Kathleen and Sherry crawled up beside us and began licking her tits and sucking her nipples. Beth couldn’t help but like this. She loved to have her tits sucked and licked. She stared at me in defiance, before her wall crumbled and she bit her lower lip. Yes, indeed, she was now enjoying this. I picked up my pace and felt an orgasm approaching. Hers was already starting when mine soon hit. I didn’t pull out as she always wanted me to. Instead I flooded her pussy with my cum, and her eyes got big and round. She was completely shocked that I did this.
While I rested, Kathleen and Sherry untied Beth, and flipped her over doggy style, in front of me, and retied her hands to the headboard. Beth tried to fight them off, but they overpowered her, and outnumbered her. My cousins won the battle easily. I thrust my semi-hard cock back into her pussy, to soak up our juices, and then entered her tight asshole. She screamed in pain, and cried loudly, but I kept repeating my actions, until her ass was well lubricated. The tightness of her ass and her clenching up made it very tight, and exciting, because she didn’t want this even more than she didn’t want me to cum in her pussy, or mouth.
I began fucking her ass as she begged me to stop.
“Please, Mike! Don’t do this! I’m sorry for fucking Sherry’s husband!” She pleaded.
Sherry laughed, and I slapped Beth’s ass roughly causing her to wince in pain.
“You going to be a good girl and shut up, or do you want more of this?” I asked.
“Please, don’t!” She cried.
I slapped her other asscheek harder than the original and she cried louder. I began thrusting into her ass harder, breaking her resistance and causing her asshole to loosen up. One thing is for sure, before today her asshole was never fucked. Now it was being broken wide open. I spread her asscheeks as I thrust in and out at a good pace. I kept it slower than when I fucked her pussy. I wanted her to be taught a lesson.
I grabbed her hanging tits and molded them to my hands. I pulled on her nipples hard and she moaned. Her head soon hung in acceptance of her fate. She no longer fought me, but still didn’t seem to like the fucking I gave her ass. I picked up the pace as I felt my cum approaching the head of my cock. I let the first few jets go into her ass, before pulling out. I quickly went up to her head, where Kathleen and Sherry held her head to the side, and forced her mouth open and unleashed the last streams of my cum to enter her mouth.
“Now, I think we are even. What do you say, slut?” I asked Beth.
“Do you think we can do this again sometime?” Beth asked, shocking us all, as she partially smiled with how horny she was.