I tucked him away and went out to the kitchen. Carly didn’t even look up as I passed her and Karina. They were tightly cuddled up together on the couch. In a vacuum, they looked cute lying together like that. They exuded an innocence that was both sexy and perfectly normal all at once.
I took a plate of leftovers to the kitchen table to eat. It was only a frozen lasagna, thrown in the oven to heat up, but it tasted so exceptionally good at that moment. I closed my eyes and let out a ‘Mmmm’ as I chewed the first bite. I really hadn’t eaten much since the Korean BBQ yesterday with the girls. I filled my belly quickly. I took my plate to the kitchen when I heard a soft moan. I stopped silent, unsure of what the sound I was hearing was.
“Ohh. Mmmm.” There it was again, this time followed by a “Shhh.” That was definitely Karina and Carly. Were they really messing around in the living room? With our parents due home sometime soon?
As stealthily as I could I tiptoed towards the living room. They had moved to the recliner, Carly sitting in Karina’s lap. Carly had her head thrown back; her eyes tightly closed. I couldn’t see Karina’s face. They had a blanket covering their bodies and I couldn’t see any obvious signs of movement. Carly moaned out again. Karina shushed her
“He’s right in there,” she whispered.
“You think he heard me?” Carly craned her neck around.
“He heard,” I said out loud.
“Shit!” They both exclaimed at the same time. There was some shifting about, and Carly slid onto the floor.
“Sorry. We … we were just …” my sister stammered, quite uncharacteristically. Her face was full of shock as she stumbled over her words.
“Pretty sure I know what you were just doing. Just remember, Mom and Dad should be home soon. I’ve got to get back to work.”
I went back into my room and shut the door. My head was spinning a little. Karina was basically fingering my sister right there out in the open. Wow. Two days ago, I would have never imagined that scenario. Now I was replaying it in my mind.
I tried to concentrate on work. It was difficult, with my dick semi-hard and the sounds of Carly’s moan fresh in my ears. I shook my head and chugged some water. I hadn’t accomplished much yesterday, and I was behind schedule. I put my headphones on and cranked up the volume.
I had not gotten very far when Karina poked her head through my open door. “Hey Trev”
I looked up and saw her gorgeous smile. “What’s up?” I asked?
“Can I ask you something?” she said, tiptoeing over and sitting on the edge of my bed.
“Umm, sure.” I pulled the headphones off my head and saved my progress in the program I was in. “What’s up?”
“So, Carly has a date tonight,” she said with a sad look.
“Oh, I didn’t know that.” I was curious now.
“Yeah, some guy we met at the corner store earlier,” Karina told me.
“Oh, that’s cool I guess.” I tried to be supportive and disinterested all at once.
“Look, this is a little awkward for me so I’m just going to say it.” Karina took a deep breath. “I think I might be jealous of him.”
“Umm… Ok. But didn’t you have a date last night?” I asked.
“I know.” She hung her head. “Does that make me a terrible person?”
“I wouldn’t say that.” I went and sat beside her. “But I think you should talk about this with Carly.”
“It’s weird,” she said with a shiver. “Carly and I talk about literally everything. But I’ve got these weird feelings for her that I can’t explain.”
“Okay …” This entire conversation sounded familiar.
“It’s like, I love her and the things we do … but well, you know … I’m not attracted to women at all. But I am attracted to her. I can’t explain it.” She covered her face with her hands.
Part of me wanted to console her. This conversation sounded so much like the one my sister and I had yesterday.
Tentatively, I put my arm around her waist. “Look I don’t know exactly what is going on between Carly and you, but I get the feeling both of you are thinking way too hard about this.”
“You think so?” She looked up at me.
“I do.” I tried to be reassuring. This part wasn’t my strong suit. “I won’t speak directly for Carly, but I get that feeling.”
“Did she say anything about me last night?” she asked.
I pulled my arm away and waved both my hands in front of me. “Nope, not getting in between you two,” I said. As my mouth spoke those words, my cock decided to awaken at the thought of literally being between the two of them. Dammit.
“Please Trevor, I’m dying here.” She leaned her head on my shoulder, giving me a perfect view down her blouse at the lacy white bra restraining those magnificent breasts. I felt my dick twitch.
“You’re just fine,” I restated, “talk to my sister.”
“But what if she wants more than I can give her? I mean, we’ve never gone past a certain point … sexually, you know. I’m really scared to. But I think she wants it.” She threw her head against me again.
‘Oh my god,’ my dick thought as it stiffened at the deja vu. I knew exactly what she meant. “Look, Karina, I think you should just enjoy what you two have and not worry so much. This is one date. You seemed to enjoy yourself with that guy last night. Carly was there for you to talk to when you got home. Just do the same for her tonight,” I reasoned.
She sat there silently for a bit, her head still leaning on my shoulder. I did my best not to stare down her blouse the entire time but failed miserably. I was so close to those perfect breasts my cock just couldn’t stand it.
“Trevor,” she asked quietly.
“Yes?” I responded.
“Can I ask you something?” Her voice was almost a whisper.
“Sure,” I said.
“Yesterday, after we got home from dinner, did you jerk off thinking about Carly and I being together?” She sat up and looked me right in the eye. I’m sure the shocked expression on my face gave her the answer before I spoke.
“Umm, well… yeah, but… not… I mean… it’s not like I did that the moment we got home,” I stammered.
“But you did,” she pressed on.
My turn to hang my head, “Eventually, yeah, I did.”
“It’s ok,” she said softly, “I’m glad.”
“You are?” I asked, confused.
“I’m sorry. We had been, well … mostly me to be honest, kind of teasing you a lot the last day or so. You know, talking about stuff out loud and being a little careless around the house together – like you saw earlier. I don’t know, somehow the thought of being caught makes the thrill of messing around even more intense,” she confessed.
“Like an exhibitionist.” I summarized.
“Well, maybe. I mean, we’re not running around the house naked or anything.” Yeah, that visual would never leave my brain now either. “But the little bit of hinting and dirty talk is kind of exciting,” she ended in a whisper.
“Sure,” I said, absent-mindedly. I was still trying to absorb what she had just said.
“I was just wondering, because when I hugged you before my date last night, I was pretty sure you were hard.” She smiled at me again.
“I… well, yeah. You looked really good,” I said, trying not to blush.
“Thanks. You’re sweet. It’s kind of nice to hear that from someone new now and again,” she said, staring at me sweetly.
“It’s true. You are gorgeous. I’ve always thought so.” I told her the truth.
She hugged my neck and kissed me on the cheek. “Thanks Trevor. I never had a real brother. I’m glad I’ve got you here.”
“I’m glad you’re here too.” My cock twitched in agreement. Karina stood up and smoothed the front of her blouse out.
As always, I watched her ass sway as she walked towards the door. She looked back over her shoulder and smirked at me, catching me in the act. I blushed. She winked and closed the door.