Jessie
Smiling as she shut the door, she turned to head back to her room. Inside, she pulled on a pair of panties, but then heard her tummy rumbling. That combined with her head being in the clouds over Dexter’s revelation, she forgot to get dressed the rest of the way.
Turning, she left the room and started a pot of coffee for Donna, then got in the fridge and started to try and figure out what was for breakfast.
Donna’s door opened, but bending down as she was, she didn’t see who came out. She stood up, and looked to the right toward Donna’s door, but then saw someone behind her out of the corner of her eye.
John’s rough finger slid down the side of her panties and she smirked, leaning forward to look in the fridge.
“Pancakes or eggs and bacon?” she asked.
“Eggs and bacon, please,” he replied.
She nodded, reaching for the eggs but having to steady herself as he slid one of his rough digits over her anus and then back again.
After a few seconds, she managed to pull the food out and set it on the counter, John following her.
“Wait,” she said, holding up a hand. He stopped instantly, looking surprised.
“What’s up?” he asked. “We okay?”
She smiled. “We are, but you have to know something before you get me all worked up and I forget. If you can get Donna in here, I’ll tell you both at the same time.”
He nodded and turned to head to Donna’s room.
“Gah, fucker, quit!” Donna yelled, causing Jessie to smile.
A few seconds later Donna was pushed forward, and Jessie started to cook.
“Jessie needs to tell us something,” he said.
“Oh. Well you could have said that, cock-stain,” Donna said, punching him in the stomach.
He doubled over with a grunt of pain and steadied himself on the door frame.
“We can talk over breakfast,” Jessie said, and went about making it for the three of them. After ten minutes or so, she had three plates of eggs, bacon, and toast and sat down as John brought over some OJ for the three.
After a few bites of food, she started to tell them what happened.
“Something happened that shouldn’t have, and you guys need to know about it, since it could have affected us all. It’s semi-serious, so just listen and let me finish,” she said.
They both nodded, concerned glances passing between them.
“First, Dexter and I are okay, and you two aren’t in trouble or anything,” she clarified, hoping to put them at ease. “John, you’ve already heard part of this story, but I’m going to explain everything so there aren’t any misunderstandings. I’m sorry if it gets repetitive.”
He nodded, looking a bit concerned.
“Saturday at Dex’s party, I accidentally crossed some lines that I shouldn’t have. You both know how I can sometimes get in over my head when I get flirty, and I’ve always been super-flirty with Dexter’s dad. Dex told me a little bit after we started dating that it was okay for me to flirt with him and make him feel desired, and I even got him to jerk off for me once or twice because I’d started to clean their house naked for them.”
She ate a few more bites and took a drink, seeing them doing the same but still listening.
“Well, I guess I didn’t realize just how pent up he actually was from not having sex. Plus, all the naked girls at the party didn’t help. When I got stung by the fire ant, he took me inside and doctored it up. When he was done, I was sitting in a precarious position and…”
“Precarious position?” Donna asked.
Jessie nodded, but then demonstrated on the counter behind her before sitting back down and eating some more.
“Yeah, that’s pretty precarious,” John agreed.
Jessie nodded. “I’m dense sometimes, you guys,” she said, shrugging. “So, he starts looking like he’s having trouble breathing or something and sort of just… yanks me off the counter and shoves his cock in me.”
“Oh my God!” Donna said, her eyes wide.
“I know,” Jessie said. “I was shocked at first too, but I instantly knew he was upset by what he was doing, and he kept apologizing. I’m not really doing justice to how intense and sexual it must have been for him. I mean… he must have been thinking, “Here’s this naked little slut that’s flashing her pussy at me like it’s nothing.” How does a guy not take advantage of that?”
She sighed. “So, after he yanked me off the counter, apologizing as he shoved that gorgeous…” she stopped, opening her eyes when she realized that she was quickly turning the story into an auditory fantasy. Clearing her throat, she started from where she left off. “He pushed me up against the wall and fucked me so… intensely, it was hard to stand afterward. I mean, I actually couldn’t stand, if memory serves. I collapsed to the ground and just… let the orgasm he’d given me, flow through me like a damn tidal wave.”
Donna couldn’t stop looking at her, and John was grinning and nodding.
“Yeah,” she said, nodding at both. “It was… really… really good.”
“Fuck, I’ll bet,” Donna said. “What happened after? He probably felt bad.”
Jessie nodded. “He fucked me until he came, and God, Donna, there was so much of it! That poor, pent-up man.” She sighed, shaking her head and refocusing.
“Erin had come inside and saw what had happened. Don freaked out and ran upstairs, and I went with Erin to the bathroom.”
She took another bite and swallowed it down with some OJ.
