Beads of nervous sweat appeared on Tyler’s forehead as Michelle’s sensuous mewls of anticipation started morphing into tenser and distinctly less delighted vocalizations. An unbidden and quite bitter flash of irony struck Tyler as he realized that all the double anal porn he and Michelle had watched lately was now turning out to be perfectly useless when it came to actually doing the deed in real life. Despite his sister’s naughty willingness and weird determination, it started dawning on Tyler that he may seriously have been right all along in considering that whole thing a bad idea. As if in answer to his doubts though, Michelle’s trembling voice resounded in the room.
“Uuhh Ty… Push harder, get that dildo in there! Pleeease, push it in!”
Sighing and clenching his jaw, still viscerally bound to answer his sister’s pleading call, Tyler removed his free hand from its comfy perch on top of the big soft mound of Michelle’s plump asscheek and brought it closer to her straining bootyhole. Ever so gently, he used his thumb to pull the tautly dilated edge of her butt-ring further apart while at the same time adjusting the dildo into a better position for penetration, but he could only pry his sister’s fully stuffed backdoor open another fraction of an inch.
Much to Tyler’s surprise though, despite the fact that he was feeling like an inept burglar attempting to pick a complex lock with the wrong tools, it worked. The little widening he had induced in Michelle’s already dick-jammed bootyhole, combined with the pressure he was applying on the cock-shaped toy and the way he was angling it, not to mention the unimpeachable quality of his prepping and lubing ministrations on her delicate anus, unexpectedly did the trick.
All of a sudden, as Tyler’s eyes widened in awe, the glans-like tip of the dildo punched through, slipping between his swollen shaft and the stretched out rim of Michelle’s butt-ring to wedge itself inside her anus alongside his ass-cramming dong. Instantly Michelle stiffened and took a sharp intake of breath, soon followed by a squeal of blatant discomfort.
“Fuck! Ooowwhh shiiit! Nnghh! Fuuuuck!”
“Mimi…” Tyler mumbled with undisguised concern, inviting her and all but begging her to ask him to stop. His words were slow and heavy as his heartbeat suddenly accelerated, the whirling mixture of horniness and disquiet inside him finally coalescing into a knot of real fear for his little sister’s well-being.
“N-n-noohh, Ty… I c-c-can d-d-do it…” Michelle stammered in a strained whimpering voice, fighting not to yell out her evident pain, yet stubbornly refusing to accept the not-so-veiled plea in Tyler’s voice to abort that perilous mission right there and then.
Clinging to her quirky fixation to keep up with Gabby’s anal skills, Michelle brought a hand to her clit and started rubbing away frenetically in a last ditch effort to soothe the stinging, burning jolts of discomfort radiating from her dangerously overstuffed sphincter with some much needed clitoral comfort. Meanwhile, as much as Tyler looked for signs of improvement, Michelle’s scrunched up brow and suffering facial expression didn’t change at all. Nevertheless, she kept stuttering encouragements to her brother, desperately trying to deny the fact that she had barely taken the tip of the dildo up her ass and she was already hurting way past the limit of her endurance.
“D-don’t stop, Ty… I… I want… Ooowwhh shiiit! I know I c-c-can… Do this… Ooowhh fuck! Uughh, it hurts!”
No sooner had those pain-laced words left Michelle’s mouth that Tyler was already removing the plastic toy from her struggling bootyhole. An involuntary but very genuine sigh of relief erupted from Michelle’s mouth as soon as the plastic toy was unjammed from her anus. Immediately, her tender sphincter stopped hurting and a general sense of restored comfort washed over her now that her little orifice was no longer being forced to take more than it could handle.
Breathing easily again now that he could see the suffering painted on Michelle’s cute visage melting away while her whole tense body started relaxing, Tyler went as far as withdrawing the significant portion of his dong that was already buried inside her sweet ass. He knew he didn’t have to do it, but he felt like he actually did. And it wasn’t just a way to err on the side of caution either; first and foremost, it was a self-punishing measure that Tyler chose to inflict upon himself to atone for letting his mindless buttlust blind him so completely that he got sloppy in the fulfillment of what he had always considered to be his core duty in life: to protect and take care of his sister.
“I can’t do this, Mimi. I just can’t,” Tyler stated with lucid finality over the slurping, lube-wet sound of his fat glans popping out of her pulsating pink hineyhole. “There’s no way I’m gonna hurt you. No way in hell. I’m sorry, Mimi… I should have known better.”
Already confused by the sudden transition from painful, straining fullness to total disappointing emptiness in her ass, Michelle panted and blinked and gathered her wits for a couple of hazy seconds as she processed her brother’s guilt-ridden words. Then, rolling onto her side to face him, Michelle spoke with a kind, bright smile on her face, all the while extending her arms to grab Tyler’s hands and hold them in hers.
“Ty, no! Nononono, don’t be sorry and don’t be sad,” Michelle said urgently as she pulled her big brother closer, until he climbed into bed too and was lying on his side facing her. “You don’t have to be sorry, it’s okay. I’m okay, really.”
“Are you sure, Mimi?” Tyler said, his arms automatically wrapping Michelle in a loving embrace even as his brow remained furrowed with worry and self-reproach. “I’m serious. Are you hurt or something? Tell me, please…”
“I’m fine, Ty. It was pretty bad for a moment, yeah, but when you took the dildo out the pain went away immediately. My butthole is alright, don’t worry,” Michelle concluded with a smile that turned into a chuckle as she added: “You didn’t have to pull your dick out too, though. We both know that I can take one cock in my ass, at least! And it’s a huge one too!”
Unable to stay broody when it was clear that nothing bad had really happened and his little sis was indeed okay, Tyler laughed with relief along with Michelle, but not before having let out a liberating sigh and having tightened his bear hug around her voluptuous body. The next thing he knew, Michelle was resting her delicate hands on the sides of his face and kissing him deeply, one of her smooth thighs meanwhile draped over his leg, her petite frame pressed so close to him that her big round boobs were squashed against his muscular torso. Given their snuggling face to face position, Tyler’s swollen dong ended up poking right against Michelle’s shaved pussy mound as they lost themselves in their soulkiss, their lips and tongues dancing happily while they moaned into each other’s smooching mouth.