Okay to play catch with their son who wanted to be outdoors? Laughing and having fun and just being a kid? Was she being serious right now?
Jen was the first one to acknowledge the awkwardness of the situation. She quickly stood up and walked over to them. “Mom, Dad! I didn’t think you were coming.” She kissed them both on the cheek.
“We didn’t even realize the wedding was back on. We had to hear it through the grapevine. The girl told me it was over.”
The girl? God, did she even know my name?
I saw some people turn toward me and James out of the corner of my eye. Only a few people knew about last night. My parents weren’t among them. Shit.
James cleared his throat. “Mr. and Mrs. Caldwell, thank you so much for that wonderful toast. Being at your house was the highlight of my childhood. As you might have guessed. I’m sorry, if you’ll all excuse me.” He tossed his napkin on the table. His chair squeaked against the floor and he made his way over to his parents. He walked out the front door without saying a word to either of them. Mrs. Hunter smiled at me and then followed her son out of the apartment with her husband in tow.
“You knew and you didn’t tell me,” James said coolly as the door closed behind them. But even after the door closed, you could still hear their voices. “Why didn’t you call me? She came to you because she couldn’t come to me and you just let her leave? Do you have any idea what I was going through? Did you even care?”
“Of course we care about you,” his mother said back. “That’s why we were happy it was over.”
“Then why the fuck are you even here?”
“Do not raise your voice at me, James.”
God, everyone can hear this. Music! “Rob!”
He was staring at the door in horror.
“Rob, do you know how the sound system works? Could you put some music on?”
“Yeah, Penny.” He shook his head and stood up. In a few seconds music was blaring through the apartment. I was surprised to see Rob slip out the front door.
Everyone was either staring at me or the door and I had no idea what to do. I felt frozen. What could I possibly say that would make this better? I gave Jen a pleading look. She was so good with people. Please make this better.
Jen laughed awkwardly. “For those of you who don’t know my parents, this is just classic Hunter family drama.”
It sounded like possibly one person laughed.
“I’m going to go see if they can calm down just a bit for normal social interactions.” She smiled and excused herself from the table.
Don’t leave me!
Times like this reminded me of how young I really was. All I wanted to do was run to my room and hide and let my parents take care of it. But my parents had no idea what was going on. Everyone was staring at me, wondering what to do. At least the conversation in the hall could no longer be heard. I awkwardly cleared my throat.
“For those of you who don’t know, those are my soon-to-be mother and father in-law. They’re still adjusting to the idea.”
Mason laughed. “They don’t like anybody, Penny. Don’t worry about it.”
A few of James’ friends from college laughed too.
“Seriously,” Matt said. “I’m still not even sure they know my name and I’ve known them my whole life. So… are you going to go out there and argue with your new family too?”
“What exactly are they arguing about?” my father said.
I hadn’t told my parents about James’ parents so that they wouldn’t have preconceived notions going into meeting them. I just wanted everyone to get along. It didn’t seem like that was a realistic option though. It was time to tell them. “Could I talk to you and mom for a second?” I excused myself and walked into the kitchen. Rory and his friends were all awkwardly standing in there, most likely hiding from what was going on.
“Could you guys maybe go ahead and serve dessert? Hopefully your delicious food will distract everyone.”
“Sure thing.” Keira gave me a sympathetic smile and dropped the dish she had been scrubbing.
“In-laws,” Rory said with a shrug. “They’re the worst.”
Keira swatted his arm playfully. “You love my parents.”
He laughed and grabbed a tray of decadent looking desserts. “Mhm.”
She shook her head and grabbed one of the trays. The rest of his friends followed suit as my parents walked into the kitchen.
“What’s going on, sweetie?” my mom said. She looked shocked by what had just occurred with James’ parents.
“James has a… complicated relationship with his parents.” What was the best way to say this? “They never really supported his decisions growing up. And they don’t exactly support his decision to marry me.”
“When were you planning on telling us this?” my mom asked.
“I’m sorry. I just wanted you to make your own opinions of them. I had this idea in my head that we were all going to be this happy family. But I should have told you. James didn’t even want them to come to the wedding. I pushed him to invite them. This,” I said and gestured to the door,” is all my fault. They hate me. The worst part is that James thinks they hate him. And I know that’s not true, they just have a horrible way of showing that they care. I was just trying to fix it. I just wanted us to be able to get along.”
“Pen,” my dad said with a laugh. “Not everyone you meet is going to like you.”
“I know that. But they’re going to be my family. I thought they could at least pretend. Their son is getting married.”
“From what I can tell, you have a pretty great group of friends out there. That’s your new family. You can’t force something if it’s not meant to be, sweetie,” my mom said. “Now, what’s this about them thinking the wedding was off?”
“James and I had a fight last night.”