Andrea sensed I had something planned, so overruled Bethany’s request. As we played the game, I made it a point to ‘accidentally’ leave me cards in sight of Bethany more than once. She took the bait, giggling with satisfaction as she crossed off cards she saw I had. I pretended not to notice her outright cheating.
Sure enough, she guessed Colonel Mustard in the Kitchen with the Rope, winning the game. As we picked up the game she giggled… “Daddy, I could totally see your cards.”
I shook my head, feigning shock at her cheating. Andrea swapped out the game boards and began counting out the Monopoly money.
“Since we have cheaters in the house, let’s make life a little difficult. New rule for tonight, if you have to pay any money when you land on a space, then you also have to take off one article of clothing.”
“Hey no fair!” Andrea playfully protested. I remembered why. When she had redressed she had skipped her bra and panties meaning just two payouts would leave her nude.
Bethany giggled again. “I am really good at Monopoly!” she bragged. To me it didn’t matter as we would soon all be naked.
The first couple of trips around the board were uneventful as we each hurried to make quick property acquisitions. Finally, I was the first one to land on an owned property. Andrea cheered with glee, but was disappointed when I removed a single sock.
A few moves later it was Bethany who had to pay up. She pulled her hoodie over her head, but this time it was me who was disappointed to find her wearing a tank top underneath. I was not however disappointed to see her young body was apparently blessed with beyond-budding breasts.
Around the board again, and I acquired a few more properties, but ultimately ended up having to give up another sock.
Andrea made the mistake about bragging how she hadn’t paid out. On her very next turn she landed on property I had just bought. “Oh youuu!” she said glaring at me.
She contemplated, and decided to go with her jeans. She pulled her sweater down as low as it would go to keep as much covered as possible. She shimmied out of those tight pants. Try as she might she couldn’t avoid flashing us with a view of her pussy. Bethany blushed a little bit. Perhaps from the sight of Andrea, or perhaps knowing she would likely be in the same boat soon.
However, it was me who had to deal with my rules next. I pulled my t-shirt off, passing the die off to Bethany. She rolled doubles and escaped with a chance card that sent her to Go. He subsequent roll landed her right on one of my properties. She stood up and bravely unfastened her denim shorts. Underneath was a pair of purple and white striped panties.
A couple of turns later, Andrea faced her undoing. She landed on Park Place. Bethany triumphantly exclaimed “That one is mine.”
With nothing left to hide, Andrea stood up and slowly and seductively pulled up her purple sweater and tossed aside. My semi-erect cock moved to full on hard-on at the sight.
Bethany gasped. “Your boobs are big!”
“All of me is big honey!” Andrea said in a self-deprecating tone.
As the game continued Bethany had trouble keeping her eyes off Andrea’s nude body. While she was distracted, I skipped a space so I would have to remove a piece of clothing. I stood up and unfastened my jeans. I pulled them down over the huge bulge in my boxers.
Bethany stared at the bulge, seeming to be extremely curious but unsure what to say.
Her silence didn’t last…. “Noooo…” she cried as she managed to roll another double that took her straight onto one of the owned properties. She slipped off her tank top, revealing her pale breasts with light pink nipples. She was already at what I guessed was a B cup, but she wasn’t wearing a bra. She didn’t seem shy about being topless in front of us.
“Roll again…” Andrea urged.
Bethany eyed the spaces in front of her. She needed a total of four to hit a Community Chest space and avoid losing her last bit of clothing. She grimaced and rolled … a two and a three.
“Woohoo… take it off. Daddy is the winner.”
Bethany stood up and pushed her panties down. Her young pussy had a thin tuft of blonde curls at the top and pudgy outer lips.
“Very nice! Don’t you think Daddy?” Andrea commented.
“Very!” I agreed as Bethany sat down to begin picking up all the game pieces.
“Well Daddy you won, but I think it is only fair if you lose your underwear too.” Andrea continued.
“Fair enough.” I stood up and pulled down my boxers, kicking them aside. My throbbing manhood hung free.
Bethany stared wide-eyed. I grabbed the shaft and gently stroked the length.
“Mmmmm, what do you think of that Bethany?” Andrea asked.
Bethany was at a loss for words and struggled to respond. She completely forgot about the game board she was picking up. I let go of my cock and held out my hand. She blindly took it in her own. I guided her from the living area into Andrea’s bedroom. Andrea followed, closing the door behind us.
I gently guided Bethany to the bed and pushed her back. I knelt at the side of the bed and slowly kissed up her soft thighs. She shivered as my lips touched her.
“Mommy and Daddy are going to do things — things you can never tell anyone about.” Andrea instructed her.
Bethany nodded and squirmed as she could feel my warm breath on her untouched pussy.
Andrea gasped loudly as she watched me slip my tongue across Bethany’s little clit and then into her tiny pussy. “Mmmm Daddy…”
Bethany squirmed excitedly as she felt my tongue enter her virgin vagina. She tasted tangy with a sweet aftertaste.
I pushed my tongue deeper, and listened to a little whimper of excitement escape her mouth. She was quivering from the new sensations she was feeling.
I backed away and little Bethany arched her back, trying to follow my tongue.
“Come here Andrea, I want you to taste this pussy. Get her nice and wet, she is going to need all the wetness you can give her.”
Andrea laid back on the bed and directed Bethany to straddle her. Bethany climbed atop the cushion of Andrea’s 40Gs, supporting herself against the wall. Andrea grasped Bethany’s pale white, round ass in her hands and began to lick that tiny slit.
Bethany clawed at the wall as Andrea ate her first pussy expertly. She squirmed as Andrea didn’t let up.
