John chuckled, nodding. “Yeah,” he said. “She’s so… full of life and… just… so passionate and caring. I’ve been there when she was hurt in the past. Some guy she really liked and sounded promising never called her back, or some girl at school mentioned her being a slut.”
Dex nodded. He’d heard the stories before.
“I’ll tell you what though, man, I might be perfect for Donna, but I’ll be damned if you aren’t perfect for Jessie. That’s how I know you’ll be okay with all her extracurricular activities and shit.”
Dex laughed. “Shit, I hope so,” he replied honestly.
“I mean, hell motherfucker, you get to fuck every woman that she fuckin’ knows. You can’t let this little bastard have a turn with her sometime?” he asked, grabbing his crotch and grinning.
Dex laughed again, nodding. “I hear you bud. It makes me feel so fuckin’ selfish. You practically beg me to nail Donna, and I get bent out of shape over a blowjob and shit.”
John shrugged and patted him on the shoulder. “Don’t sweat it too much, man. Not everyone is built to be able to handle it. There’s not that many guys that can handle their girl steppin’ out with another hombre.”
Donna came over then, looking seductively at the two, then kissed them both in turn. “I’m about to start pushing her,” she said.
“Jessie?” he asked, drawing a nod from the brunette vixen.
“If I’m going to make this happen as naturally as possible, I’m going to need to find one of them to help me to get her to misbehave a bit. Any suggestions?”
Dex hadn’t thought of that and looked over at the group of guys.
“Ronnie?” he asked. “She’s already done stuff with him, so it’s not like it would be a stretch for her.”
“I’ll see if I can stoke the fire a bit after I talk privately with him and Lacey,” she said.
“Okay,” he said, taking a deep breath.
He’d figured that if he saw Jessie and Ronnie in a compromising situation and it bothered him, it would be easier to deal with since she’d gone out with the guy before.
“I appreciate your help,” he said.
“Oh, I plan to get something out of this. You and John are going to both have me at the same time,” Donna said. “No one else, just you two.”
John nodded emphatically. “We can replay the morning after you sucked his dick the first time, but this time Dex can actually fuckin’ come in the room.”
“Ooo,” Donna said, turning winking at him. “That’s such a good idea baby.”
Kissing John again, she turned and kissed Dex as well, before walking off into the party to go and make some trouble. Dex began to wonder if he’d bitten off more than he could chew.
*****
Jessie
After Dex and John hopped out at the liquor store, Jessie turned to Erin and Cass.
“She told you about her and Dex?” she asked curiously.
Cass leaned forward a bit and nodded.
“I told her about you and me too,” Erin added.
“My slutty sister’s life seems to revolve around sex ever since she started going out with Alec,” Cass said.
“Oh, shut up,” Erin replied. “I know damn well that you were in your room every day after school sucking off your old boyfriend, and don’t even try and deny it. Is it okay to swallow, Erin? What does cum taste like? Will it make me fat?”
Cass rolled her eyes as Jessie giggled at the two.
“Oh stop,” she said. “I did, but that was for just a few months and I only asked you those things because it was new.”
“You just need to forget about him and find a nice guy to hook up with tonight. Why do you think I suggested Dex?”
Cass sighed. “What is wrong with you? His girlfriend is right there, Erin.”
“She’s fine with it,” Erin said dismissively.
Jessie giggled, then looked over. “Cass, I’m not going to tell you that you should sleep with Dex. I’m just going to say that… I love my boyfriend with all my heart, and you’re more than welcome to fool around with him if you want. My life didn’t start being about sex when I met him, but it certainly made it much more enjoyable. Dex is…”
“Special,” Donna said, cutting into the conversation, “and not just because he’s hung like a horse.”
The girls, including Cass, laughed at the description.
“So, wait,” she said a few seconds after the laughter stopped. “You’ve all been with him?
“Mmmhmm,” the three girls said excitedly.
“And he’s that good?”
“Mmmhmm,” came the repeated answer, drawing laughs.
“Sweetie, he’s not going to fall in love with you,” Erin said. “He’s not going to call you the next day. He’s not going to break your heart. If you want to get with him tonight, you can. He’s going to make you cum so hard your legs quiver for a good half hour, but when you see him and Jessie together for a while, you’ll know that they are in it for good.”
“Aww,” Jessie said. “That’s so sweet.”
“Dex has a good grasp on doing the right thing at the right time when he’s with a girl, and it’s like… he’s completely focused on you,” Donna said as she looked back at the three from the front seat.
“But she’s keeping it from Alec, you’re keeping it from John. Aren’t y’all scared that they’ll find out?”
Jessie giggled. “John is very aware that Donna sleeps with Dex,” Jessie said.
