We rolled around on my bed, her on top, then me again, then Evie once more as she came at least three more times on my rock hard cock. I returned to the top position and began pounding her relentlessly as she stared into my eyes. I grabbed her feet and placed them onto my shoulders making her groan in pleasure before she cried out “Oh god yes, Dale. Fuck me and make me cum WITH you. Fill me with your cum, claim my pussy as yours and yours alone!”
I rose to the occasion and released my cum as it plastered the back wall of her pussy with my huge load of cream. Evie screamed and kissed me deeply as her body shook violently as she came with me. Once we had both come down I gently let her feet back down and then rolled us over to keep my weight off of her.
“Christ almighty, you are incredible! I can’t believe my little brother is the best fuck ever!” She kissed me several times before laying her head on my chest and just resting. Every few moments I could feel her pussy clutching at my cock as another convulsion passed through her body. After a particularly strong one she lifted her head up and said, “I can’t believe it but I just came again! Not a big one or anything like that, just a nice soft shake as my body reacted to your huge cock pulsing inside of me!” She kissed me once more and then settled back into my arms as we just enjoyed the sensation of being so incredibly close.
I thought I heard something but Evie kissed me when my cock lurched inside of her once more and I forgot about the sound. Moments later I heard Amber scream out, “OH my god Eva! Not with him! Not with your shit head brother, oh my god! Oh Jesus how could you?”
Evie rolled her face towards her friend and gave her a grin before saying, “You ought to know, he’s the best fuck I’ve ever had!”
“No, last night you got the best fuck you’ve ever had! I watched some of it! I got fucked pretty good as well! But shit girlfriend, do you have to fuck your own brother so soon after that? I couldn’t fuck today if I wanted to!”
I looked up at my sister and said with a sad face, “Shit, she only got fucked ‘pretty good’. That can ruin a guy’s image.”
“Shut up dick head, Spiderman fucked me quite well last night. But god Eva, you’ve reached a new low here.” Amber glared at me before pleading with my sister, “Please come to your senses Eva and stop fucking him and get off of your albatross!”
Evie kept saying Amber’s name while Amber spoke and finally she literally shouted out a super loud and extremely long “AAAAAMMMMMBBBEEEERRRRRRRRRRRRR!” Her friend stopped talking and just looked at my sister with disgust written all over her face. “It’s about time you shut up! Look over there,” and she pointed to my costume hanging from the hook. “Guess who didn’t stay dressed as Hop-a-long for very long?”
“Shit, anybody can get that costume and hang it on a hook! That just shows he heard about us and got creative!”
Evie grinned at me before giving me a quick kiss. “Amber, take a look at your forearm for just a minute. Good, now take a look at this,” and she slowly lifted up and nearly off of my granite shaft. An audible gasp was heard as Evie neared my tip. “Satisfied now? Ahhhhhhhhh fuck he’s so good,” she said as her pussy slipped back over my shaft.
I noticed the sudden change in Evie’s demeanor and she suddenly cried out, “Oh fuck, what a turn on that was! Oh god Dale, I’m cumming again! Oh fuck, oh shitshitshitshit!” My sister’s hips began pounding her pussy on and off of me rapidly as she came again but then she slowed way down until she finally stopped all movement.
“HO … LY … SHIT!” Amber softly said as she walked around the bed and stared at our connection from where our feet were intertwined. Evie leaned way forward which pulled her nearly all the way off of me and Amber cried out, “Oh my god, you are him!” In a flash she was naked on the bed beside us pleading, “Oh god, Eva, get off of him so I can ride his wonderful cock again! Oh god I need it so bad!”
Evie looked at her and said, “But you said you couldn’t fuck today if you wanted to! Sounds like you want to which means I don’t need to move because you can’t fuck!”
“Selfish bitch!” Amber cried out as she pulled on Evie’s arm.
Evie laughed at her saying “Hey girlfriend, I’m just yanking your chain, and it was really wound up tight! I’m good for now. Besides I want to watch him in action as I was busy up until just before you keeled over last night.” As she spoke she lifted her delectable ass off of me and gave me one last kiss before moving away so Amber could climb onto me.
“Hey sexy!” I said as she positioned herself over my cock.
She looked into my eyes and snarled, “You’d better be HIM! If you are just a fake, I’m going to cut this fuck-stick off of you!”
“I’m not worried, and for your information I have a LOG, not a stick!”
Evie laughed out loud at that and Amber gave me another glare before she slowly lowered her body down onto my flagpole of a cock. “Oooohhhhh fuck,” she groaned as she bottomed out, our pelvic bones crushing together. Amber and Evie looked at each other and she said in a wavering voice, “Oh gosh, he certainly FEELS like the guy from last night!”
Amber lifted up and pushed herself back down twice before she looked at me in awe saying, “Oh my god YOU ARE HIM! Oh god Dale, I’m sorry I doubted you!” Amber was moving rapidly as she worked herself towards her first huge climax of the day. I grasped her face and pulled her lips to mine, our kiss reaching heights of passion I had never reached before! All through our kiss she was moaning in joy as she took my cock to her core over and over. My hands had found her tits and were tweaking her sensitive nipples when she clung tightly to me, her face by the crook of my neck as she cried out, “God yes, I’m cumming! Oh fuck Dale you’re making me cum!” Then she kissed me again and didn’t stop until her orgasm was over!
