“Have you ever thought about a third-party joining you and Lucas during sex before?” Anita asked, smirking at me as she raised her eyebrows in a questioning gesture.
I moved my focus from the TV as I turned to look at Anita. My other best friend, Regina, just giggled as she chewed her popcorn.
“What do you mean by a third party?” I asked.
“You know what I’m talking about, Hope. Like a threesome.” Anita emphasized.
“No shit.”
“What?” Regina said. “Don’t tell me you’ve never imagined another guy having sex with you, including your boyfriend at the same time?”
I blushed and looked back at the TV. I’m not the most experienced girl out there, but I sure as hell have thought about a threesome. I’ve thought about sharing my fiance, Lucas, with some other guy. In fact, there is this particular guy I’m so ashamed to mention.
“You don’t have to be shy, Hope. I know you like Ian. I see the way you look at him. I know you want him to fuck you.” Anita said.
I turned to look at her as I shot her a playful glare.
“You can’t say that.” I whispered.
“Say what? That you have a big fucking crush on your boyfriend’s twin brother? It’s cool, Gina is aware. We all are. We see the way you look at him, and during one of our sleepovers you whispered his name in your sleep.” Anita said.
I bit my lip and looked away.
“Hmm… you little thot.” Regina said, giggling.
“It’s no big deal, Hope. We’ve all been there. Every single girl wants to fuck Ian. God, he’s so hot and quiet. He’s shy, but fuck, he’s good in bed.”
God, she sounded like Alison from pretty little liars.
“Please don’t tell me you’ve been involved with him.” I said, staring at my two best friends.
“Yeah, I have,” Anita said. “Twice. The first one was solo sex. We did it in his apartment, and the second was Regina and I. A fucking threesome. He was hot and big, and a sex machine.”
“God…” I shook my head and lifted my legs from the floor as I pulled it to my chest.
“So you really wanted Ian inside you, yeah?” Regina spook. I ignored them, thinking about my fiance’s twin brother in between my legs, peppering kisses up my neck with his mouth around my nipples.
“You fucking slut! You’re thinking about it.” Anita said laughing, including Regina.
“Fuck you guys so much. I’m going to get a drink.” I said and stood up as I walked to the kitchen.
Okay, a little story about me. I was 24 and I was engaged to Lucas Sawyer. This hot accountant that I fell in love with three years ago when I was still in college. He was the best thing that’s ever happened to me. Lucas and I were like opposites considering the fact that I was a shy, nerdy goody two shoes, and I’ve never really liked parties, and I sometimes secretly fucked my celebrity crushes in my head, and I’ve always craved a threesome but I didn’t have the balls to get myself involved.
Lucas and I dated for a year before we finally had sex. He popped my cherry to be precise and I loved him. And then there’s his twin brother. This super, sexy, hot lawyer, with the body of Gods, blonde haired, six foot 2, well-chiseled, with a smile like the angels, and the eyes like the ocean. He was everything my sex life had been missing. I’d secretly fantasized about the two of us doing the dirty without Lucas really finding out. I knew I couldn’t have him. I was in love with his younger twin brother and we were getting married this summer.
Ian was nothing like Lucas. In fact, Ian was more like me. He barely partied and he was so committed to his job, and since I knew the guy, he barely slept around. He dated this millionaire’s daughter for a while and they split about a year ago and yet I barely ever see him with any woman. And the most annoying part was as much as I’ve always secretly admired him and lusted over him, he never saw me as anything more than just his future sister-in-law. The girl his brother was about to marry.
It was fucking annoying.
“Hey, girls.” I heard the voice of my fiance from the living room. I quickly took a sip from my bottle of cold water to stop me from blushing.
“Hey.” My best friends echoed.
My fiance, Lucas, was good-looking. He was hot, but he was nothing like his older twin brother. They looked like normal brothers and they didn’t even look alike. Ian was two inches taller than Lucas. Where my fiance lacked a good amount of physical fitness, Ian had a lot of it. It was impossible not to lust after him.
“Hi, Ian.” I heard Anita’s voice.
Ian’s here? Shit!
“Hey.” His deep, gruff, yet sexy voice greeted my friends.
“Where’s my birthday girl?” Lucas called. I guessed that was my cue to join them.
I closed the bottle of water and dropped it on the kitchen counter before joining them in the living room. My eyes first landed on Ian who was looking around his brother’s apartment like it was the first time he was here. I haven’t seen him for a while though. I heard from Lucas Ian traveled to Italy for a job and I guess he was back. God, he looked better than I last saw him. His chin and jaws were peppered with blonde facial hair. He spotted a dark brown jacket and black pants. God, he was gorgeous.
