“Did you enjoy yourself tonight?” he asked.
“Very much!” Lori said as Lisa nodded.
He undressed for them slowly and felt their eyes traveling over his body.
The moment he was naked, they each raised a hand to get him to join them. He knelt comfortably on the end of the bed and gestured for them to come to him.
“Take me in your mouths,” he commanded, and their smiles widened. They loved it when he asserted his claim over them.
They slid over the sheets to bring their faces closer to his stiffening cock.
Lisa dipped her face lower and sucked one of Ben’s balls into her mouth and swept her tongue over its surface. While she did this, she gently scratched his other testicle with her nails. He immediately moaned as the sensation was exquisite and pushed his cock toward its full strength.
Not to be outdone, Lori sucked the head of his cock into her mouth, locking her lips around the ridge of the glans. She stroked the head with her tongue and Ben’s moans increased as did his rigidity. Lori’s fingers curled around his shaft to gently stroke the hot flesh.
“That feels so good!” Ben rumbled as he gazed down at the two gorgeous redheads.
He wanted to please them at the same time, so he made them both lie back on the bed side by side. He gazed down at their beauty in awe. They smiled back at him with love in their eyes.
“Bring your knees up to your chests,” he ordered, and they giggled excitedly as they rushed to comply.
He spotted the gleam of the jeweled tops of their butt plugs and he gently pressed on them, rocking them from side to side.
Lori moaned but Lisa’s eyes threatened to roll back. He smiled as he loved how differently they responded to similar stimuli. He dipped his face down and worshipped Lori’s pussy with his lips and tongue as she cried out, clinging to his head.
While he did this, he rubbed Lisa’s pussy with firm hand, finally plunging a thick finger into her depths as she moaned in bliss.
When they were both very wet he pulled back and watched their dazed eyes lock onto his.
“I want Lori to ride my cock as Lisa straddles my face,” he said, and they quickly moved so he could lie between them. The moment he was ready, Lori swung her leg over his torso and positioned herself over his cock. She rubbed it against her wet pussy then dropped her weight against it. It took several tries but eventually she had all of him inside her. Her body trembled at the fullness she was experiencing.
Lisa moved up and settled her pussy down over his mouth, and he drank deeply from her as his hand found her anal plug to tug on it. She cried out and rocked her hips to keep pace with his tongue.
Lori was lifting and dropping on his cock, but he could tell she was beginning to reach her limit. He slid a hand down her body and rubbed his thumb over her clit, and she suddenly clamped down on his cock as her body spasmed through an intense orgasm. She clung to his hand, pressing it harder against herself.
Playing with Lisa’s butt toy was pushing her to her limits as well. She twitched strongly as Ben felt her body begin to shake through her release.
He was a little surprised by how quickly both had crested as he was only halfway there.
Lori pulled herself from his cock and dropped onto the bed next to him, panting.
Lisa eased herself down his body and stretched out over him to smile at him. “That was delicious!” she purred. She wiggled her body against him, feeling his erection pressing up between her legs. She sighed as she felt the heat.
“Ben, I’m ready,” she said.
He raised an eyebrow. “Ready?” Lori was watching her sister curiously too.
“I-I want you in my ass,” Lisa gushed. Lori squeaked in surprise.
Ben gave the beauty resting on his chest a cautious look. “I’m much larger than the plugs you’ve been wearing.”
She grinned bashfully. “The one I have in now is much larger than the one you originally bought for me. I’ve been training myself with larger sizes.”
Ben realized this explained why Lisa’s reaction had been more dramatic than her sister’s when he’d played with the jeweled tops of their plugs.
“You didn’t tell me!” Lori said to her sister in surprise.
Lisa looked at her. “I know you aren’t as much into this as I am. It’s okay.”
Lori still seemed a little put off by her sister’s secrecy.
“You kept this a secret from your sister?” Ben asked as he held Lisa’s gaze. She dipped her eyes submissively.
“I’m sorry. I didn’t mean any harm,” Lisa said contritely.
Ben cupped her cheek with his palm. “Of course, you didn’t, but you’re going to need her help with his so it would have been good to keep her in the loop?”
Lisa looked at him in confusion. “I-I’ll need her help?”
Ben nodded and saw he had the curious attention of both sisters. He sighed. “I’m not going to give details, or names, but from my previous experience with a first-timer, the real thing was nothing like the… practice experience the person had. They needed loving support of a friend as well as my efforts to make it pleasurable. We don’t have to do this now. You can take some time to think on it.”
“No, Ben. I’ve psyched myself up to do this and I really, really want to do it!” Lisa begged. She looked to Lori. “Will you help me?” she asked desperately.
