“John?” I say, breaking the kiss. “What is your number one sexual fantasy?” I ask, wondering if he’ll say sex with two women like Jenny said.
“What we just did,” he answers without hesitation. Kissing my lips again. “You’ve dominated my sexual fantasies for the past ten years, Sara,” he says.
“You’ve been in mine, too, John,” I smile. “But isn’t there some sexual fantasy, beyond spanking me or fucking me that you’ve always wanted to try?” I know I’m leading the witness but I really want to find out if this is his fantasy or Jenny’s.
“How did you know about the spanking, anyway?” John asks, moving his hand along my thigh and pulling me against him. “Did Jenny tell you?”
“I’ll answer you as soon as you answer me,” I laugh. “Come on, wild sexual fantasy,” I prod him.
“I don’t know, Sara,” he says reluctantly. “Just being here with you, just like this, is beyond anything I’ve ever expected to happen.”
“What about two women at once?” I ask him, looking directly in his eyes.
“Did Jenny tell you that, too?” he asks. “Damn! Is there anything she hasn’t told you?”
“That is your fantasy, then?” I ask, smiling.
“Well, sure. I mean, what guy doesn’t fantasize about two women making love to him,” he says, sheepishly. “But it doesn’t mean I’m not completely satisfied with just you… or Jenny,” he adds defensively.
“I know, John,” I say, squeezing his muscular ass and pressing my pussy mound against his cock. “But what if you could have Jenny and I together?” I ask.
“Um…” John hesitates, wondering if it’s a trick question.
“Never mind,” I say, reaching between us and wrapping my hand around his throbbing cock. “I think I’ve got my answer right here! You love the idea!”
“Hell yes!” he smiles. “But it’s just a fantasy.”
“Jenny wants to make it come true,” I tell him as I caress his cock. “She wants us to surprise you for your 40th birthday; you and I in a threesome with her,” I tell him.
“Did you tell her about us?” he looks at me incredulously.
“Of course not!” I answer indignantly. “She came up with this idea on her own. But I think it’s a good one, don’t you?”
“If you do,” he says, relaxing against me. “What do I have to do to make this happen?” he asks.
“Just turn 40 I guess,” I smile as my hand leisurely pumps his hard cock.
“Wow!” John says. “So what all did Jenny tell you?” he asks. “Obviously, she told you about my fantasies and about how I like to spank her. What else did she say?” he asks.
“She showed me a video,” I answer.
“What?” he asks, jerking his head up from the bed. “She showed you one of our videos?” he questions. “When did this happen?” he asks.
“Friday night while you were gone,” I answer. “I came over so Jeremy could use my apartment for his date.” Or so I thought. “Jenny and I had dinner together and then she decided to show me the video.”
“What happened?” he asks, looking at me with a curious expression on his face.
“What do you mean what happened?” I ask. “You’ve seen the videos, you know what happens.”
“No, I mean, what happened between you and Jenny when you watched the video,” he asks, and I’m not sure how much I want to disclose to him. What the fuck! He’s the only one seemingly not trying to manipulate me and we are planning a threesome.
“She spanked me… and finger fucked me… and… um… ate my pussy,” I tell him and I feel his cock swell inside my hand.
“You’ve got to be kidding?” he says, while little beads of sweat form on his forehead.
“Ooo, you like that idea, don’t you?” I tease, sliding my hand up and down his hard cock. “You’d like to watch that, wouldn’t you?” I ask, knowing what Jenny has in mind for his birthday.
“Watch you and Jenny?” he asks. “Yes, I’d love to watch that,” he says, pushing his hard cock against my hand.
“Maybe if you’re a good boy. I’ll let you see the video?” I tease.
“There’s a video of you and Jenny?” he asks excitedly. “What would make me a good boy?” he asks as he rolls me onto my back.
“Well, you can put this monster inside me again for starters,” I answer, spreading my legs as he positions himself over me.
“Wow! You and Jenny, huh?” he says as his thick cock glides into my well-lubricated tunnel. “Can we watch it while we fuck?” he asks as I pull my knees up and suck his cock deep inside my enflamed pussy.
“No,” I answer breathlessly, shaking my head. “I want your undivided attention,” I smile.
“You’ve got it!” John exclaims, pushing his tongue into my mouth as he sets a steady rhythm, pumping his big cock into my hot pussy. As I start rocking with him, I realize that I’ve already made up my mind to do the threesome with Jenny. Why not? My fantasy was always for us to share John. I’ve never wanted to take him away. Plus the idea of eating Jenny’s pussy is growing on me. For some reason, doing it with John there makes me feel less like a lesbian.
“Wait!” John says, stopping mid-stroke and interrupting my thoughts. “The cameras aren’t on, are they?” he asks.
“No, John,” I answer, rocking my hips to get him started again. “I made sure we’re alone,” I tell him as I grip his shoulder and hump my ass off the bed.
“Fuck me, John! Fuck me hard!” I moan and he responds immediately, slamming his thick cock into my anxious pussy.
As my orgasm approaches, I dig my fingernails into John’s back and flash on Jeremy and Jenny’s deception. What am I going to do about them, I wonder? At first, I wanted to confront them but I’ve gotten what I’ve always wanted, right here with John. A confrontation might not be in my best interest. The threesome sounds interesting and I’m still curious about being with Jenny.
“God, Sara! You feel so fucking good!” John says as he pounds his hard cock into my enflamed pussy.
“You make me feel good, John!” I breathe, my orgasm about to explode any second.
Hey! Another idea hits me. Why should men be the only ones to fantasize two lovers? Why can’t I have a threesome? Why can’t I have Jeremy and John together? Couldn’t one fuck me while I suck off the other one? That sounds scrumptious! Two holes filled with thick cocks at the same time! My pussy gushes at the idea.
“Ahhhhhhhhhh!” I moan as John slams his hard cock into me and I imagine sucking off my nephew at the same time. That could be heavenly.
“Ohhhhhhhhhhhh! Fuuuuuuccccccck!” I cum so hard, I see stars. John collapses on top of me, kissing me tenderly on the lips.
As my breathing slows to almost normal and I feel John’s cock deflate within my satiated pussy, I realize that everyone is going to get what he or she wants. My sister may have orchestrated an elaborate deception but she’s really brought the family together. In a most satisfying way!