“So, what do you want to do? Not what do you wish, but what do you think we can do?” She didn’t sound angry or irritated; she was just discussing things honestly.
I lost myself for a couple of minutes in the sensation of my cock sliding in and out of her tight, nearly virginal pussy. “How often can you spend the night?”
“How often do you think?” She still wasn’t very responsive to my actions, allowing me to have sex with her, but not really into it.
My arms were getting tired, and I leaned down and kissed her. Then I rolled over and pulled her on top of me. She guided me back in and was soon laying with her full weight on me, and I caressed her back as I rolled my hips, sliding in and out of her.
“How often?” She repeated.
“I… If I had a place for you, I wish you could stay here.”
She kissed my shoulder, nibbling at the skin. “I don’t need much room.” Now I could feel the rolling of her hips as she responded to my thrusts.
“Would you? Would you live here with us?” I was holding her tightly while I drove in and out of her a little more forcefully.
“I don’t know. It depends on a lot of things. I guess you’ll just have to make me an offer.” She pushed up on her arms and sat upright. She was so pretty, her young full breasts so firm. I pulled her down so I could lick and suck on first one nipple, then the other, while she rocked back and forth on my cock.
She sat upright again, and then climbed off for a second as she turned around facing the end of the bed. She put her hands on my legs just above my knees, and lowered herself back onto my cock. I held her sweet ass cheeks and thrust up into her as she bounced up and down on my cock.
I reached between her cheeks and let my fingertips run from where my cock entered her, back along the crevice of her cheeks across her little butthole.
“Mmmmm, now that’s naughty” she moaned.
I let my thumb linger on her ass, nudging the tip into her.
“Sorry, baby, but that’s not on the menu… yet.” She laughed, clenching her butt cheeks tightly.
“God you feel so great.” I told her. “Lean forward.”
She obliged getting on her hands and knees, and I pulled my legs out and got behind her. I ran my cock up and down the crack of her ass, pulling the head across her asshole, before I pressed it back inside her. I was feeling pretty close to coming. I grabbed her hips and fucked her as hard and fast as I could, the slap of our skin echoing in the room. There was something about the view of her narrow waist swelling out with the curve of her hips, the heart shape of her full ass, and vision of my cock disappearing into her, that made my blood burn.
“I’m gonna come baby,” I gasped.
“Come in me,” she whispered back, and I did, thrusting deeply, filling her with my seed.
I collapsed beside her. She got up and came back from the bathroom a few minutes later with a warm washcloth. She wiped me clean, threw the washcloth in the general direction of the bathroom, and climbed back in the bed. I followed her back up and lay beside her pulling her to my side. We were quiet for a couple of minutes.
“I’m so confused, Jack.” She finally broke the silence.
“Me too.” I closed my eyes and thought about what I’d gotten into, letting my hand caress her shoulder.
I came close to falling asleep. But the creak of the door opening jolted my eyes open. I looked up to find Debbie walking across the room. She came to my side of the bed.
“Jack.” she whispered, standing there trembling, wearing only a long t-shirt.
“What’s wrong baby.” I wasn’t sure if Beth was awake or asleep, and I spoke softly.
“I’m… I’m so embarrassed, Jack. I… I can’t stand being alone up there. I’m sorry. Can I please sleep in here? I’ll sleep on the floor.” She couldn’t even lift her eyes. “Please.”
Beth was awake. I felt her lift herself up on her side, and look across at Debbie.
Debbie looked up and saw Beth watching her. She started crying. “I’m sorry, Beth. I’m sorry, I’ll go.” But she just stood there shaking and sobbing.
I rolled my legs off the side of the bed, and took Debbie’s hands in mine. “I’m sorry Debbie, but it’s not my decision to make. Tonight, this is Beth’s room.” I stood, and threw on my robe, and headed for the kitchen to get a drink, and to see if they could maybe work this out on their own.
I’m sure a lot of people might think I was a coward trying to take the easy way out. Maybe they’d be right.
After getting a drink, I settled onto the couch in the living room. I could hear the murmur of voices behind the closed door. I thought I’d wait until one of them left, or they came and got me. I almost fell back to sleep, before Beth called me from the doorway. “Come on back.”
Debbie looked a lot better, she’d cleaned up her face, and she was sitting on one side of the bed. Beth was standing on the other. After a few seconds of silence Beth spoke. “Well? Go ahead.” Her words were clearly directed towards Debbie.
Debbie looked up. “Beth says I can sleep here, but you decide where everyone sleeps. I really don’t mind sleeping on the floor. Really.”
I walked over to Beth. “You don’t have to do this.”
“I’ve been thinking, Jack. Here’s the deal. I’m leaving myself wide open. But Debbie agrees. You should belong to both of us. Both. Anytime she’s with you, I can be there too, and whenever you’re with me, she’s welcome. But it’s our decision. If you share your bed with one of us, you have to be willing to share it with both of us. Can you live with that?”
“I’d love to. I guess this means nobody else. No Cathy, no Karen.”
“No. I don’t think so. Not for now. But it’s our decision. If we say no Karen, then it’s no Karen. But for now, as long as each night is spent with us, I think we can deal with the rest of it. Let’s just not go adding another pile of lovers to your harem just yet, Ok?” Beth didn’t sound quite as confident the more she spoke.
I climbed into the bed, and faced Debbie. “What about you?”