“I made her go out and distract Dexter until I could calm Don down. I told him I knew he couldn’t help it and that I liked it, and stuff like that. I don’t remember all that I said, but he was calmed down in the end. So… we finished out the party and we started all fooling around in the den.”
Donna nodded, John taking a drink and eating more bacon.
“When I was fucking Dex, and you two were screwing around with Don, I told Dexter what had happened. At the time, he seemed to enjoy it. It was a poor choice on my part to confess my sins while we were fucking. Later, he told me that he took it that I was only saying it to be kinky. He didn’t realize that I was actually trying to tell him it was real and confess my sins to him. At that point, I still didn’t think it was any big deal, and to tell you the truth, I still don’t. I mean, yeah, Don fucked me, but I pushed him to that point and Dexter said it was okay for me to push him. Plus, it was only like a couple of minutes at the most, hardly even qualifying as sex.”
“I can see why you and Dex had to talk,” Donna said.
Jessie nodded. “All I was seeing during my confession was my boyfriend being more and more turned on, and so, in the heat of the moment, asked him if he was okay with me doing it again. He apparently thought I meant telling him kinky stories when we fucked and said yes. So… thinking that he was okay with it, I went and fucked Don again.”
John got a concerned look on his face and glanced at Donna, obviously guessing what had happened next.
Jessie sighed. “We moved over to the hallway where we could watch the fun, and he fucked me up against the wall.”
She sighed, thinking back to the state she’d been in, how fun it had been. Briefly closing her eyes, she took a deep breath and continued.
“After he… filled me up with another load of cum, John saw the state I was in. He came over, obviously thinking that since Dex was okay with his own dad fucking me, that it was okay for him too, and fucked me up against the same wall.”
“Goddamnit,” John said. “Jess…”
She shook her head. “I let you John. Come on, you know I came again while we were in that hallway. Plus, you’re not a rapist, and not unstoppable.”
John nodded. “You’re right, though. Exactly. I thought it was open season. I mean, I got excited and figured I should ask Dex, but I mean… you were fucking his dad where he could actually see you. I thought it was just… orgy time.”
She smiled and clasped his hand comfortingly for a few seconds. “Honey, please don’t think you did anything wrong. I enjoyed it. I really did! It’s just… we were wrong. Dexter and his dad had a talk, and his dad admitted that he felt bad about using me when I was his son’s girlfriend and not his. That’s when Dex figured out that I’d been telling the truth. He came over and I told him everything that happened.”
She immediately noticed the change in their expressions and waved her hand to quiet their unspoken concerns. “We talked it out though, and we’re going to be okay.”
John sighed, shaking his head. “Jess, I’m so sorry,” he said. Donna put her hand on John’s, treating him kindly for once, and then reached over and clasped Jessie’s. “I really… really fucked up.”
“John, look at me,” Jessie said. “If Dexter had been okay with it, it would have been fine. I loved being able to finally let you have me a little bit. But, unfortunately, it’s not okay with my boyfriend, so we shouldn’t do that again.”
He nodded. “I completely understand,” he said. “I hope I didn’t mess anything up with you guys.”
She shook her head. “No, like I said, Dexter and I are good. We’re going to keep talking and working things out.” She smiled, thinking about the revelation this morning. “He told me earlier that he loved me, like for real loved me.”
Donna smiled, as did John. “Goddamn that’s good to hear,” he said. “I wouldn’t be able to live with myself if I caused you guys to split up.”
She smiled. “Thank you for being such a good guy,” she said. “For what it’s worth, I really, really liked it when you fucked me up against the wall.”
He smiled. “Thanks. I’m sure it was just the excitement of the situation. I know I don’t have much to work with but that’s beside the point. I’ll behave myself from now on.”
She smirked. “Well, let’s not go that far. He just said no more sex. “Go back to your relationship with him before you guys had sex,” or something like that,” she said, imitating Dexter. “If you want to grope and manhandle me in the mornings, I’m sure it will be okay.”
He laughed at that, and then stood up, coming over and hugging her. After a few seconds, he stood and playfully shoved his cock toward her face, but then backed away and sat back down.
Jessie smiled, watching as he leaned over and kissed his girlfriend.
“Don’t worry Jessie,” Donna said. “I’ll punish him for his transgressions.”
Giggling, Jessie shook her head. “I don’t think you can punish someone like him,” she pointed out.
“Well, you could be nice to me,” he said, grinning widely.
She snickered, having to agree with his assessment. A few moments later, she finished breakfast, smiling as John took her plate and headed to the sink with it.
That evening, Dexter came back over after a long day at work. They ordered some Chinese food and stayed in. Oddly, John and Donna didn’t come out of their room and didn’t sound like they were fooling around, but she figured it was just from all the revelations that had happened that morning.