“Hey, baby.” Lucas greeted, wrapping his arms around me as he kissed me.
“Hey,” I whispered into Lucas’s ear as I hugged him back. My eyes landed on Ian’s blue orbs which were already staring at me.
He surprisingly gave me a small smirk.
“You’re home. How was your outing?” I asked Lucas as we pulled apart.
“Great. And guess who’s back?” Lucas said with a big smile on his face as he acknowledged his older brother.
“Hi, Hope.” Ian greeted me.
I blushed a little and I hated myself for it.
“Hey, Ian. You’re back. How was your trip?”
“Good. You look beautiful.” Ian said, and he surprised me again by hugging me.
I stilled at once, with my hands hanging loose beside me, and my heart doing a backflip. This was the first time we were hugging. Ian’s never been the most social person out there so there was no reason for a hug. We only talked sometimes and gave each other a handshake, and not a hug. Feeling a little awkward and taken aback, I hugged Ian back as he pressed me against his hard body.
Fucking hell. What I would give to just run my fingertips on his solid chest.
“All you have to do is say the words,” Ian whispered into my ear as he pulled away, leaving me breathless and dumbfounded.
What did he mean by all I had to do was just say the words? Did I just say that out loud? Me willing to give anything to have my fingertips on his skin.
I am losing my mind.
Ian gave me a secret wink as Lucas said something. My best friends giggled amongst themselves as they stood up.
“We’re gonna leave. Big day tomorrow at the office.” Anita said as she grabbed her bag.
“See you, Hope. We’re gonna talk more about that stuff tomorrow at work.” Anita winked at me as she left with Regina.
“So, who’s hungry?” Ian asked when we heard the front door shut.
***
“You know, I was wondering…” Lucas said later that night.
We were both in our nightwear and cuddled up against each other in bed. His arm was around my waist and my hand was running alongside his stomach.
“What?” I whispered.
“Have you ever thought about sharing me with someone? Like a guy?”
“What?” I sat up at once.
Why would he ask me that? What was I supposed to say? And why was he even asking me that?
“You don’t have to freak out, honey. Sharing me with someone, or me sharing you with someone doesn’t mean I don’t love you. I do and I’ll always love you.” Lucas said as he sat up and cupped my cheek.
“Why would you ask me that? Why would you think that?”
“Nothing. I just…” He sighed and laid back down. “I just want you to be sincere with me. It doesn’t have to mean anything. I just thought it was time we talked about it.”
“Would you like to share me with someone?”
“I asked first.” Lucas winked at me.
I knew Lucas loved me. He would never do anything to hurt me. In the years that we’ve spent together, I’ve come to notice he would do almost anything for me. But telling him I’ve fantasized about fucking him and his brother at the same time might ruin my relationship, maybe I just have to be honest with him without telling him I wanted to share him with his brother, and I’ve thought about it not once, not twice, but every chance that I get.
I licked my lips and lay down next to Lucas.
“You won’t be mad if I’m honest, right?”
“No.” He gave me a reassuring smile.
“Okay. Yes. Yes, I’ve imagined a threesome with you and some other guy.”
“Wow, you’re naughty, baby,” Lucas said.
I blushed.
“Stop.” I giggled. “What about you? Have you?”
Lucas was quiet for a minute before speaking up.
“I have. Once.”
“Who?”
“One question at a time sweetheart. It’s my turn to ask you a question, and not your turn.”
I rolled my eyes at his tactics.
“Okay. Go one. Ask your question.”
“Who do you have in mind?” Lucas asked, turning his head to look at me. “You can be sincere with me, Hope. It’s your birthday week, remember?”
I sighed and looked away from my fiance. Ian was sleeping in the guest bedroom two bedrooms from ours, and the thought of him spanking me turned me the fuck on even when I was sleeping next to Lucas.
“Ian.” I spat.
“Hmm.” He muttered and turned to look at me with a small smile.
“Are you mad at me? It’s…”
“Hope, breathe.” Lucas turned to look at me as he cupped my cheek.
“I love you, Hope. And I’ve also thought about sharing you with my brother, not once, not twice.”
I smiled.
“Thank God. I thought I was in trouble.” I said giggling.
“You’re not. So what do you have in mind for your birthday?”
