Giggling, she continued, “So we started kissing and making out, and then one thing led to another. She told me later that she liked to go to parties and make the boys think that they were going to have a chance with her, and then take a girl home. She said it got her all worked up and wet.”
“Did you ever do it again?” Marie asked.
“No, no,” Molly said, shaking her finger, “Your rules said one question. I answered it. Your turn Mark.”
Everyone laughed at that. Mark shrugged and looked over at Duncan. “I’ve never had any body piercings,” he said with a grin.
Everyone looked around. No one was drinking.
“Dammit,” Kelly said, bringing her wine glass up. “Mark, you ass,” she said, taking a drink.
The entire room, save for Duncan of course, was staring at her with their mouths open. “You have piercings?” Marie asked.
“Well obviously,” Kelly responded. “I took a drink, didn’t I.”
“This I gotta hear,” Drake said, taking a drink.
“Hey, hey,” Duncan said. “Mark gets to ask the question.”
Mark grinned. “Tell us the story of how you got pierced. Like I wouldn’t jump at the chance to know that story,” he said, grinning widely at Duncan.
Kelly sighed and looked up at her husband.
“I’m sorry, Baby,” he said, kissing her on the forehead. She was only blushing slightly by that time though.
“Well, again, back in college before I met my husband,” she said, glancing over at Molly. “I was briefly dating this other guy named Cooper. This was just after I got to college and got away from my parents. I was just as much of a servant then as I am now, but I wasn’t aware that some guys would take advantage of it. I was very naïve,” she said, glancing to her left at Becky.
Duncan chuckled and nodded. “We both were,” he whispered.
“Are,” Marie clarified with a grin.
“So Cooper tells me that he has this thing for nipple piercings and wants me to get some. I’m a servant at heart, and I suppose part of me was wanting to rebel against my tyrannical mother, so I said yes. I went and had it done and it took about two weeks for them to heal, but the funny part off the story is that besides the fact that he insisted on paying for them, I caught him kissing another woman and broke it off before they healed.”
“So you got free nipple piercings,” Becky said.
“I got free piercings,” Kelly confirmed.
“Nice,” Becky replied. “I’d love to ask you about them, and maybe see what they look like later, if that’s okay. I’ve been thinking about getting mine done.”
Kelly blushed but nodded. “We’ll see,” she said. “Okay Ed,” she said, desperate for the attention to be off her.
“I’ve never had sex with more than three people at once,” he said, smiling at his wife as they both took a drink.
“Too easy,” she said, swatting at his shoulder. “I’ve never been tied up,” she said quickly. Becky, Molly and Marie all took a drink, as did Ed and Mark.
Molly’s turn came up then and she thought for a second. “I’ve never had sex with two men at once,” she said smiling.
Marie sighed and took a drink. Ed chuckled beside her. Both of them then looked at Molly, waiting for her question. The game continued for several more rounds. Ed and Marie were asked the bulk of the questions and they all pertained to the lifestyle that they’d chosen to lead. Everyone was curious, as they had come to expect and they were both very forthcoming.
Duncan knew that Kelly was still nervous about being singled out, and sure enough, several rounds later Mark had his chance.
“I’ve never been a natural redhead,” he said, grinning at Kelly. She sighed and took a drink, feeling more than a little tipsy by that time.
“Go ahead then, ask your question,” she said, her hand stroking Duncan’s leg softly.
Mark smiled. “Show us your nipple rings,” he said.
She smirked at him as the others laughed.
“First, that’s not a question. Second, even if you’d asked if you could see them, I’d still say no. I answered it, and I did so honestly. No,” she said with a grin.
“Fine,” he said, “Are they barbells or rings?”
She looked skyward for a second in mock irritation and looked back at Duncan. He shrugged.
“Rings,” she said, blushing.
Mark grinned and let the game continued. When it got to Marie though, she apparently decided to get naughty again.
“I’ve never had a penis bigger than 8 inches,” she said, smiling first at Kelly and then Duncan.
Duncan sighed and took a swig of his beer as everyone guffawed and the guys laughed uncomfortably.
“Please don’t ask him to prove it,” Drake said, shifting in his seat.
Marie cocked her head and thought for a second. “How big is it?” she asked.
Duncan sighed and blushed. “Jeez, Marie,” he said nervously. The ladies were giggling and the guys were laughing nervously for him.
“I dunno,” he said. “I’ve never measured the damn thing. Ask Kelly.”
