the sigh, feeling both arms wrap around my torso. Hugging her back, I kissed the top of her head. “Still going to miss you, Mark.”
“Megan, I get a message from you nowadays, and I smile. That’s the place I’m in mentally when it comes to you and me. I only have good thoughts about us.”
Walking out of her bedroom a couple of minutes later, Cindy and Alexa looked at me expectantly, Megan approached Caroline, offering her hand. Caroline rose to her feet, Megan suggesting they enjoy another drink as the three of us would be leaving. Caroline was surprised by that, but one look at me told her why. After a series of hugs, they walked Cindy, Alexa and I to the front door, wishing us goodnight. We wished them a good night in return, insinuating what they might be up to within a few minutes of our departure. They both blushed, which certainly made me chuckle.
As I hadn’t really had much to drink, I got behind the wheel, Cindy kissing my cheek once she was in the passenger seat, Alexa leaning forward to kiss my cheek too. They didn’t ask what Megan and I had discussed, I think it was obvious to them. “I think you still have love in your heart for her, Mark,” Cindy said during the drive home, “All the bitterness you were feeling is gone. You’ve forgiven her for what she did. You’re in a better place now, and you’re allowing yourself to think positively about her again.”
“You’re right. I now remember the good points of our marriage, not the bad points.” I squeezed her hand. “Meeting you was an absolute godsend, Cindy.” Once at a red light, I turned back to Alexa. “And I’m not forgetting you either, gorgeous. But I’m still not sure how this all works.”
“Just go with the flow, handsome,” Cindy said, kissing my cheek.
Drove the rest of the way home in silence, going over everything that happened and what it might mean for the future. Cindy could see I was still thinking as I plonked myself down on the couch at home, Alexa sitting next to me, resting her head against my shoulder. “Now I’m thinking,” she admitted.
“You can stop thinking straight away,” Cindy said, walking in with a bottle of wine and two glass, a beer for me, “I know what you’re thinking, Alexa. I’ve told you to trust me.”
I leaned back so Alexa could look at Cindy. “You’re my best friend, Cindy, but you’re in love and I’m just…”
Cindy motioned for me to move so she could sit next to her friend, hugging her immediately. “We promised each other, Lexi,” she whispered, “I’m keeping it.”
“But you love him…”
“So do you…” Cindy left a soft kiss on her lips. “I know how you feel about him. So does he. We’ll make this work.”
“What does Mark think?”
Both looked at me as all I did was shrugged. “I think this is something you two decide. You know I’m in love with Cindy, but I also have a lot of love for Alexa.”
“Alexa, I think we take our lover to bed, and maybe you’d like to be in the middle this time?”
Alexa kissed her before she leaned across to kiss me. “Think I’ve fucked you quite a lot, baby. And I do enjoy certain people making love to me in return.”
As soon as we were naked in our bedroom, Alexa and Cindy both dropped to their knees. Probably smiled like a kid whose Christmases had all come at once, Alexa happily bobbing up and down on my cock, Cindy giving my balls some attention before she moved around, feeling her hands spread my cheeks and her tongue teasing my rear.
“Fuck, that’s pretty good,” I muttered.
Cindy was always enthusiastic and even exuberant when going down on me. I was the same when returning the favour. We did it because we loved making each other happy, and definitely helping each other cum. Alexa was just as enthusiastic, making love to my cock with her mouth and tongue. Her very talented tongue, that had my motor running and me making some rather soft moans of pleasure.
Cindy moved her tongue from my butt, feeling her rest her head against my hip. “She’s good, isn’t she, Mark?”
“Fuck yes,” I moaned.
“Want to suck me afterwards?”
“Sweetheart, I always want to suck your girlcock.”
Hearing her giggle, I turned my attention from Alexa to Cindy, seeing her look up at me smiling. “I think Alexa can suck mine after she’s finished with you. She needs some man cock inside her.”
Alexa now had me on the verge of orgasm, running my fingers through her hair, gently thrusting my hips as her nose was bumping into my groin. Her emerald green eyes gazed up into mine, and it did make my heart beat that little bit faster. A simple gaze often spoke volumes about how someone felt. I saw the same look from Cindy every time.
