One afternoon, while they were playing Overwatch and exchanging their latest ranting speculations and predictions about Game of Thrones, Tyler concluded his observations by stating: “You know what? At the end of the day, all the wars and tragedies and deaths in the story would never have happened at all if only Jaime and Cersei had done anal instead of regular sex.”
After letting out a bright chuckle, Michelle nodded and replied with enthusiasm: “Yeah, I agree one hundred percent: anal is the answer! You could even say that the whole incest thing isn’t really that big a deal if it’s only limited to anal… Right?” she tentatively added, still facing the screen but looking at Tyler from the corner of her eye to catch his reactions.
“Well, a lot of religious girls do it in the butt to stay virgins, and to them anal doesn’t really count as ‘having sex’, so…” Tyler replied, casting a quick sideways glance at Michelle before concluding: “I guess you could apply that whole virginity loophole to a brother and sister scenario too.”
“Honestly, I don’t really see anything wrong with brother and sister doing anal…” Michelle slowly said, her heart beating faster with every word that tumbled out of her mouth. “Do you, Ty?”
“No, Mimi,” Tyler answered, his tone calm and steady even though he felt his breathing getting labored and his cock getting stiffer by the second. “I don’t think there’s anything wrong with that at all.”
“Well, not as long as they love each other, of course!” Michelle quickly added, tittering and grinning playfully as she turned to look at Tyler, who was already facing her way and smiling at her.
“Yeah, of course,” he agreed. “That would make a lot of sense, actually.”
For a couple of intense seconds, Michelle and Tyler’s gazes remained locked together, while all the unsaid things they still couldn’t bring themselves to let out in the open seemed to silently filter through to one another. Then the sounds of shooting from the screen called them back to their game and the moment was gone. But not their unspoken understanding.
The culmination of the siblings’ constant back and forth butt-centric flirtations coincided with the last days of the school year. With just a few days to go before graduation and with their final grades already nicely secured, Michelle and Tyler were thinking of nothing but each other.
After all their talk of anal on top of the complicit looks they cast back and forth all the time, with Michelle making more and more naughty remarks about Tyler’s big dick while Tyler increased his devoted and always well-received fondling of Michelle’s majestic booty, the siblings were working each other up to such a point that just being in the same room together made them rabidly aroused. Unsurprisingly, their respective masturbatory sessions now only revolved around the one shared fantasy that gave both of them the most incredible orgasms: the mind-blowingly hot thought of Tyler’s huge dick vigorously pounding Michelle’s big juicy ass.
Desperately horny for her brother but still unable to openly declare her hottest and most forbidden desires to him, Michelle finally decided to create a situation where something could actually happen between the two of them almost by accident, thus bypassing the last vestiges of uncertainty and restraint that still somehow affected the both of them. Knowing that Tyler was just as willing and excited as she was, thrilled by his undisguised lust for her plump ass and thus certain that he wouldn’t turn down a real chance to get better acquainted with her booty if he was only given the right opportunity, Michelle opted for a final flirtatious move that mixed apparent innocence and open sexiness: sunbathing by the pool in her skimpiest and sexiest bikini.
As a rule, Michelle was quite the indoorsy type and had never really liked lying still under the scorching sun, which was a good thing, considering how fair-skinned she was. Of course, since the house they were currently living in had a nice pool in the backyard, she did go outside to join Tyler whenever he was in the pool, taking full advantage of the chance to touch her brother’s muscular body and be touched by him in turn as they laughed and splashed and horsed around in the water. On top of that, whenever Tyler did laps in the pool, Michelle was always glad to rest in the shaded patio and kick back on a recliner, where she could relax and tease her pussy by rubbing her thighs together while she watched her hunky brother swim back and forth, her eyes fixed on his powerful arms and strong back as they emerged from the water in time with the rhythmic tempo of his breaststroke.
