I let go of her hips and she sighed. Then she rolled over, still on my chest, and pulled her legs back almost to her full tits. I felt Amie’s hands take hold of my cock and gently guide me into Beth’s tight ass. She held me firmly and I gave a thrust, pushing hard against the tight opening, feeling resistance before popping through. Beth gasped, and I felt a couple of inches slide into her.
“Oh shit. Stop, stop!” She cried out.
I held her still, letting her get accustomed to me.
“Fuck, that hurts,” she groaned. She breathed deeply. “Ok, slowly now.”
I pulled back a hair, and pushed forward again. “Stop!”
I held perfectly still. It was a bit of a strain, because I was holding her up by the hips, and if I let go, she’d be skewered.
“Amie, get some lube from the bedside,” Beth asked her friend. “Hurry.”
As Amie made a dash for our bedroom, I tried to calm my sexy, but sore, little teenager. “We don’t have to do this now. Hell, we don’t have to do it at all.”
“No. I can do this. I’ll be damned if you can screw everyone else’s ass, and not mine,” she insisted.
“This wasn’t how it was supposed to be,” I told her, kissing her cheek.
“You think? You weren’t supposed to tear my ass in half, leaving me a screaming, helpless invalid.” She teased, giggling, then groaning as she settled just a bit down my cock. She turned her face and looked at me, wide eyed, then gave a little nod.
“Slowly,” she whispered urgently.
I lowered her just a bit more, and felt when we’d reached our limit, and her ass was clinging too tight to make any more progress.
“Is that almost all of it?” she asked.
How could I tell her it was less than half? As I was about to break the news, Amie finally showed up with bottle in hand.
“What the fuck, Ames? That took forever!” Beth hissed.
“I’m sorry, but there was an uncovered cock in there I just had to have a little taste of.” She looked suitable ashamed.
“You are such a fucking cock slut. Now help me before I’m ruined.”
“Lift her up a little,” Amie told me.
My arms were really feeling it but I managed. If Beth would just let go of her legs, it would have been a lot easier. “Should I pull out?”
“No!” Beth growled. “I don’t know if I could ever get it in there again.”
Amie got the exposed part of my cock well lubed up, and I lowered Beth a bit, feeling the immediate difference. I was able to lift her up more easily the second time, and I felt more of the cool lube just below my buried cock head. Holding Beth still, I pushed up with my hips, gaining more ground, then pulled back even further. I could feel my cock almost come out, the head barely lodged inside of my sweet little roommate. Amie came to the rescue, rubbing even more lube on us, and when I lowered Beth, I sank a good half-way into her.
“Are you Ok?” I asked
“God, that’s so much better. It feels tight, but it doesn’t hurt. Try some more.”
I carefully pressed into her, pushing in and out, working my way deeper, inch by inch. Amie continued to help, her hand on my cock, feeding me into her best friend’s tight butt-hole. It took a while but I finally felt her ass settle all the way down as the last of my cock filled her.
“That’s it,” I told her.
Beth groaned. “God, I can’t believe you’re in my ass.”
I held her still, while she got used to me. That was too much a temptation for Amie who leaned down and pressed her lips against Beth’s open, exposed pussy. I could feel her chin pressed against my cock.
“Oh, my God,” Beth gasped, “Oh God, Ames, that’s it!”
I nudged my cock in and out of her, as much as I could from where I was, while Amie tamed her. She was driving Beth crazy, and I was happy to be along for the ride. Beth’s moans and groans grew more insistent, and her hands reached down to hold Amie’s face against her. I could feel Amie’s fingers through the thin walls of Beth’s pussy, and found I was able to fuck her butt more completely, sliding in and out of her for at least half my length, her tightness and her complete abandon driving me crazy.
I turned her face to mine, and thrust my tongue into her mouth, thrusting harder into her. She was breathing hard, through her nose, and moaning into my mouth. When she came she almost bit off my tongue, screaming into my mouth. Her mouth became slack, and I probed her mouth deeply with my tongue, fucking her even harder.
“God, that looks so amazing,” I heard Amie say.
I looked down and saw our friend was sitting up, her hand still working away at Beth’s young pussy. I reached out and pulled the back cushion off the couch, making a little more room. I rolled with Beth, staying buried in her virgin ass, until we were both on our sides. I lifted the teenager’s top leg to get a little more leverage, and began to fuck her tight ass for real. She gasped on each full stroke, while I pounded her hard.
“God, that’s good Jack, you’re fucking my ass so good.”
I was, and I was feeling the impending undeniable need to come inside of her. “I’m going to come for you, beautiful,” I told her softly.
“Come for me. Come in my ass. Do it,” she gasped, pushing back on each stroke. I peeked over her shoulder, and watched Amie kneel beside the couch and lean forward to kiss my sweet young roommate.
With a groan I emptied my load in her ass, feeling a burning fire pulse down the length of my cock, as I sprayed her continuously, burst after burst filling her. I was breathing hard, gasping, as my hips finally slowed and then stopped, still completely sheathed.
Amie smiled. “That was incredible.”
Beth giggled. “You should try it from this side. I won’t be able to sit for a week.”
“I didn’t hurt you, did I?” I asked, worried that I might have gone a little too far. Even with the lube, it was a thorough ass pounding. Especially for her first time.
“Of course you hurt me, you jerk. You stuck a fucking baseball bat up my ass and reamed me senseless with it,” she growled. I eased my cock out of her butt, and she sighed when I finally was out.
“I’m sorry, baby, but it felt so incredible.” I explained, nervous that I might have really pushed things too far at the end.
“God, I’m not. I don’t know if I ever came that hard. We are SO going to be doing that again, once I’ve recovered. Debbie’s going to have to see this.” Then she turned to her friend. “This was all your idea, you know. Making him rape my ass. I swear I’m going to cheer him on when he splits you open like that.”
Amie leaned in and kissed her again. “It may kill me, but when we play again, I’ll let him take that cherry, if you’ll help.” Then she leaned over Beth and kissed me. “Would you like that, Jack? Would you fuck my virgin ass, and make me cry for you? Stick that beast of a cock so far up my butt that I can taste it?”