Warning Alexa I was about to blow, she readied her mouth as I felt that initial surge, tightening my fingers in her hair as I released a growl, Alexa almost giggling as the first couple of spurts filled her mouth, swallowing those immediately. Cindy’s fingers caressed my thigh as I released at least four more spurts before I was done, Alexa’s tongue moving up and down my shaft before she circled the head, cleaning up any excess cum.
“I have to suck your cock more often,” she cooed, “As that was delicious.” Leaning forward, she kissed Cindy deeply, “And I’m going to suck yours next, beautiful.”
“It’s been a while since you’ve done that, Alexa.”
Cindy sat against the headboard as Alexa leaned down on her elbows and knees. Positioning myself behind Alexa, Cindy passed me a bottle of lube. Placing that down next to me, I dove into Alexa’s arse first, which had her giggling for a few seconds, my tongue proving rather eager. She eventually stopped blowing Cindy, resting her head on the lap of my girlfriend, happy to enjoy what my tongue was doing before I finally applied some lube.
“Gentle, baby,” she whispered, “Nice and slow. But I really want you inside me soon.”
Noticing Cindy was stroking her hair, she smiled at me as I slid a finger into Alexa’s very tight arse. I’d fucked her before, but from memory, only a couple of times. She’d certainly fucked me a hell of a lot more in return. With three fingers inside Alexa, I had her moaning and her long, thick cock dripping. Once I had her begging for my cock instead of my fingers, I relented quickly.
Lubing up my cock, I teased her again, running it between the crack of her arse. It earned more than one giggle, Cindy smiling at me too. “He teases me all the time. God, the anticipation for when he finally slides it inside me,” she murmured.
Alexa gasped as the head of my cock slid inside her. She was incredibly tight. Snug doesn’t even begin to describe it. Tight, warm, and nicely lubed up so it was pleasurable for both of us. As soon as my cock was buried, I gently pushed her lower down so I could lean forward easily, placing my mouth close to her ear. “Suck her tasty girlcock,” I whispered, “I want you to make my girlfriend cum.”
“Make me cum too,” she whimpered.
“I’ve got an idea, Alexa. But you must make Cindy cum first.”
“He always thinks about me, Lexi,” Cindy said, smiling at me.
Leaning back, holding Alexa by the hips, I gently started to thrust, letting her concentrate on blowing her best friend first. Cindy spent nearly the entire time stroking her hair but looking at me, blowing me kisses and just being as seductive as I knew she could be. Alexa was loving what I was doing to her in return, spending most of the time moaning around Cindy’s cock, her head bobbing up and down, no doubt rather eager to make her friend cum so I’d fuck her harder.
“Oh, that’s good, baby,” Cindy moaned, “Almost forgotten how good you were at sucking my girlcock.”
“Never forgot, Cindy. And I remember you returning the favour.”
“You ever made love?” I asked. It wasn’t any of my business but I was intrigued.
“She’s too big for me,” Cindy said, “We tried a couple of times and it hurt, even with all the preparation possible.”
“Sorry, sweetheart.”
Smiling at me, she replied, “It’s fine, baby. Watching her fuck you is something else. I’m impressed every single time.”
“I love fucking him,” Alexa murmured before resuming her blowjob.
“I know you do, sweetie, which is why I’m never going to stop you doing it,” Cindy whispered, continuing to stroke her cheek.
Keeping my thrusts gentle, I was watching Alexa’s head bob up and down on Cindy’s cock. She was loving the attention, her head rolling back with eyes closed. I knew that look. Utter enjoyment but also not wanting to cum just yet. Whispering her name, she opened her eyes as I urged her to cum, using my eyes to gesture at Alexa. Cindy immediately started to move her hips, gripping Alexa’s hair tighter. Alexa loved it, moaning again, and I knew it was all about Cindy as I was barely moving inside her now.
“I’m close, sweetie,” Cindy moaned, “Get ready!”