Once her climax had waned I rolled us over, finally taking the on top position with the love/lust of my life! I instantly started powering my cock hard into her, eventually lifting her ass in my hands and fucking her with her head and shoulders on the bed while her legs hung limply in the air behind me. She was groaning out “Oh … oh god yes … ooof … oh … god … oh … OH … OH … Fuck ME Dale, SHIT GOD OH, OH, OH, OH, OH, OH, OH, OH, OH, OHOHOHOHOHOH GAWDDDDDDDDDD!” My hands looped around her thighs and were pulling her pussy into me hard as my hips rapidly slammed into her gash like a jack hammer. Amber’s eyes bulged out as she screamed in orgasmic bliss again, her hands gripping the sheets by her sides.
Once more she suddenly fell limp as I held her body by her thighs and ass, her head arms and feet lying on the bed unmoving. Her eyes opened as tiny slits and she moaned out, “Ohhhhhh Dallllllle!” before struggling to pull her torso up until she could hug me and smother me in kisses. “You are TOTALLY the guy! I love how you make me cum so hard, but why were you looking for me at the party?”
“Yeah brother dear, why … her?”
I ignored Evie’s implications as I said, “Amber, you know that we really got along whenever Evie wasn’t there. The only time you acted mean to me was when she was there.”
“I’m so sorry, Dale” she said.
“Oh gosh, was I really such a bitch to you?” Evie asked.
“Yup,” I said to my sister before turning my attention back to Amber. “I’ve always wanted to date you but sis made sure I couldn’t even have a chance to prove myself. So I thought maybe I could get into the party and you’d be in the, um, party mood …”
“Wild and horny?” Amber volunteered.
“Well … yeah. Anyway I guess my suit got quite a bit of attention and I was lucky to find you. I never thought it would turn out so good with you, but I’m sure glad it did.”
I had lowered her body to the bed and was slowly fucking into her as we talked. Our talk was peppered with our moans and groans and soon she said, “Please, Dale, fill me with cum!”
“As you wish, my sweet Elvira!” I grabbed her legs and spread them as wide as they would go as I speared her body with my rampant cock. Amber grabbed her legs by my hands and pulled her legs back until they were touching the bed, still spread wide. My cock was dragging hard across her g-spot and her eyes rolled back in her head as she soon began to shake.
“Oh my god you wonderful man, I’m going to cum again! Oh god fuck me Dale, fuck me! Harder! Pound that cock into me hard and give me … ooooohhhhhhh goddddddd … your cummmmmmmm!” My balls churned and when my cock lurched its first time she screamed “Oh god damn I’m fucking cummmmmmminggggg Dale! Do it! Give me your cum! I WANT IT ALL! OH FUCKING HELL!” My hips were slamming into her pussy, which she had totally opened for me, her hands still spreading her legs wide and I used mine to brace myself as I pounded into her, my cock spraying my cum deeply within her.
Our mutual climaxes finished and I leaned down to gently kiss her. Amber would have none of that as she pulled my face tight against hers and her tongue forced its way down my throat. She eventually broke off the kiss with many small pecks on my lips before she looked into my eyes and said, “You have truly fucked the shit out of me, and I LOVE IT! I need to rest and then I want to do it again, if you want to.”
I just gave her a thrust with my hips as Evie said, “That was the most incredible thing I have ever seen! Why didn’t I know my brother was such an orgasm maker?”
Leaning over and giving her a quick tongue kiss I said, “Because you were too busy telling me to go to hell to notice!”
“True and to the point,” she said. “I am forever sorry and hope you won’t deprive me of your wonderful cock!”
We spent the next four hours switching back and forth as I would fuck one of them to two or three orgasms and then switch to the other to give her the same treatment. Each of them begged me for my cum and I didn’t hold back, filling them over and over with my spunk. Amber was riding my cock as Evie lay beside us recovering when Amber looked down into my eyes and said, “Dale, would you please do me the honor and marry me!”
Evie and I both exclaimed “WHAT!”
“Think about it. We really do get along well, like you said and I know we have similar interests besides sex. And we are definitely compatible in the sack! Plus I love Eva dearly and would never deprive her of your incredible cock! You could fuck her any time you wanted to and nobody would be the wiser!”
“Sounds good to me,” Evie said.
“That’s a big step, especially for a LITTLE high school boy!” I said as both of them punched my arms.
“I didn’t say you needed to do it today, but after you get out of school would be nice. Just think about it.”
The subject was dropped but I knew all of us were thinking about it. Around 4:00 PM I was laying on my back with Evie riding my cock at a leisurely pace while Amber was riding my face as my tongue worked wonders on her clit. I heard a car door open and close and tensed at the thought our folks would be home early, but then heard it drive off and returned to my task at hand of getting both girls off at the same time.