My cock twitched and after a couple of minutes of watching I climbed onto the bed. I pulled Bethany off Andrea and laid her back on her back. I climbed on top of her. My throbbing dick brushed against her leg as I brought my mouth to hers. She kissed me, but was unprepared for my tongue slipping into her mouth. Awkward at first, she slowly got the hang of it. I then kissed down her neck and pulled one of her nipples into my mouth. She moaned loudly as she felt yet again a new experience.
I moved to the other nipple and felt her wet groin rub against my chest. She moaned loudly… “Daddy!”
I raised up, “Andrea, come here baby. Watch and enjoy.”
Andrea excitedly moved next to me on the bed.
I positioned my hard dick at Bethany’s virgin pussy.
“I am going to put this deep inside you, are you okay with that?”
She nodded, “Daddy, you can do whatever you want. I want you to do to me what you do to mommy.”
Both girls watched wide-eyed as I pushed forward. Bethany whimpered in pain as she felt me beginning to impale her. Her labia were wet with Andrea’s saliva.
My tip was in and I pushed deeper. Unlike Andrea, she was very tight. Her pussy clamped hard around my cock. She cried out and I stopped. She looked up at me through teary eyes, and I started to pull out. But I felt her hands clench my back. “No Daddy! Keep going! If mommy can do this, I can too.”
“Mommy isn’t this tight…”
Andrea pushed firmly on my lower back forcing me deeper. “She said she wants it, now fuck that little pussy.” she urged.
The wetness dissipated to slight dampness as I slipped deeper. I looked down at her soft pale skin spread before me. Bethany was a cute girl, already blossoming into a woman. If you had looked at her tits, you would have assumed she was older, but I knew better. I should have felt bad about it, but like others before she didn’t care about society’s rules. She didn’t care I was nearly four times her age… or married… or fucking other women. She was enjoying the positive attention of an authority figure and wanted to be sure I was happy.
I looked down at my cock and realized just how much she was stretching to fit me. I slowly pulled back, dragging my precum along the walls of her young slit. When I pushed forward again it lubricated my shaft. She moaned sensually as she felt me sliding more readily into her still tight cunt.
Andrea reached out to caress one of Bethany’s tits. “You know, today was my first time doing this too!”
“Really???” Bethany asked with surprise.
“Yeah, Daddy fucked me good. I was dripping with his cum all afternoon.
“What’s cum?” Bethany asked.
“You will find out soon enough. I am gonna fill your sweet little pussy.” I said as I slowly thrust into her.
“Mmmm… Daddy… is it like what animals do when they mate? Mom — ummm, my old mom — tried to explain it once to me. She came home with this stuff all over her shirt a couple of weeks ago. I was confused how it got there if it’s supposed to be for mating.”
Andrea laughed… “Ohhhh honey, if you only knew. But yes, it is the same thing.”
I pulled slowly out of Bethany’s pussy and fell back on the bed.
I pulled her onto me and lifted her chubby ass in my hands. Andrea grabbed my shaft and positioned it at Bethany’s swollen pussy lips. “Ride Daddy’s big dick!” Andrea commanded.
I moved my hands to Bethany’s hips, and began to bounce her roughly on my dick. My precum coated her insides as I shoved deep. Her pale pink nipples bounced furiously as I impaled her on my cock over and over.
Andrea had her fingers shoved deep in her own pussy as she reached over with her free hand and began to rub Bethany’s little clit.
I felt Bethany tense. This caused her pussy to clench tight at the base of my shaft. When she relaxed, my cum exploded deep into her young pussy. It plastered the walls and splattered deep into her womb. I grunted loudly as I filled her.
Bethany cried out with excitement. I had let my hands loosen my grip on her hips but she grabbed my shoulders and continued bouncing on me. She moaned “Oh Daddy! I don’t wanna stop…”
“Mmmmm you just came in her!” Andrea gasped excitedly. “You really fucked her and came in her!”
Bethany was thrashing on my dick at this point, keeping it from softening. I knew she was enjoying all the new sensations that were coursing through her body.
Andrea moved in behind Bethany, letting Bethany lean back against her soft body. I felt Andrea’s pussy-juice soaked fingers brush the underside of my plunging cock. I realized she was seeking Bethany’s tight ass hole.
Moments later it was obvious that she found it as Bethany tensed again and let out an unflattering howl of surprise. I felt Andrea’s knuckles brushing my ball sack as she fingered Bethany’s ass hole.
Bethany clawed at my skin and her body quivered. She groaned loudly as I felt my dick get coated by her young orgasm.
She collapsed forward against me, panting heavily as Andrea gently fingered her ass.
Bethany looked up at me as she squirmed. “Daddy. Did you like doing that with me?”
I kissed her forehead. “You are a fun little toy. Do you like Daddy fucking you?”
She writhed under Andrea’s continued touch. “I do!”
Andrea spoke up “So you like this girl I got you? And you thought her mother wouldn’t give her up. I knew she would! I knew this little pussy was ours to play with.” She gently pulled her finger from Bethany before slapping her round butt. “Okay, get off Daddy, let’s see how much cum he put in you.”
Bethany reluctantly slid off me. My cum gushed from between her swollen lips.
“Oh fuck! Daddy that load is huge.” Andrea exclaimed.
Bethany smiled proudly at the mess between her legs.
Andrea’s face suddenly clouded and she sighed loudly.
“What’s wrong?” I asked, confused by the abrupt mood change.
“Well now you have her you won’t want to fuck me. I mean her little tight pussy or getting fucked by my fat self. It is obvious what you will choose.” she lamented.
“Get over here. Stop being stupid, I loved you riding me earlier. I don’t mind you are ‘fat’ at all. I knew you were a big girl from the day we met. I want to fuck that fat pussy again, and those huge tits, and hell I will even try to bury it that big ass.” I assured her.
She looked at me shocked but excited. The night was still early and she realized the three of us would not be sleeping tonight.