Knowing his sister as well as he did, Tyler sensed that something was up the very moment Michelle announced that she was going outside to catch some rays. That wasn’t like her at all, he thought. Then, when he followed her out and saw her sitting on the edge of a recliner intent on carefully lathering the alabaster skin of her legs with sunscreen lotion, Tyler couldn’t help but grin to himself. As the situation became clearer in his mind so did his meaty dick grow harder and thicker in his pants, his eyes all the while mesmerized by the sexy way in which Michelle’s minimal bikini top covered pretty much only her nipples while leaving her round jugs almost completely naked, not to mention how her skimpy thong literally disappeared between her luscious asscheeks, devoured by the fleshy plumpness of her big epic booty. As if her choice of bathing attire wasn’t an obvious enough invitation already, the flirtatious pout that Michelle’s adopted when she rolled on her tummy and asked him to put some lotion on her back confirmed Tyler’s initial suspicions: sunbathing had nothing to do with what Michelle was really trying to do there, and he was very glad about it.
Of course, much to their mutual delight, on that first day of ‘sunbathing’ Tyler took great care to spend a lot of time massaging and kneading and caressing Michelle’s fabulously round bubble-butt. Still, that was all that happen that afternoon. Even though Tyler’s monstrously swollen boner bulged obscenely in his pants, poking and prodding against Michelle’s soft curvy body, they just joked about it as usual while Tyler took reverent care of his little sister’s booty with his hands
On the second day of ‘sunbathing’ things spiced up a bit. For starters, Tyler suggested that he should straddle Michelle’s shapely thighs while she lay down on her tummy to better massage her back. She agreed with a big enthusiastic smile, as Tyler expected. A good fifteen minutes into the devoted, lustful massage he was giving to his sister’s big beautiful ass, Tyler further turned up the heat. Letting go of her majestic booty with his right hand, he seamlessly shifted his fingers ever deeper into Michelle’s generous butt-cleavage. Receiving only a breathless moaning “Yeees!” and a clear approving nod from his sister, Tyler parted her plump globes wider apart, pulled aside the thong wedged in her pillowy cleft and let his long forefinger venture further into Michelle’s asscrack, until he made contact with the gummy, rosy little knot of her sphincter.
While his left continued kneading her meaty buns and his trunks-trapped boner kept stubbornly pressing against the jiggly lower half of her round buttcheeks, Tyler slowly and deliberately began tracing circles all around the rim of Michelle’s tiny asshole, getting it slick with lotion and pliant to his gentle poking touch. Maddened by the feel of her brother’s digit caressing her sensitive rosebud as much as Tyler was floored by the fact that he was not only finally seeing his sister’s insanely cute asshole but actually touching it, Michelle panted and mewled like a sexy kitten as Tyler stared at her pink little sphincter in utter adoration, rubbing his slippery fingertip around the soft puckered rim of her forbidden orifice all the while.
Utterly stunned with arousal, Tyler lost track of time as he caressed and tickled his sister’s receptive butt-ring with gentle circular motions of his fingertip, coaxing long humming purrs of approval from a squirming, equally hyper excited Michelle. As if in a trance, Tyler watched himself cupping his little sister’s ample buttcheeks in his greedy palms and then holding them nicely spread so that he could use both forefingers and even his thumbs to play with her mesmerizing pink asshole. His breathing caught in his throat as he delicately pulled the soft rubbery edges of her sphincter apart, making Michelle’s lovely hineyhole gape slightly and wink invitingly at him.
Tyler’s right forefinger was trembling visibly as it approached his sister’s twitching and barely open orifice, until it slipped past her elastic butt-ring and slid inside the velvety, insanely tight warmth of her anus. Holding his breath and disbelieving what his eyes were seeing, Tyler couldn’t help but smile broadly as he let his digit sink ever so slowly into Michelle’s steamy orifice. When his forefinger was buried inside her tiny butthole to the second knuckle, Tyler paused to glory in the naughty feel of Michelle’s anal muscles gripping and pulsating with horniness around his digit as she squealed softly and panted in sexy delight.
At that point Tyler finally exhaled and blinked before he started carefully masturbating his sister’s forbidden passage with slow back and forth pumping motions. The fact that he had finally managed to somehow get inside Michelle’s ass, even if merely with his finger and not really pushing particularly deep into her virginally snug chute either, was still more than enough to completely blow away Tyler’s already lust-inflamed mind. Fingering his sister’s adorable pink butthole and feeling her warm little orifice squeezing and clinging and nibbling all around his slowly sawing digit was no doubt the most erotic experience of Tyler’s life, and of Michelle’s as well.