“ME?!” Kelly said loudly, leaning up to slap him on the shoulder. “Like I’m going to know how to answer that question.”
He chuckled and pulled her back to his chest. “I think we’ve had enough of the games for tonight,” he said.
“I’ll have to wait for proof then,” Molly said playfully.
“Oh, no, that guy has a cannon in his pants,” Mark confirmed. “I’ve known him longer than anyone. Back in college, before he met Kelly, we were at our first college party…”
“Goddamnit Mark!” Duncan said, blushing slightly.
“He got a little hammered that night and in the middle of a beer pong game, he comes up and thunks it down on the table, still in his boxers of course. I was just like, Goddamnit Dunc’!”
Everyone laughed again. Marie saw Duncan and Kelly growing more uncomfortable and suggested they end the game and just talk.
*****
Kelly
They all visibly relaxed a little then, but the conversation stayed sexual. Kelly would rather have it stay on something a little less risqué, but their friends were a horny group, apparently.
Everyone had several questions for Marie and Ed, and now that the ice had been broken, weren’t afraid to ask.
“Look, you guys seem reasonably curious, but we have to warn you, we don’t normally swing with friends. If something were to go wrong or feelings were to get hurt then friendships can suffer,” Ed said after answering perhaps the thirtieth question that night.
“I don’t know,” Marie said, turning and looking at him as she leaned easily into him on one of the couches. “I think in this case it might enhance the experience.”
Molly was nodding. “I think that since we’re so close, maybe it’ll enhance the pleasure.” She turned and looked at her husband. “What do you think?”
He shrugged. “As long as I don’t cross swords with any of these guys,” he said, eliciting a laugh from everyone.
“Look, it’s a big leap for everyone,” Marie said. “If you are interested, there are a few parties coming up that you can attend with us. You don’t have to participate, but you can certainly watch.”
“Watch you and Ed have sex with other people?” Kelly said.
“Well if you wanted to, but obviously, there will be other people there,” she replied.
“So what, is there gonna be people in masks, some weird dark music,” Mark asked.
Ed and Marie both chuckled and shook their heads. “No, that was a Stanley Kubrick wet dream, not reality.”
“The reality is that it’s normally just an evening that starts out like ours did, except there’s sex at the end of it.”
“Well,” Becky said, glancing at Mark. “We can always start here among friends and see if we like it, and then try other things,” she said to him.
He shrugged and glanced over at Duncan.
“I think Kelly and I still have to talk over how far into this we want to go,” Duncan began. “I mean, we were both so sheltered growing up, sex was dirty and forbidden. Kelly wearing skimpier clothes and talking openly about sex is a huge leap for us, and now we’ve progressed to admitting stuff to our friends. I think we need some time to process all of this.”
“I couldn’t agree more,” she said to him. “I mean, we’re both obviously wanting to expand our horizons, but I don’t think we’re going to be jumping in the sack with anyone. At least not tonight,” she said, giggling as everyone whistled and laughed in surprise.
“Of course you guys should talk it over,” Marie confirmed. “Take your time. We’re not going to stop any time soon, so you have plenty of time. If you decide that this is something you are interested in and would like us to hold your hands, so to speak, we’d both be happy to. The Lifestyle is wonderful, but it’s not for everyone. You should communicate with each other, or there will be jealousy. There can’t be any secrets. It can also destroy a marriage, so be sure that you want to do this. For us, it’s only made us stronger.”
“I’ve got an idea,” Ed said. “It’s not another game, but it is something that will bring us closer together and will allow us to play a little, while everyone talks with their partner and decides if this is what they want.”
Everyone nodded and seemed interested so he continued.
“I think we can issue some challenges via group text.”
“How do you mean?” Becky asked as she pulled out her phone.
“Well, say that Molly issues a challenge. First one to have sex with their spouse or lover in a public place and post proof, wins.”
“Wins what?” Kelly asked.
“Well, I dunno. The challenge? Maybe we can keep track of a point system for some kind of eventual reward. Like a day at the spa for the ladies, or tickets to a game for the fellas.”
“Mmm, that sounds nice,” Marie said, kissing him. “I like this idea.”
“So, about those nipple piercings,” Becky said. “Mind if I take a look?”
Kelly blushed slightly but shrugged.
“Yeah I think we all need to see, for science,” Drake said.
“Fuck science! I just wanna see her titties,” Mark said with a wide grin.