“As for Alec…” Erin said, “let’s just say that he likes his games.”
Jessie didn’t know what that meant but figured Erin would tell her when if it was relevant.
“So, you’re okay with people just… sleeping with your boyfriend. Don’t you… like… think he’s going to fall for someone else?”
Jessie shook her head. “Of course not. I know he loves me. It oozes out of his pores and I love him just as much. I think we’re stronger because of our sex life.”
Cass glanced past Jessie and cleared her throat as the guys came out of the building.
At the party a few hours later, Jessie was casually sipping at her glass of wine and talking to Lacey when Donna and Erin came up. The party had been going on for a while, and the barbecue had turned out to be some hamburgers and hotdogs that weren’t all that good compared to what Papa had made for everyone at Dex’s birthday party.
Donna asked Lacey to come with her for a moment as Erin sat down next to Jessie.
“So, I just wanted to thank you for backing me up with Cass. She’s been such a drag since she dumped her boyfriend.”
Jessie looked over at her new friend. “Oh, you know me. I’m happy to let anyone have Dex for a bit.”
Erin’s approval of the idea was obvious, and the two exchanged a knowing glance. There was a roar of a laughter at something, and the two glanced over for a few seconds before continuing the conversation.
“So, what games does Alec like to play?” Jessie asked as Erin looked up at her.
Erin sighed in amusement, then surprised her by looking around before answering.
“So… the weekend thing… where I seduced Dex in the middle of the night… was planned,” Erin said, causing Jessie’s jaw to drop open.
“What?” she whispered.
Erin nodded. “It was Alec’s idea. He… he’s got a certain fetish. He likes to tell me to do dirty things,” she said.
Jessie was genuinely surprised. “I can’t believe you guys planned that! Did he intend on seducing me that night?”
“Oh… no, no, no,” Erin assured her. “No, the plan was for me to fuck Dex and then act like it was a secret between us.”
Jessie scrunched up her face in confusion. “But why?”
Erin giggled in response and sighed. “He said he wanted to feel like we’re breaking rules. He does this from time to time. He makes me go and flash a group of guys at a bar, or like… fuck me in a public place. It’s about making me do dirty things, really, and making it feel like he’s doing something he shouldn’t. This was the freakiest thing he’s ever made me do.”
“So… he doesn’t actually want to have a threesome?” she asked.
“Huh? No, he still does. He just wants me to do what he says more. He’s… different,” she said. “For him it’s more about watching me, but he definitely still wants to have fun too.”
“I get the fetish,” Jessie said. “I just wanted to make sure he still wanted us both at the same time.”
Erin snickered, rolling her eyes at Jessie. “Believe me, that hasn’t changed at all!”
Jessie giggled, then saw Donna gesturing for her and Erin to follow. She smirked and stood, grabbing Erin’s hand and heading over to where Donna was. As they approached, they saw that Donna and several of the others were playing some kind of drinking game. Reaching up, Donna yanked her down into a chair before Jessie could get away.
Over the next half-hour, while new people continued to arrive, Jessie did very poorly at the game, and she finally had to bow out to go and take a break, or else she was going to be too drunk. Heading to the kitchen, she got some water and drank it quickly, then refilled her glass.
“This way girls,” Donna called, leading Erin, Lacey, Sandy, Cass, and a girl that Jessie couldn’t remember the name of.
Jessie giggled, seeing Ronnie following along, but noticed none of the other guys were with him. He looked like he wanted to go back and hang out with the rest of the guys. She was surprised that more girls weren’t coming in, knowing how persuasive Donna could be.
“I’ve got a volunteer for us,” Donna said, coming into the kitchen where Jessie was standing, giggling and shaking her head at her.
“What are you doing?” Jessie asked.
“We’re gonna do some shots,” Donna explained, grinning. “You’ve got to check this out. John thought this would be fun!”
The girls all came into the kitchen, followed by Ronnie, and Jessie found that they were relatively secluded from the rest of the group. Most of the other people were either outside, or in other parts of the lake house.
Donna opened the fridge and got out a bowl of cut limes, then went and grabbed the saltshaker from the counter, and produced a bottle of Tequila from somewhere.
“Oh shit,” Ronnie said, grinning. “I ain’t gonna want none of that,” he said.
“It’s not for you,” Donna said. “Shut up and hop up on the counter.” She turned and looked at Lacey. “You sure it’s okay?”
Lacey grinned and nodded. “Go ahead, he’ll love it!”
Ronnie looked over at Jessie inquisitively, and she shrugged, smirking. He sighed and hopped up on the countertop, scooting back so that he wasn’t hanging off the edge.