***
It was my birthday and Lucas threw me a surprise party. He invited all of my work friends to come and celebrate with me at our house. I danced with my best friends, my fiance, and I cut my cake.
There was alcohol and music and it was one of the best birthday parties ever. The conversation Lucas and I had about sharing each other with his twin brother was still fresh in my mind. I couldn’t stop thinking about it and now I even dream about it. I dreamed about Ian and I going at it in my kitchen as he pounded into me from behind. I woke up sweating that night. And ever since that night Lucas and I had a conversation about a threesome, I haven’t laid my eyes on Ian. He left our house early the following morning.
Ian didn’t show up at my birthday party either. I was worried. I was worried that Lucas might have talked to him about a threesome and my confession since they were twins and he was disgusted by me.
Who wouldn’t? I would if I found out my future in-law wanted to sleep with me and my partner. I told my friends about the conversation I had with Lucas that night and they told me to stop thinking about it. That it was nothing.
I couldn’t stop thinking about it. I wished I wasn’t honest with him that night. I just had this feeling that Ian was avoiding me. Lucas told me Ian was busy with work and that he traveled.
During the late hours of my party where everyone was already leaving and most people were drunk out their asses, Lucas wrapped his arms around me and told me he wanted to give me my birthday present. At the beginning of the party, Lucas told me my birthday present was coming and it was a surprise.
“What’s it?” I asked him as he led me up the stairs with me blindfolded.
“If I tell you, then, it’s going to ruin the surprise.” He whispered as he continued to lead me.
The party attendees were already gone by then, and a slow song was playing through the house. I heard a door open and Lucas gently pushed me forward.
“Okay. So don’t take it off, okay?”
“Alright. Now I’m really anxious. What’s it?”
Lucas laughed and I heard shuffling around. A minute or so later, I felt Lucas behind me as he started to untie my blindfold. He slowly untied it and removed it as I blinked my eyes a couple of times while I tried to get used to my environment and the bright light. We were in our bedroom, Lucas and I’s bedroom. I glanced around and my eyes surprisingly fell on a very familiar person wrapped as a birthday present.
Wait, he was my birthday present?
What was going on?
“Surprise! And happy birthday, beautiful.” Lucas said and kissed me on the lips before pulling away and stepping back a little.
I stared down at Ian wrapped up as my birthday present. What I didn’t understand was why Ian was being gifted to me. Why was he wrapped as my present?
“You might wanna open your birthday present.” Ian said.
I was dumbfounded and caught off guard. I least expected this and I was confused. I slowly approached Ian-the-birthday gift as I started to tear off the wrap around him. He stared at me and watched me as I tore off the gift wrap one after the other. It took me time considering the fact that he was a full person. As I tore the wrap apart, his naked chest came into view, all golden skin and toned with little chest tattoos scattered around his smooth chest.
Fuck, he was beautiful.
“You might wanna continue unwrapping me, sweetheart.” Ian’s voice was deep. It sounded so husky, sexy, and filled with hunger.
I gulped, with my hand on his toned chest. I took a deep breath and turned to look at Lucas, he gave me the go-ahead and a naughty smirk. I turned to look at Ian and continued unwrapping him. Wrap after wrap, and I have finally unwrapped my birthday present. What I didn’t expect was just out there for me to look at. Ian was standing bare before, naked from head to toe and very much rock hard. My eyes stared at his bare cock in shock.
What is going on?
I had no fucking idea.
I stepped backwards a little as I turned to look at Lucas who was smirking at me and slowly undressing himself.
“Ian’s your birthday present, honey.” Lucas said.
“What?” I’m struck right there.
“My tongue, my lip, my fingers, and even my dick Is all yours tonight, Hope. You’re gonna do to me whatever you want, and we…” Ian nodded to his twin brother, my fiance. “… we’re gonna fuck you senseless tonight, Hope, till you won’t be able to walk and scream anymore, and till you’ll be sore when morning comes.” Ian said, and just like that, my knees buckled, my toes curled, and my panties were soaked.
I turned to look at my fiance and he was completely naked, just like my brother-in-law who turned out to be my birthday present.
“Why don’t you be a good girl and get on your knees? We want you to get on all fours and crawl towards us. You’re gonna blow us at the same time.” Ian said.
Both men stood in front of me like predators and I was just the horny prey. I reached behind me and unzipped my dress. Slowly, I pulled it down and it fell to the floor. I stepped out of it, and with nothing but my panties on and my heels, I went on my knees like a good girl and crawled towards these two men.