Judy went rigid and held her breath as I pushed a second juice-coated digit inside her butthole, gently sinking to the second knuckle into her tight hot rectum. As soon as I started sawing my fingers in her ass, she began yelping in pleasure, trembling all over. The increased stimulation from the anal fingering and a final assault of whirling licks on her clit pushed her over the edge.
“Ooooohhh! Oooh Greeeeg!”
She came spectacularly. A flood of pussy juices bathed my face as Judy’s virgin little asshole clenched and unclenched around my fingers, making me giddy with the preview of what it might feel like to be buried inside that warm constricting passage. When Judy descended from her peak I was still licking her scrumptious girl-cum off my lips and her labia, glorying in the taste of that sweet reward for the pleasure I had just given her.
Cooing, Judy rolled off me and came to lie by my side, snuggling into me as she traced soft kisses all over my face, tasting her own run-off nectar. “Mmmh okay, it’s official now,” she purred as she hugged me, pressing her tits tighter against my chest, smiling impishly, “you are indeed a great pussy-licker!”
“Thanks, but I sort of cheated,” I replied nuzzling her slender neck, “if you consider fingering your butthole cheating, that is.”
Judy chuckled and gave me a long wet kiss. As she sucked my lips into her soft mouth, her fingers reached down to my cock, encircling me and fisting me to full hardness.
“Yeah, you did exploit my weak spot, but that counts as a plus,” she said huskily. “It made me cum so hard to have my pussy licked and my ass fingered at the same time. I loved it, Greg.”
“I noticed,” I snickered, wrapping my arms around her and reaching my hungry hands to her beautiful plump ass. Grabbing those round juicy globes in my palms, I kneaded her curvy booty and sank my fingers in her fleshy buttcheeks. “You came almost immediately when I started pumping your ass,” I murmured, “and your tiny little asshole felt so tight, Judy. So fucking tight…”
She grinned and jacked my hard meat faster as my fingers explored her crevice and circled her pliant rosebud, eliciting a contented sigh from her when I poked a fingertip inside her rubbery anal ring. It drove me wild with desire to see how sensitive Judy’s asshole was, how she seemed to melt when I teased her forbidden little hole.
“You like fingering my ass? You like playing with my naughty asshole? Because I do,” she purred, her lips brushing against mine, her breath labored. “It drives me crazy to have my butthole fingered… I can’t wait to feel your cock deep in my ass, stretching my tight virgin asshole.”
My shaft throbbed in Judy’s hand and my heart beat faster at her words. I could hardly believe the reality of it, but I was overjoyed that Judy was so willing to let me fuck her amazing ass. The steel hardness of my member pulsing in her tiny fist let her know exactly how I felt about her idea.
“You want my ass, Greg?” she whispered in my ear, making me shiver in excitement. She was rubbing her warm slender body against mine, writhing and panting as I slowly masturbated her virgin anus. “Tell me, baby, aaahh! Tell me how much you like my ass… I want to hear you say how badly you want to fuck me in my tiny little asshole oooh!”
“Yes! Fuck yes,” I grunted as her slender hand flew all along my rock-hard pole, “I want to fuck your beautiful ass so bad, Judy. You have the roundest, juiciest, most perfect bubble-butt ever and I love it and I wanna fuck it like crazy!”
“I want that too, I want you to take my anal cherry and pump my ass full of your creamy cum,” she panted, grinding her leaking pussy against my thigh. I sank my index deeper into her butthole and eased in a second digit, making Judy mewl into my ear. “Ooohh fuck yes! Finger me deep, baby, open my ass for your big cock!”
Our mouths met in a languid soulkiss as Judy rolled on top of me, my fingers still buried in her accepting sphincter. We made out sloppily for a bit while she rocked her hips, grinding her dripping pussy on my hardness. Her butt-ring was clamping erratically around my probing digits, announcing her rushing climax, when Judy suddenly unclasped her mouth from mine and reached her hand to my cock, wrapping her slender fingers around my thick meat.
“Time to lube you up,” she smiled, raising her hips and pointing my raging erection to her sopping wet cunt.
I grunted in pleasure as my bloated glans slipped inside Judy’s hot little slit. I watched in awe as her splayed pussy lips descended along my pole, our bodies joining and our crotches coming closer and closer. Her slippery vaginal walls opened around my invading thickness and enveloped inch after inch of my dick in her warm velvety snugness, until I was buried to the hilt inside her.
“Aahhh Judy, your pussy is so tight and wet” I panted as she sat still on my pole, breathing raggedly. Her slick walls were squeezing me deliciously as her pussy reshaped itself around my embedded cock.
“Ooooh this feels so good Greg, you’re so big inside me,” Judy mewled. She was biting her full lips as she straddled my lap, impaled on my shaft, her hands resting on my chest for balance as she rotated her hips, stirring her tight honey pot with my length. Her eyes were closed as she enjoyed the feel of my cock filling her pussy and my fingers masturbating her asshole.
After a while, gasping and moaning, Judy started riding me cowgirl style. At first she barely let an inch or two of my cock slide out of her gushing clingy pussy as she lifted herself off me, but soon she got into a smooth bouncing motion.
Even when she raised her plump ass up and my nectar-glossy shaft briefly vacated her sweet cunt hole, I kept sawing my ass-probing digits into her tight rubbery butt-ring. I sank them all the way into her virgin anus whenever her puffy dripping labia were pressed against my abdomen and my raging boner was sheathed completely inside her pussy. Judy moaned out loud then, and so did I, crazed by the sensation of touching my own cock with my butt-pumping fingers through the thin membrane separating her tight holes.
The only thing that beat the amazing feel of Judy’s tight gushing slit gliding along my shaft was the sight of her rapt face as we fucked. She was breathtaking, this sweet beautiful girl riding me like there was no tomorrow. I was too overcome with affection and pleasure to do anything but moan and buck my hips up into her pussy, clapping against her descending hips, but the image of Judy with her mouth open in a perfect O, her eyes closed, her head thrown back and her dark ponytail swinging around etched itself in my mind indelibly. She was the one, I knew it without a doubt.
With her perky tits swaying mouth-wateringly before my eyes in time with her bouncing rhythm, it was impossible for me not to attack those pink hard nipples tracing circles in the air. Sitting up, pushing my cock even deeper inside Judy’s snug pussy, I took her erect puffy buds in my mouth in turn, sucking and nibbling and licking them, worshiping her boobs as I fingered her ass faster and she fucked herself ever more wildly on my throbbing erection.