“Of course!” Lori insisted.
The women turned their expectant gazes on Ben and he nodded. He quickly rolled Lisa off onto the mattress then rolled her back under him on her stomach. He pressed her to the bed under him. She gasped and closed her eyes as she felt his hard cock pressing between her ass cheeks.
“Fuck!” she sighed.
Lori was watching Ben with wide eyes as he turned his face to her.
“Get the bottle of lube from the drawer in the bedside table, please,” he asked.
As she slipped off the bed to collect the lube, Ben slid down Lisa’s body, kissing her skin until he was facing her ass. He kissed her cheeks and she gasped.
“Let’s see what you’ve got hidden back here,” Ben said as he played with the disc pressed up against her puckered orifice.
Lisa made a cute little grunt noise as he slipped his fingers around the top and began to tug gently.
“Ah! Oooh!” she cooed, then bit her lip as she looked back at him with need in her eyes.
Ben, and Lori who’d joined him, watched in fascination as Lisa’s sphincter slowly stretched wider and wider to accommodate the shiny bulb of the plug. He glanced at the sister as he was having some trouble pulling it out. He didn’t want to force it.
“Maybe you could add a little lube to this?” he said quietly.
Lori nodded and spread a little of the slick stuff against the edges of Lisa’s widened orifice.
“AH! Oh god!” Lisa gasped.
Ben allowed the plug to settle back in and tugged it out to get the lube to spread evenly across its surface. Then he began to pull it a little further out with each tug.
“OoooO!” Lisa cooed again.
Finally, Ben got the widest part of the plug past the ring of muscle, and it quickly slipped down the other side, forcing it out.
“FUCK!” Lisa gasped as her body trembled.
Lori looked at the width of the plug and looked at the girth of Ben’s cock. They seemed roughly the same. She locked eyes with Ben. “She seems to have the size right.”
Ben nodded. “But the plug lets the orifice relax once it’s inside. A cock doesn’t.”
Lori’s eyes widened. “Right. Oh!” she exclaimed as she looked up into her sister’s desperate eyes.
Ben pushed himself up onto his knees as he straddled Lisa’s legs. “Lori, lube me well.”
Lori grinned as she scooped some of the slick stuff out and stroked it onto his cock. He pulled her to him and kissed her deeply as she pumped his cock to maximum rigidity. He pulled back and Lori watched his mouth hungrily.
“Spread some on Lisa’s asshole,” Ben said, his voice rough with lust.
Lori grinned and pressed a glob over Lisa’s twitching rosebud.
“Ahh!” the prone woman gasped at the sensation.
Ben smiled at Lisa. “Are you sure you want this?”
“Yesss!” Lisa gasped as her sister wiped the excess lube from her hand onto her sister’s butt cheeks.
Ben looked to Lori. “You’re going to guide my cock in, so hold the head against her asshole.”
Lori’s eyes widened and she reached between them as Ben braced himself over Lisa’s body. She gripped his cock and pointed the head down slightly until the head settled into place directly over her sphincter. “Okay. You’re on target,” she said with a nervous smile.
“Lisa, you need to relax as much as you can,” Ben said as he began to apply pressure.
“Oh fuck!” Lisa grunted quietly.
“If it becomes too much for you let us know,” Ben said.
She nodded and Ben felt her struggling to relax her ass. He applied pressure in slight pulses until the head of his cock was suddenly accepted inside.
“OHHH! Fuck!” Lisa gasped.
Ben held still and waited for her trembling to calm. When she seemed to have accepted that he began pushing again.
“Ohhh! Oh, oh, shit, oh… god!” Lisa moaned quietly.
Ben looked at Lori and nodded to her and gestured with his head for her to move up to Lisa’s face. She released her grip on his cock and stretched out on the bed next to her sister until she could see her expression. “Are you okay, Lisa?” Lori asked. Lisa’s eyes were glassy and her face was red.
Ben managed to sink an inch then another into the woman’s ass then he held still to let her adjust to this.
“It… it’s nothing… like the… plug,” Lisa managed to say.
Ben frowned as he shared a glance with Lori. “Should I pull out?”
“No! Please, no. It’s so intense, but I want more,” Lisa begged. She began to pant.
Lori was watching her sister with wide eyes.
Ben drew out an inch and pushed in three.
“OOOOOOOHHHH! SO FUCKING FULL!” Lisa moaned loudly.
Ben didn’t bother asking if she wanted him out. She’d tell him when she’d had enough. He began to slowly stroke in and out.
“Fuck! Oh yes! Ahhh!” Lisa exclaimed as she writhed under his body.